Poetry hunting every day
Pay attention to the reading dogs
Yesterday, I introduced the "Song Ci Ranking List" compiled by contemporary Scholars such as Wang Zhaopeng, and the top 10 rankings of them really made many netizens dissatisfied. For example, some friends think that the ranking of Xin Abandoned Disease words is too low, the artistic deviation of "Man Jiang Hong", and Su Shi's "Jiang Chengzi", Xin Abandoned Disease's "Qingyu Case" are not on the list, and so on.
In fact, the "Song Ci Ranking List" is not the first time to cause dissatisfaction among netizens, before this there is also a "Tang Poetry Ranking List", of which the top 10 have also caused controversy among netizens. And look at the top 10 of this "Tang Poetry Ranking":
"Tang Poetry Ranking" No. 1: Cui Hao,"Yellow Crane Tower"
"Tang Poetry Ranking" No. 2: Wang Wei "Send Yuan Er Envoy Anxi"
"Tang Poetry Ranking" No. 3: Wang Zhizhuo", "Liangzhou Words"
No. 4 in the "Tang Poetry Rankings": Wang Zhizhuo,"Climbing the Stork and Bird Building"
5th place in the "Tang Poetry Ranking": Du Fu's "Dengyue Yang Lou"
6th place in "Tang Poetry Ranking": Liu Zongyuan", "Dengliuzhou City Tower"
7th place in "Tang Poetry Ranking": Meng Haoran,"Lindongting Lake"
No. 8 in the List of Tang Poems: Chang Jian's "Zen Temple after the Title of Broken Mountain Temple"
Ranked 9th in the "Ranking of Tang Poems": Wang Bo,"SendIng Du Shaofu to Ren Shu Prefecture"
10th in the List of Tang Poems: Li Bai's "Shu Dao Difficulty"
These 10 poems are indeed excellent works in Tang poems, but then again, there are wonderful works of Tang poems that are both artistic and influential, and 10 poems are simply not enough to choose. For example, Du Fu's "Ascending to the Heights" is also known as the "First Seventh Law of Ancient and Modern Times", Li Bai's "Quiet Night Thoughts" can be described as the most widely spread sentence in thousands of years, etc., but these masterpieces have not entered the top 10!
The most astonishing thing is the two peak poems of Tang poetry, Saint Du Fu and Li Bai, the poet Xian, with only one poem each entering the top 10. Among them, Du Fu's "Dengyue Yang Lou" ranked 5th, and Li Bai's was somewhat outrageous, choosing "Shu Dao Difficulty" to rank 10th! Many netizens said: Dissatisfied!
"
Shu Dao Difficulty (Excerpt)
Don Lee Bai
……
Silkworm bushes and fish, how dazed to open the country!
Erlai is forty-eight thousand years old, and is not inhabited by Qin Saitong.
Xidang Taibai has a bird path, which can cross the peak of Emei.
The landslides and mountains destroy the heroes to death,
Then the ladder stone stacks are hooked together.
There are six dragons on the high standard of the sun,
There is a reversal of the river.
The flight of the Yellow Crane is still not passable,
The apes are anxious to climb the aid.
Green mud and plate, 100 steps and nine folds haunting rocks.
He sighed on his back and sat with his hands caressed
In fact, Li Bai's "Shu Dao Difficulty" is indeed a masterpiece of ancient times, describing the strange thrills of Shu Dao with rich imagination, and the brushwork has fluctuated and is unpredictable, which is amazing.
But Li Bai has written many poems, and there are many excellent works, such as "Quiet Night Thoughts", "Sending Meng Haoran to guangling", "Will Enter the Wine", etc. in terms of art and influence, and they have not lost "Shu Dao Difficulty", let alone his so-called top 9!
Therefore, such a ranking is really unbelievable, and some netizens shouted on Douban: Zhao Ritian was the first to disobey! What do you think? Leave a message to discuss!