Question: Is Sister You a concubine? Jia Lian secretly married Second Sister You, why did Bao Dai sympathize with her, but felt that Wang Xifeng was an evil person?
Text/Jiang Zi shushu
The next stone under the Qinggan Peak, once recorded the illusion and seal text, the moon will stone see "Stone Record"!
Rong is Hua Xihua is Rong, the former Lord of the Mengxi Hall of Mushi, rouge dyes "Dream of the Red Chamber"!
Sound energy two singers two mu, two jian wind and moon two flowers! With poetry passing on the history of stone ink, who knows the thrush zhao wind and current?
The daughter who is not married will not be surrendered, and the last days will be loyal and righteous! At the time of the first time, the name was Tong Lingyu, and the surname was originally Qin.
The source is Eryu playing Erbao, generous and elegant as a concubine, Rong Yuanning playing Yin Zhen, "胠箧", "Nanhua" continued "Zhuangzi"!
- Preface to The Book of Stones
In the story of "Dream of the Red Chamber", whether You Erjie is Jia Lian's concubine or not, the answer to this question is no, it is obvious that You Erjie is Jia Lian's wife, second room, side room, and not an ordinary concubine, and there is a lot of evidence in the original text.
First, the sixty-fifth recollection of "Dream of the Red Chamber" is called "Jia Ershe secretly married You Ershe, You Sanjie, and Liu Erlang", the ancients Yun, marrying a wife and a concubine, since it is a concubine, naturally it is not a concubine.
That is to say, Ping'er is a Yahuan, Wang Xifeng can scold and buy and sell Ping'er, but for You Erjie, Wang Xifeng cannot do this, and Feng Er'er first saw You Erjie and said a word, which also proved this.
Ping'er was busy and also came up to see the gift. Second Sister You saw that he was dressed up and had a good demeanor, and it was expected that ping'er would be Ping'er, and she quickly held it in person, only to shout: "Sister quickly rest like this, you and I are the same person." Sister Feng also got up and smiled and said, "Kill him!" The sister only had to be treated, he was originally our handmaiden. Don't do that in the future. ”
Second, Jia Lian married You Erjie, which is called "stopping his wife and remarrying", whether it is the author or all the characters in the book, mentioning this matter is the same statement.
Since the ancient way of "wanting to make Zhi faint", Jia Lian only cared about coveting the beauty of the second sister, listened to Jia Rong's words, and then in order to calculate everything, he took the clothes he had now, and stopped his wife and remarried, and yan father's jealous wife all kinds of inappropriate things were ignored.
If it is a concubine of Jia Lianna, it is a branch office, and there is no talk of "stopping the wife and remarrying", and it is not necessary to use words such as "stealing marriage" and "stealing the gong cannot be knocked".
Third Sister You said, "I also know that your wife is too difficult, and now that I have kidnapped my sister to make a second room, I can't knock on the stolen gong." I'm also going to meet grandma Phoenix to see if he's a few heads and a few hands. If everyone is good at taking peace, just stop; If there is a little bit of trouble, I have ben to take out your two cattle and yellow dog treasures beforehand, and then fight with that shrew, and then fight for their lives, it is not Counted as Yousan Aunt Grandma!"
Third, You Erjie married Jia Lian, it is Jia Zhen's marriage, because it is the nature of marriage, it is worth talking about marriage, if it is a concubine, it is purely the nature of spending money to buy, just like buying a lady, where you need to buy makeup and other things, and how to call it grandma, so that fengjie is hooked up.
The second sister is also a watery person, who has been inappropriate with her brother-in-law in the first place, and often resents zhang hua for wrongly allowing zhang hua at that time, resulting in a lifetime loss of place later, and now that Jia Lian has feelings, the brother-in-law has hired him to marry, and if he refuses, he will nod his head and agree. So the two discussed, let people see the house to play jewelry, buy makeup for the second sister and apply bed tents and other things in the new room.
The more Jia Lian looked at it, the more she loved, the more she looked at it, the happier she became, and somehow flattered these two sisters, but ordered Bao Er and others not to mention three and say two, and directly called grandma, and she also called her grandmother, and even put Sister Feng down.
Fourth, You Erjie died, Jia Mu said that Jia Lian and You ErJie were husband and wife, if it were not for Wang Xifeng's chaotic saying that You ErJie died of tuberculosis, and sent her a lot of no, it should be seriously broken and buried according to the specifications of Jia Lian's wife.
Jia Mu said, "Believe his nonsense, whoever dies of tuberculosis does not burn a sprinkle, but also seriously breaks the ground for mourning." It is not only a two-room, but also a husband and wife, stopped for five or seven days to carry out, or burned or buried on the ground. ”
In the story of "Dream of the Red Chamber", Wang Xifeng is Jia Lian's head wife, Jia Rong, as a nephew, actually said to You Lao Niang, "Only wait for Sister Feng to die, then take the second aunt into the main room", Jia Lian also said "Only wait for Wang Xifeng to die, then take Second Sister You in", Second Sister You knew that Jia Lian had a wife, and even "willing to do it", why did the author and commentators, and even Yu Baodai think that Wang Xifeng was vicious, and Second Sister You was extremely pitiful?
The sixty-eighth time in "Dream of the Red Chamber", the author's recollection clearly reads "Bitter You Niang earned into the Grand View Garden Acid Feng Sister made a big fuss in the Ningguo Mansion", look at the praise and depreciation of this word, You Er Sister is bitter, is pitiful, Wang Xifeng is sour, is hateful.
Looking at the fat criticism again, not only does it say that Wang Xifeng is a blessing in disguise, does not read the blood food of the ancestral temple, and is the first sinner of Jia Zhao, but also says that Wang Xifeng's "Noisy Ning Mansion" section is extremely fierce, and the "earn the second sister" section is not to be reproached, but also uses the evil of all people to show Wang Xifeng's evil.
General comment before Menghui: Writing Feng Jie is inexhaustible, but it is written from top to bottom, left and right. Write Qiu Tong extremely obscene, and write Feng Jie extremely obscene; Write Ping'er ExtremeLy Righteous Qi, and write Feng Jie Extremely Unrighteousness; Write the maid bullying the second sister, and write feng sister bullying the second sister; Write down people feel Dai Second Sister, and write down that people do not feel Dai Fengjie. Shi Gong is not known for reading dead books.
In the story of "Dream of the Red Chamber", the pen describes the gentle and shungao Feng sister ten times, and the words and deeds are five points better than the Feng sister, which can be jia lian's second room, that is, Jia Baoyu and Lin Daiyu, who also stand in line with the second sister you, thinking that she is too pitiful.
The sisters in the garden and Li Feng Yingchun Xichun and others are all well-intentioned for Sister Feng, and Ran Baodai is secretly worried about the second sister. Although they were not troublesome, they saw that the second sister was pitiful and often came, but they all sympathized with him.
In the story of "Dream of the Red Chamber", Wang Xifeng is indeed a character who is "virtuous on the outside, cunning on the inside, and reckless in life", while You Erjie is a person with a soft heart, whether it is in the face of You Laoniang, Jia Lian, Jia Zhen, Jia Rong, Wang Xifeng, Ping'er, or those who bully her, You Erjie has never had any malice, and she only wants to protect herself, but she cannot protect herself, and she has never complained half a point.
Sister You cried, "Sister, my character has been a failure in my life, and today's retribution is of course, so why should I be wronged by killing?" Endure with me. If heaven sees mercy and makes me well, wouldn't it be better to have it both ways? Neither can they live in peace, but they are also reasonable, and the slaves have no complaints. ”
Looking at You Erjie's attitude towards Ping'er, although Ping'er pit her and told Wang Xifeng about this matter, it caused You Erjie to be calculated by Wang Xifeng, and the child and herself were not saved, but You Erjie was a piece of gratitude.
Second Sister You pulled him to cry, "Sister, I have been here since then, thanks to my sister's care." For me, my sister didn't know how much idleness I had suffered. If I escape, I will repay my sister's kindness, but I am afraid that I will not be able to escape, and I will have to wait for the next life. My sister was wrong. If his sister didn't tell him, he wouldn't have been able to find out, but his sister said it first. Moreover, I also want to come in with all my heart, and become a body, and work with my sister. ”
In the story of "Dream of the Red Chamber", You Shi is weak, only You Sanjie is an exception, and the tragedy of You ErJie is also related to the weakness of You Lao Niang and You Shi. Miao Yu entered the Jia Mansion, and also asked Jia Fu Zheng'er to invite her to the underground post, and You Lao Niang brought two daughters into the Jia Mansion, just a word from You Shi, Jia Zhen did not come forward, this came over, the two daughters were bullied, You Lao Niang only did not know, and even thanked Daide, the tragedy of You Erjie was already doomed.
The information in this article is mainly quoted from: "Dream of the Red Chamber" Cheng Gaoben, "Fat Yan Zhai Full Review Stone Record"