We often say that money is not brought by birth, and death is not brought away, and the most important thing in a person's life is family affection. However, how many people have lost their dignity and conscience in the face of money, they have left their family affection behind, trampled on blood kinship for the sake of so-called interests, and some people even spared no effort to hurt innocent relatives for money, and even brothers and sisters will go to court.
First, because of the compensation of 500,000 yuan, the sister took her sister to court
Su Zirui, who is only in her 20s this year, don't look at her age, but she is already a remarried woman, she has a lot of ups and downs over the years, talking about sad things is a mixture of tastes, the person she is closest to in life is her sister Su Zikun, no matter what she thinks, she will tell her sister, but what she never expected is that one day her sister will take her money and not give, but she had to sue her own sister in court.
The sister accused her sister in court of being too cruel, having no family in her eyes, and not having her sister. Hearing her sister's scolding, her sister bluntly said that she was also forced by her sister to do this, what is going on?
It turned out that four years ago, when her sister Su Zirui's ex-husband was at work, an accident occurred in the factory, and the factory compensated her with a compensation, in order to avoid her mother-in-law's difficulties, she put this compensation in the hands of her sister Su Zikun.
Two years ago she remarried again, did not expect that a year ago her current husband Yu Haodong was hospitalized because of illness and urgently needed a surgical fee, she wanted to find her sister to get back the 500,000 yuan, but her sister did not agree, resulting in her husband's condition delay. Because these 500,000 sisters did not have less disputes, in her opinion, the sister just wanted to take the 500,000 for herself.
The sister said that her sister was too unconscionable to speak, and the reason why she did not give her sister this money was that she was afraid that her sister's money would fall into the hands of unscrupulous people, and she was protecting her sister's money. But the sister retorted that the person with bad intentions was the sister. The two sisters each said that they had their own reasons and began to argue.
Su Zikun said that this sister of hers, when she was young, she had no opinion, saying that it was good to hear it was kind, and saying that it was ugly was stupid, because this reason was not less used, including her suing herself in court this time, it must have been instigated, and this person is her sister's husband Yu Haodong.
The sister believes that this Yu Haodong has a bad character, and originally pursued his sister in a stalking manner, and tried every means to marry her to the 500,000 yuan in his sister's hand. Sure enough, after they got married, my sister chased after her every day for money. Because she knew that her sister was going through a rough ride, she couldn't watch her get hurt again. In order to protect her sister, she can only be this evil person. She hoped that the judge would persuade her sister and reject her request.
But the sister's kind sister did not appreciate it, she said that Yu Haodong was not the way her sister imagined, it was her sister who was confusing the public.
Second, why the sister gave the money to the sister for safekeeping, the two told the truth
It turned out that after Su Zirui got the 500,000 yuan of compensation, her ex-in-laws changed their minds, saying that she had only been married to their family for a long time, and had not given birth to a son and a half daughter to their family, and they were not eligible to take the 500,000 yuan, and the former in-laws also scolded her for being a broom star, killed their only precious son, and demanded that she compensate them.
At that time, the words of the former in-laws were engraved on her heart like a knife, and if she did not give the money to the second elder, they would find her all kinds of trouble, and also go to her unit to make trouble, and she quit her job. Even more egregiously, the in-laws also went to the bank to beg someone to transfer the property in her name to theirs. The sister saw that this would not work, so she proposed to let her sister put the 500,000 yuan to her, as long as the money was not on her, the ex-in-laws would have nothing to do with her. She heard that this idea was good, so she agreed.
The sister also said that her sister's ex-in-laws were so hateful that they wanted to force their sister to die, and they saw nothing but money. At that time, her sister encountered difficulties, and she, as a sister, must give her the master, so her sister transferred the 500,000 to herself.
The sister submitted the transfer certificate in court, as well as the chat history of the two WeChat. My sister said in the chat: "You transferred 500,000 to me, I will keep it for you for the time being, your in-laws can't find my head, even if you find it, I will not hand over the money." My sister also said that when your in-laws don't come to make trouble, I will transfer the money back to you, and you can tell me at any time with the money.
The sister admitted that there was indeed such a thing, but the sister remarried with Yu Haodong without telling the family, and she accused her sister of not treating them as relatives again. But the sister explained that she did not dare to tell her family that during the time when she and Yu Haodong were in a relationship, her sister and her parents broke up them for various reasons, making her almost lose her relatives.
The sister said that they did oppose their sister's association with Yu Haodong, because they went to inquire very early, Yu Haodong's character was particularly bad, he was a little when he went to school, and he was expelled from school before graduating from high school. The most infuriating thing is that when he was dating his sister, he had not yet broken up with his ex-girlfriend. She also wants her sister to get married and start a family as soon as possible, but only if she finds an honest and reliable person, because her sister really can't afford any harm. Therefore, their whole family is not optimistic about Yu Haodong.
Third, the sister refused to give the sister money, saying that it was: to protect the sister from harm
About the matter of asking for 500,000 yuan, the sister said that because Yu Haodong accidentally fell, took the medicine has not been good, when he went to the hospital for examination, the doctor said that the spleen rupture needed surgery, when the couple could not get this money, she wanted to find her sister to get back the 500,000, but the sister refused.
The sister said that if her sister was sick and hospitalized, she would take the money out without saying a word, that is, it was no problem to use her own money, but this happened to Yu Haodong, and the character of others was not good, and she could not trust him. Hearing this made his sister angry, and Yu Haodong did not pretend to be ill.
It turned out that after the sister looked for her, the sister privately contacted Too Haodong, probably his operation fee was 80,000 yuan, the two discussed a good one to take out 40,000, at that time Yu Haodong agreed to it. However, on the day of the operation, she did not send money to the hospital because Yu Haodong first lost faith in her, and he did not borrow a penny. She believes that Yu Haodong may not have borrowed money at all, she was helping her sister save money.
What makes the sister happy is that half a year ago Yu Haodong's body recovered, the two planned to buy a house, she looked at several real estate, and finally hit one, probably needed a down payment of 400,000 yuan, she looked for her sister to return the 500,000 yuan, but the sister still did not agree to give her money, this time she really can't stand it, she found her sister to quarrel, but it still didn't help.
It is reasonable to say that the sister buying a house is a legitimate need, and the sister should support it. But the sister said that this house should not be bought by the sister, it should be Yu Haodong, when he first married his sister, he was not even prepared for the marriage house, and now he uses his sister's money to buy a house, and he also requires the names of the two of them to be written on the house book, which makes the money she wanted to give to her sister interrupted again. She believes that Yu Haodong is a white wolf with empty gloves, and her sister is foolishly willing to be deceived by him, but she has a mirror in her heart, in case the two buy a house and the man files for divorce, the property is half of one person, so she resolutely does not let Yu Haodong's plot succeed.
But the sister said that the name written in the house book was proposed by her, the two discussed well, the down payment she came out, and then the loan husband to bear, this house is equivalent to their husband and wife to buy together. Hearing this, my sister was anxious, because Yu Haodong had never done a serious eight-hundred-hundred-year job since he married his sister, he had no money and no income, how could he pay the mortgage, and then Yu Haodong remembered that his sister's money was not a day or two.
It turned out that after her sister got married, Yu Haodong had asked her sister for 100,000 yuan, saying that she had a new car, and at that time she did not agree, and her brother-in-law scolded her on the phone, such a man really did not deserve her sister to pay so much for him, but unfortunately her sister did not listen to advice.
But the sister said unconvincedly that three months ago, she had heard from her sister-in-law that her sister had bought a house, that she had heard her sister cry before, that she could not even pay the childcare fee for the kindergarten, and that she suspected that her sister had bought the house with her own compensation. In this regard, the sister admitted that the house she bought was hard saved by the two of them, and she had never touched her sister's 500,000 yuan, and her sister said that it really hurt her heart.
It turned out that in order to protect her sister's 500,000 yuan, the sister did not think of using her sister's money, she also specially applied for an account, and submitted the account and passbook in court, so that the sister was suddenly stunned.
Finally, under the court judgment, the sister returned the 500,000 yuan to the sister within 10 days, seeing this result, netizens talked about it, some people said that the sister was too stupid, the sister was a good person, and some people said that there was a day when the sister regretted it.
Sentiment Analysis:
Seeing this result, I am also like everyone else, it is not worth it for this sister, they all say that sisterly affection is not worth mentioning in front of money, but in this world, there are really people who are willing to be an evil person for sisterhood. Therefore, the people who initially questioned her sister's behavior understood her sister's bitter heart. But family affection belongs to family affection, and in the face of the law, it is really the law that does not tolerate affection. Although the final verdict was fair and reasonable, everyone really carried a heart for this sister.
1. The sister has the right to return the money to the sister
In fact, the mainland civil code stipulates that the owner has the right to possess, function, benefit and dispose of his own real or movable property according to law, and no one can arbitrarily occupy the property of others, and the sister also submitted the transfer records and chat records to the sister, and the sister also admitted that the sister gave her 500,000 for safekeeping.
And the sister also promised in the WeChat chat that the sister can get the money back at any time, but when the sister asks for the money, the sister will not return it for various reasons. As the owner of 500,000 yuan, the sister has the right to ask the sister to return the money, and the sister has no right to interfere in the handling of this money. Therefore, the sister's request was justified and reasonable, and the sister had no reason to refuse.
2. The sister should not swallow the 500,000 compensation alone
As the saying goes, money is a bottomless sea that drowns personality, conscience, and truth.
The sisters argued in court over the 500,000 yuan, and the sisters tried to protect their sister from harm, but they were hurting the two elderly people who had lost their only son. The sister's ex-husband died, as an in-laws, the son is gone, equivalent to losing the security of dependence and old-age care, the factory compensation of 500,000 yuan should have half of the two old people, but it was appropriated by these two sisters.
McLee once said: A good heart is the best law. But the sister accused her sister's ex-in-laws of "they have nothing but money in their eyes", but she did not think that her sister was also such a person, she seemed to be protecting her sister, but invisibly did her sister's accomplice, despite the sadness and isolation of the two old people, transferred 500,000 compensation for her sister, seemingly playing a sisterly love, in fact, behind what we see is a battle for compensation that has lost its conscience, which is too ruined. So behind the family affection can sometimes let us see the greed of human nature.
3. There is a cycle of cause and effect, and man cannot extinguish his conscience
It is often said that good deeds do not counteract evil deeds, and bad deeds cannot cover up good deeds, and each act has its own retribution. It is the selfishness and inhumanity of the two that will make their sisters go to court. The sister's refusal to give 500,000 yuan in compensation to her in-laws shows that she is short-sighted and has no sympathy and filial piety for the elderly. Only to let her remarry and find a man who is not doing the right thing, this may be the inevitable result of the cycle of cause and effect, and the unhappiness of retribution.
There is a saying that when you do good deeds, you do not seek retribution, but only for peace of mind. Suffering losses is not necessarily a blessing, but it is all atonement for sins. I hope that these two sisters can be kind and human, and when defending their own interests and safeguarding their family affection, they will not destroy their conscience as human beings for their own selfish interests!