Arguments and practices to refute: Animal protection claims are weak and difficult to succeed, for reasons: (1) Circus cruelty to animals is protested but circus viewers are still more (2) conservation movements

Rebuttal of views and practices: Animal protection claims are already weak and difficult to succeed, for reasons:

(1) Circus cruelty to animals was protested but the circus was still watched by many people

(2) Animal protection organizations take in stray cats and dogs because of low funding and have to deal with them humanely

(3) Overcorrection, divided into some genres, stray dogs, wild animals, it is difficult to reach consensus between each other.

【Inspection ability】

Comprehensive analytical capabilities

【Examination Question】

The rebuttal topic can be regarded as a comprehensive analysis topic in general, and can be carried out in accordance with the idea of "putting forward views, re-analyzing, and grasping implementation". The focus of this rebuttal question is to discuss the necessity and positive significance of animal protection, and three points of view can be given around the stem to refute it. The expression and implementation links should be simplified as much as possible, and can be taken at the beginning and end of the sentence.

Question 1: "Circus cruelty to animals protested but circus still watched by more people"

This quote is about the circus's repeated prohibitions, and we can refute it from the comparison of the two different situations before the circus and the present, especially to highlight the hard work of animal protectors for this change in the circus.

Question 2: "Animal Protection Organizations Take In Stray Cats and Dogs Because of Low Funding And Have to Deal With Them Humanely"

This sentence is about some animal protection acts that do not have a humanitarian spirit, and we can fully argue from the necessity of this measure and the humanitarianism embodied at present, especially the rationality of the current treatment method.

Review point 3: "Overcorrection, divided into some genres, stray dogs, wild animals, it is difficult to reach consensus with each other." ”

This sentence argues for the problem of the animal protection genre. If the principles upheld are correct, then it is certain that it is helpful and beneficial to the collective, to the masses, and it is inevitable that a small number of private interests will be offended in a timely manner. At the same time, speaking of principles is not inflexible and impersonal.

Therefore, the idea of this question can be determined as: how to implement the opening statement - harmonious coexistence - humane protection - precise force

【Parsing example】

I believe that animal protection is not only of very important long-term significance, but also of very urgent practical significance; in my opinion, the demands of this group reflect the voice of the masses, and it is bound to be a great success. Below I will refute the stem view from the following three aspects.

First, circus performances reflect the harmony between humans and animals. On the one hand, the sad scenes of those "tamers holding long whips or long sticks in their hands and hitting the performance without pain, small animals looking at the audience with tears in their eyes", "black bears kneeling on the ground to pray for food", "elephants change their feet and their skin festers" have ceased to exist, and now the circus needs to obtain domestication certificates, transportation certificates, and performance certificates for the corresponding management departments of forestry, public security, culture and other corresponding management departments to have business qualifications, and for tamed animals, cages and chains are no longer used to imprison beasts. It's about giving them room to run, plenty of food, and reasonable breaks... These advances are due to the repeated protests of animal protection volunteers, thanks to the repeated reports of animal protection activists, animal protection appeals have taken a sonorous and powerful step on the road to success; on the other hand, the circus itself includes animal performances and acrobatic performances, and there is no problem in watching circus that embodies traditional Chinese culture, but you can feel the agility and wisdom of animals from the performance.

Second, the humanitarian solution of stray cats and dogs is the humane protection of stray animals. On the one hand, stray cats and dogs are generally abandoned by their owners, lost on their own and formed in the wild, and they will have a large number of births, induce injuries, disturb people, and spread diseases because they are not managed. Some time ago, the widely discussed incident of "stray dogs bite when they see people, 1 person dies of rabies, and 3 people are seriously injured" is to show us that the work of protecting stray animals is imminent and urgent. At present, the stray cat and dog shelter center established by local funding and combined with the support of dog lovers clearly stipulates that cats and dogs that are still unclaimed after the expiration of the period will be harmlessly treated by setting up requirements, rules and deadlines for adoption. This practice of adhering to the humanitarian spirit profoundly reflects the rationality and necessity of the demands of animal protection personnel, which not only solves the problem of stray cats and dogs hurting people to a certain extent, but also promotes the construction of a harmonious society; on the other hand, the government departments have comprehensively supported the protection of animals through financial support and preferential tax policies for rescue stations, and the media and literary and art workers have spoken out for small animals and created a public opinion atmosphere for the protection of animals. The Voluntary Group for the Protection of Animals is no longer a team with scarce funds and staff, but an organization with the help of countless caring people and the strong support of government departments for steady development.

Third, the precise division of labor for animals can help the protection of animals to be fully implemented. At present, animal protection workers are not only facing the problem of wild animals being abused and endangered, but also worrying about the protection problems of cats, puppies, fish, birds, which are living animals, and the effect of such precision is more significant than that of the previous extensive casting of nets. When a qinghai animal protection association found that someone ate the national second-level protected animal Huangyu when brushing vibrato, he immediately reported it, and took the initiative to speak out on Weibo and Douyin, which solved the doubts in the hearts of the vast number of melon-eating masses and popularized professional knowledge. Through the protection of sub-fields and sub-animal groups, we can help us to find problems more efficiently, faster and more accurately and respond to problems, and we can also imperceptibly gather more like-minded people on the long road of animal protection through professional knowledge, and help the cause of animal protection continue to advance steadily.

The work of protecting animals is not achieved overnight, let alone because of one or two problems in front of it to deny its success, only the joint efforts of the whole society can truly return animals to freedom and the environment to balance.