Shang Martin, Zhang Yi, Fan Ju and Li Si, who has greater ability?
Speaking of these great powers of the Qin Kingdom, I think everyone knows them, and the following small editor will talk about their own views.
Shang Martin, Zhang Yi, Fan Ju, and Li Si were all high-ranking talents hired by Qin abroad in the middle and late Warring States period to serve as Xiangguo, all of whom were influential figures in different periods, and all of them were heroes and heavy ministers who made great contributions to the rise, prosperity, prosperity, and eventual unification of the qin state. All four of them are people with extremely high IQs and abilities, but extremely poor character. Therefore, the rise and rapid destruction of the Qin state are related to these people.
If you want to say who has the strongest ability, I think it is the martingale.
We first formulated the use of talent, contribution value, social impact three dimensions to constitute the ability value, each dimension score of 10 points, the sum of the three dimensions score is the ability value.
Among them, Shang Martin not only had the greatest influence on the Qin State, but also had a profound impact on future generations, and the centralized power system he designed has been adopted by successive dynasties, at the same time, the household registration system, the seating system, the armor protection system, and his weak people's skills are all the ruling tools of successive dynasties, and the chaotic cycle of Chinese history is closely related to this person.
Shang
Former prince of the Weiguo nobility, studied under the oniguzi, the Fa family genre. The career began in the State of Wei, when Li Wu, the master of the State of Wei, was holding a nationwide change of law, and Shang Martin learned the social practical experience of the Legalists and fled to the Qin State with the written legal code, and met qin Xiaogong who first conferred the royal way, and the filial duke did not think so, and then granted it with hegemony, filial piety and great pleasure, and immediately implemented the law of the twentyth rank of shang martingale nationwide. In the face of the Qin state, which was isolated in a corner and had a strong atmosphere of private fighting, Shang Martin used extremely ingenious methods to make the law enforceable, and immediately greatly increased the comprehensive national strength of the Qin state, proud of the West, and laid a solid foundation for the qin state's subsequent strategy of going east. At the same time, many of the laws formulated by the Shang Gong became the basis of later legal provisions, and even abolished the division of seals, and the establishment of counties and counties had a preliminary prototype in the Shang Gong Law, and it is not an exaggeration to say that the Shang Gong Law was the prototype of all the political systems in China later. According to the above analysis, I give 8 points for business talents, 9 points for contribution value, 8 points for social impact, and 25 points for ability.
The second is Li Si, who was not only the first prime minister in Chinese history, but also the mastermind behind the book burning pit Confucian incident, but also the practitioner of the Idea of the Fa, who ignored the Jiangshan Sheji for his own selfishness, and finally Sent Zhao Gao and Hu Hai to the guillotine of the Great Qin Empire.
Reese
Wei Guoren, who studied under Qi Guojixia Xueshe, was a classmate of the Fajia school, and Han Fei, another big man of the Fajia family. Li Si is a man of great talent, and this great talent just happened to meet the once-in-a-millennium Zu Long Yingzheng. After The coronation of Yingzheng, with the help of Li Si, cut off the rebellion of the Empress Dowager and Concubine Yi, and drove Lü Buwei, the great giant of Gu Ming, out of the center of power, and began the military pace of Yingzheng sweeping away Liuhe. Under the offensive of the Qin Dynasty, the Six Kingdoms were quickly overthrown, and the Qin Dynasty was able to unify the world. In the face of reunification, the Qin Dynasty, politically abolished the division of feudalism, set up counties and counties, unified writing, currency and weights and measures, set up the Qin Straight Road, opened the Spiritual Canal, and built the Great Wall, which all benefited the future generations, highlighting the Chinese nation, of course, in the cultural rush, burning books pit Confucianism, high-pressure legal policy also made the dynasty collapse in an instant. At the same time, in his later years, after the death of The First Emperor, Li Si and Zhao Gao executed the Fusu and Meng brothers who could prolong the life of the Qin Empire, which accelerated the demise of the Qin Empire, and this huge historical stain also lowered Li Si's historical evaluation. Based on the above analysis, I gave Li Sicai 8 points, contribution value 7 points, social impact 8 points, and ability value 23 points.
Again, Zhang Yi defeated the Hezhong technique with Lian Hengshu and won diplomatic space for the Qin State, but his habitual use of deception instead of sincerity won the qin state a reputation of no credibility, which was also an important reason why the Qin Empire was difficult to convince the public.
Zhang Yi
A native of wei, he studied under The Ghost Guzi (Shang Martingale's disciple), the Zongheng family genre. Zhang Yihuai did not meet, the world only knew that he had a pair of tongues that were invincible to the world, but they did not know that he also had a grand strategy of being invincible to the world. In the era of King Huiwen of Qin, the national strength of the Qin state was still in a period of rise, and the neighboring east was next to the emaciated camel wei state that was bigger than the horse, the zhao state that was arrogant after Hufu rode and shot, the chu state with a large territory, and the farther east and the rich and powerful state of Qi. In the face of the aggressive Qin state, the combined attacks of the six eastern countries again and again did not even beat it down, anyway, let the Qin state encroach on the surrounding countries step by step, so that the six eastern countries gradually became the fat meat to be slaughtered on the qin state's case board, which was Zhang Yi's strength, a sharp mouth let the million troops of the six eastern countries stop outside the Hangu Pass. According to the above analysis, I gave Zhang Zicai a score of 9, a contribution value of 7, a social impact score of 6, and a ability value of 22 points.
Fan Ju proposed a diplomatic strategy for the Qin state to attack from afar and create space for the growth of the Qin state, but these were just small cleverness, because violence and scheming alone were not enough to make a country really strong, let alone enough to make society long-term peace and stability, only a good culture and appropriate system can make a country exist healthily.
Fan Sui
The Wei people (Wei talents have all arrived in the Qin kingdom, and it is strange that they are not dead), the Zongheng family genre. When I think of Fan Ju, I think of an idiom, and I will repay you. Fan Ju was a very personality person, small-minded, with many plots and tricks, and there might not be a good opportunity for such a person in the prosperous world, but in the era of King Xiang of Qinzhuang, the times created heroes. King Xiang of Qinzhuang, who was about to enter middle age, faced the empress dowager and uncle who were in charge of the government at that time, and there was no way to vent his enthusiasm, fan Ju's arrival made King ZhuangXiang see hope, and some operations made the empress dowager return the government to the king of Qin, and the uncle Wei Ran was also driven away, and began the pace of qin zhuang Xiang wang's attack on the central plains. In terms of diplomacy, Fan Ju took gold and silver jewelry to buy through the government of the Six Kingdoms of the East, the military god of war Bai Qiren blocked the killing, the Buddha blocked the killing of The Buddha, and the pit killing of 400,000 Zhao troops made the world panic for the rest of the day, and the Six Eastern Kingdoms faced the Qin army and swept away the chaos, but just when King Zhuang Xiang would sweep the world and complete the great unification, Fan Ju was jealous of Bai Qi, so that King Zhuang Xiang was jealous of Bai Qi and eventually let him cut himself, and the dissimilarity of the Qin Dynasty finally blocked the footsteps of the Qin army to unify the world. Based on the above analysis, I gave Fan Ju talent 7 points, contribution value scored 6 points, social impact scored 6 points, ability value 19 points.
According to the above analysis, the ability of Shang Martingale > Li Si > Zhang Yi > Fan Sui.
The above is the xiaobian's view of several Qin state bigwigs. If you have different views, please leave a message to discuss!