6,000 words long text, tell you a real attack

The sixteenth edition pointed out: "In the Book of Stones, there are many texts that convey the spirit of the heart, and you do not need to explain it, but if you understand it together, you will enter the vulgar set. ”

There are two reasons why "there is no need to do it": 1. You can't do it, because once you do, you will fall into the abyss of "word hell" that cannot be recovered; 2. This is the greatness of genius authors, the real highest art is often only ineffable, always leaving the viewer unlimited imagination.

The two reasons for "no need to explain it" are reflected in the dream people, and also present two aspects: 1. Some dream people always seem mysterious and seem to hide something, such as Qin Keqing, Daiyu and so on; 2. Except for a very few, many dream people are difficult to distinguish between loyalty and traitor, and it is difficult to distinguish between good and evil. This is also in line with the complex nature of human nature and the reality of society, almost everyone is difficult to simply distinguish between good and evil by loyalty, and the same person, the evaluation is likely to be polarized, as the saying goes, Guan Gong also has a mortal opponent, and Cao Cao also has good friends.

Because the author never easily makes a conclusion about the person in the dream, coupled with the "dream of the Red Chamber is not finished", many issues in the text have become unsolved cases, and there are different opinions. Confusing and inspecting the Grand View Garden, who is the one who snubbles on Mrs. Wang in Yi Hong's courtyard is one example.

Mrs. Wang chased Qingwen, Fang Guan, and Si'er, claiming that "although my body is not big, my heart and ears are always here", and only a few days ago, Mrs. Wang was not sure whether the "water snake waist, shoulders, and eyebrows are a little like your sister Lin" is Qingwen. For Qingwen's own statement that "I don't go to Baoyu's room, and I don't often go to Baoyu's place, I can't know", she also "believed it". After Qingwen, Fangguan, and Si'er were expelled, even Baoyu wondered: "Let's play privately, how do we know?" "Therefore, there must be informers lurking around Baoyu.

So, who would be that whistleblower? On the basis of a careful study of the text and the fat criticism, we might as well take the elimination method from the whole point of view to see who is most likely to be the whistleblower who allows us to "step on the iron shoe and find nowhere to go".

First of all, you can exclude those who were expelled from the Grand View Garden, such as Qingwen, Si'er, Fang Guan, etc., because the attacker had consulted Mrs. Wang in the thirty-fourth round, many people will naturally think that the attacker is the informer, then, will the informant really be the biggest maid around Baoyu?

Don't be wronged, respectable and cute

There is often a misconception about attacking people, thinking that she is full of slaves, treacherous, has a city, and even does anything to achieve her ends.

However, this was a great wrongful attack on Qing, and the 21st time he looked back and directly called the attacker a "virtuous attacker", and Li Yanzhai criticized: "It is deserved." The verdict of the fifth attack is "self-servant and gentle and submissive, and the sky is like Gui Rulan." It is a blessing to sigh that you are blessed, who knows that the son has no chance. ", Fat Critic pointed out: "Scolding the dead treasure jade, but it is self-repentance." In the nineteenth time, "Earnestly Happy Night Flower Explanation", Li Yanzhai also commented on people's "not only explanation, but also wisdom." ", "A wise and wise man". In the part of the general approval reminder before the 28th Zhiyanzhai Return, "(Jiang Yuhan) later returned to the attacking person to worship the jade brother and Baoqing to have the same end", indicating that the attacker is not a villain with little affection.

Li Yanzhai also indirectly praises people from the perspective of comparing with other dream people. If Ping'er is the author's favorite and near-perfect dream person, there should be no controversy. The twenty-first time, Jia Lian took the opportunity to move out to fast, and came with many girls. After the fasting was over, Ping'er, who had tidied up the cover, shook out a strand of blue silk to cover up Jia Lian, who was afraid of the jealous Sister Feng, and Li Yanzhai commented on this: "Excellent! Unexpectedly, Ping'er has the identity of attacking Qing, which can be described as having no material, and the cover is different. ", indirectly praised the attack. Another example is Qingwen, the eighth time Baoyu asked about the dish of tofu skin that she specially left for Qingwen that she loved to eat, Qingwen directly responded that Grandma Li took it back to her grandson to eat, and Li Yanzhai also indirectly praised the attack: "It is a pair of cheese that is far away from the later text attack on Qing, which shows that Qingqing is not as far away as Qing Qing."

From the first to the end, without reading the entire book, Li Yanzhai, who "knows the bottom of the book", may have misunderstood minor characters such as Xiaohong (the author has added and deleted many times, and the personalities of some secondary characters have also undergone subversive changes) when he was initially criticized, but he must be clear about the attack on the "deputy of Youzhao" who is ranked at the top of the twelve sub-volumes, and the authority of his criticism cannot be questioned. Moreover, as the author's confidant, Li Yanzhai participated in the creation of the text almost the whole time, she has always praised the attack on people so repeatedly and without sparing words, if you question the attack again, is there anyone other than the author who is confident enough to think that she is more "deep in the bottom of the book" than Li Yanzhai?

The twenty-second round of fat criticism pointed out: "If you read Xue and Lin Zuo Zhen Yu and Jia Yu, you will not lose the original purpose of the author." "Jia Baoyu, who should be seen by Daiyu, eventually jumped out of the red dust and became a monk, and his "unkindness" was not that the four were empty, but that he was born with the heart of entering the world, with Buddha in his heart, ten thousand people, compassion for people, that is, a love monk; Zhen Baoyu, who should be seen by Baochu, his final "reluctance" is closer to the realm of "Ren is ruthless and moving" of "Gaoshi crystal snow in the mountains", that is, entering the world with the heart of birth, not for material bondage, not for kitsch, but to become a high character in itself. The realm that Jia Baoyu eventually reached is similar to the metaphor of Baochu, which is presented in the text of "all the metaphors in the table" (fat batch), that is, Erbao is "a couple", and the two have the so-called "golden and jade marriage".

Baoyu, "behavior is remote and perverse", in order to reach the final realm of "reluctance", it is not achieved overnight. In addition to life experience, in the text pretending to be "to make the boudoir reveal", it is also necessary to pass on the words and deeds of the unmarried beautiful woman around him, such as the "priceless jewel", to guide him to the realm of "unkindness". Sister Bao, who combines the strengths of Baoyu, Daiyu and Xiangyun into one body (the twenty-second fat batch), has the realm of "cold incense pill", and she has the ambition of "sending me to Qingyun with the power of good wind" and is undoubtedly the best candidate.

However, the identity of Sister Bao's young lady determined that she could not accompany him day and night before marrying Baoyu, and often persuaded him, and the "deputy for Zhao" (fat batch) attacker, as the big maid beside Baoyu, just met these conditions before the "golden and jade marriage" was realized. Attacking words and deeds will profoundly affect Baoyu.

Please see how the text describes the attack, and how Li Yanzhai evaluates the attack:

"Because Jia Mu doted on Baoyu, she was afraid that Baoyu's servant would not be able to do her best to be loyal, and she was pure and honest in her heart, and she fulfilled her duties, so she married Baoyu. When he served Jia Mu, there was only one Jia Mu in his heart, and now he serves Baoyu, and there is only one Baoyu in his heart. Just because Baoyu has a well-behaved temperament, every time he advises Baoyu, his heart is really melancholy. Li Yanzhai sighed: "If the world has a position, if it can be like attacking people, the world is very lucky." Baoyu is the author's "self-parry" (fat batch), Baoyu has more or less the shadow of the author when she was young, and she also feels the same with the author, many years later, when she made a criticism, she still sighed with emotion "I read this, I don't feel crying loudly", you can imagine how much pressure and effort the attacker will bear to bear this heavy responsibility.

"There is only one treasure jade in the eyes of the heart" (the third time), paying attention to the treasure jade all the time, even if there is a little missing something on him, she is also clear, such as the seventeenth Grand View Garden title match, the treasure jade who showed his poetry talent won the favor of Yan's father Jia Zheng, Jia Zheng's small house did not want to reward money, asked for what Baoyu wore, after returning, the attacker quickly found out, and the fat critic pointed out: "The attack on the jade brother is always noticed"; Dedicated to his duties, he was willing to dedicate everything to Baoyu, and Baoyu "did not want to do these tasks at home with small and large work." I can't get rid of these", and the attack "can't say that I have to slowly get tired", and Fat Critic pointed out that this is "wishful thinking". Attacking people is commendable, any era needs a person as faithful and conscientious as attacker, you can't depart from the background of the times, arbitrarily label a person like Raider as a slave, let alone demand that she rebel against the system that has been working for thousands of years, she is just a high-ranking maid.

She is the number one maid of Yi Hong Courtyard, who is deeply favored and trusted by Baoyu and has considerable power, but she has never abused this power, bullied and suppressed the maids below, and did not use this to exclude dissidents. For example, Qingwen, because of the attack and Baoyu has a cloud and rain relationship, has been in the heart, openly and secretly ridiculed her, the thirty-first time, Qingwen bumped into Baoyu, extending the anger to the attack who came to persuade, and was involved in this matter, Baoyu in anger, ready to return to Mrs. Wang, to get rid of Qingwen, the attack still did not remember the old evil Qingwen repeatedly offended her, insisted on hard persuasion before stopping him.

She is always generous, gentle, and tolerant, such as the eighth time, Baoyu returned drunk, asked about the maple dew tea that Qian Xue made in the morning, but it had been drunk by Grandma Li, and the drunken and hazy Baoyu fell the tea bell in a fit of anger, and immediately went back to Jia's mother and beat his nursing mother. The attacker, who was pretending to sleep, quickly got up to explain the dissuasion, and replied that the person sent by Jia Mu was he who accidentally broke Zhongzi, and urged Baoyu not to chase away Grandma Li, and the fat critic sighed: "Ready-made, look at him writing about attacking Qing as a person." ”； In the nineteenth time, the attacker returned to Yihong Courtyard from home, but the cheese that Baoyu kept for her had already been eaten by the nanny Grandma Li, and the attacker lied to Baoyu and said, "I ate it deliciously, and after eating it, my stomach hurt, and I vomited in full trouble." He ate it well, and left it here to spoil it. Fat Critic also pointed out: "It is the same as the previous missed broken bell, and the whole department attacks everyone, which is a bit good." ”

This is true even after gaining Mrs. Wang's trust, such as the fifty-first time, after Mrs. Wang gave the attacker's prospective aunt treatment, during the attacker's mother's funeral, Qingwen arbitrarily advocated to take away the pendant who stole the Ping'er shrimp and whisker bracelet, and the attacker came back without saying anything, just saying that it was too urgent.

If we say that the image of a good person in disguise can blind a few people for a while, but it cannot blind forever and blind everyone. On the twenty-first time, Baochi "slowly asked him (attacking) his age and hometown, etc., paying attention to peeping, and his words were deeply respectable", and the fat criticism pointed out: "This is Baoqing's first test, and it has gradually become known, and Gai Baoqing has since detected the attacking fruitful woman"; In the twenty-sixth time, Baoyu fell ill due to the magic of the devil, and after recovering from his illness, Shi Taijun discussed the merit and rewarded, and the little girl Jiahui privately hugged Hong Yu and mentioned the attack, "Even if he has to be very young, don't annoy him, it should be." Speaking in conscience, who dares to compare with him? Fat criticism pointed out: "If you are sure about public opinion, you will see the identity of the secretary."

Sister Feng and Daiyu are such intelligent people, and Daiyu has always been "lonely and self-assured, and there is no dust in their eyes", but they also praised the attackers, such as the thirty-sixth time, Mrs. Wang ordered Sister Feng to take out two taels of silver and a hanging of money from her monthly routine to give the attackers and give her the treatment of a prospective girl. Sister Feng smiled and pushed Aunt Xue and said, "Aunt heard it, what did I say in Suri?" Today's answer to my words. Aunt Xue said, "It's long overdue." Needless to say, his kind of behavior is generous, and he speaks with a rigid and strong temperament, which is really rare. ”； The twentieth time, Grandma Li looked for an opportunity to attack people, and Daiyu smiled first: "This is your mother and the attacker." That attack is just that, your mother has to seriously pomp him, it can be seen that the old back is obscure. Fat Critic also pointed out: "Attack Qing can make Qing Qing praise, and see that he is a person, what do the viewers think?" "The attack is obviously not disguised.

It is said that attacking people for the position of the girl, unscrupulous means, seducing Baoyu, not only out of the background of the times, but also out of the text and fat criticism. In the sixth time, the attacker and Baoyu received the training of the police illusion, and the fat critic pointed out: "Baoyu and attacking people are also common things for everyone." Moreover, Baoyu and the attack led the same cloud and rain, it was Baoyu who attacked people, not the attacking initiative, and the reason why the attacker agreed was because "Jia Mu has already separated herself with Baoyu, and now it is so, and it is not unreasonable", Fat Critic pointed out: "Write the attack person". In the sixty-fifth time, Xing'er introduced the family situation to Second Sister You and Third Sister You, mentioning that "the rules of our family, when the masters are older, they will first let two people serve before marrying relatives", so as Baoyu's sexual enlightenment teacher, this was originally one of the duties of attacking people.

In the seventy-eighth time, Qingwen confided her grievances to Baoyu who secretly came to see her: "Although I was born slightly better than others, I didn't have a private affair to seduce you, how to bite me to death that I am a fox spirit!" I was so unconvinced. The twentieth time was after the sixth Baoyu and the attacker's first test of Yunyu, Li Grandma attacked people and scolded her for "only wanting to pretend to be a fox and coax Baoyu". Some people may think that this is not clear that the attack is the fox spirit that seduces Baoyu, but the fat critic also pointed out: "Living like an outdated nanny scolding the girl, and calling the next person to hit the sky and bend on the attacking Qing", "Look at this sentence scared the critics to death".

The attack is also like Baochu, "nature from the festival of etiquette" (the twenty-second round of fat batch), the old Zhu mother wants to pick the grapes, let the attack people taste it, the attack refuses, and tells the old Zhu mother that there is no fresh supply on top, and you can't break the rules. People who "follow the festival of etiquette" have self-awareness, and they never look at Shu and think of right and wrong. In the nineteenth time, the attacker advised Baoyu and coaxed Baoyu's family to ransom her back, and finally Baoyu accepted the advice and kept the attacker, Baoyu smiled and said: "You have been here for a long time, and you are not afraid that there are no eight people sitting on you." The raider sneered, "I don't like this." There is that blessing, there is no such truth. Sitting down, it's not very interesting. Fat Critic pointed out: "The ridicule is not shallow, but in the attack people can be a language, it is really cute and respectable and convincing, the so-called "flower interpretation language" is also." "The 'Flower Interpretation' paragraph is that Yu Qing is full of satisfaction and will be relied on for life by Brother Jade, so it is. At this point, Yu Weiqing sighed. Ding Haichun. Teratophyll. ”

After "two years of selection, it was not bad at all" (78th), Madame Wang gave her the treatment of a prospective concubine in the 36th time. The reason why it is not clear is because Yiyi "A treasure jade is still young, and the old man is afraid that he will delay the book when he knows it; The second is that Baoyu is already a person in front of him, and does not dare to persuade him, but indulges. After Mrs. Wang gave her the treatment of a prospective concubine and valued her more and more, the attack also understood Mrs. Wang's painstaking efforts, "The more self-respecting." Where people are betrayed, or between nights, there will be no affection with precious jade."

Therefore, attacking people is gentle and submissive, kind to people, tolerant of the masses, from the rules and obedience, safe and guarding oneself, although there are life pursuits, there are also seven emotions and six desires, but can always control desires, enough can stop. To a considerable extent, her behavior is a copy of Xue Baochai, so the attack of "being a deputy of Xue Baochu" (fat batch) is enough to take on the important task of guiding Baoyu to reach the realm of "reluctance".

Mrs. Wang "is almost fifty years old, and there is only one left of him (Baoyu)" (34th), and no one (including Jia Zheng) is more concerned and concerned about Baoyu's future than her. Zhizi Mo Ruomu, Jia Mu (the text "write false, you know the truth", the humble text also "writes falsehood and knows the truth" for the convenience of description, not writing about Mrs. Zhen and Old Lady Zhen) also "know that Baoyu will also be a person who does not listen to the advice of his wife and concubine in the future" (78th), how can Mrs. Wang not know the reason? Therefore, it is especially important to find a wife and concubine for Baoyu who is good at advising rather than pandering. "If you say that you know the great gift heavily, Mo Ruo attacks people first. Moreover, he acted generously and honestly, and in the past few years, he has never been naughty to Baoyu. Fan Baoyu is very messy, he can only persuade him to die. (78th Lady Wang), coupled with the above-mentioned near-perfect advantages, made her stand out in the maid-like Yihong Courtyard, won the appreciation of Lady Wang, and established her unshakable position in the Yihong Courtyard [Note 1]. Therefore, in the seventy-seventh time, the attacker said to Baoyu that Qingwen "even if it is good, it will not destroy my order", which is by no means her self-exaggeration.

In fact, the attack has already reached the peak of what she can achieve as a maid, and even if she goes to snitch again, she will not be able to seek greater benefits, so there is no need for her to snitch, and at the same time, the informant said out of thin air that Qingwen and Baoyu are not clear, and it does not conform to the character of the text about attacking people. Moreover, if the attacker is really a treacherous scheming woman who is bent on climbing up, as some commentators believe, then how can she be stupid enough to do such a trick?!

As the two most important metaphorical carriers in the text, one by one, the birthday of the attack is the same day as Daiyu, and it is the same as Baochu, and the importance of attacking people in the text is self-evident. The object of Baoyu's first test of cloud and rain love was to attack people, and the attack was the first woman in Baoyu's life; Baoyu, who is older and has always advised him to have a remote and well-behaved personality, is also his life mentor; He takes care of Baoyu in every way, and is like his mother.

Of course, the final outcome of Baoyu was not what Mrs. Wang expected, but all this cannot be attributed to the attacker, because it is also not what the attacker wants. "Good jade is not light when you can sigh", it has been implied that in the text that conceals the dispute between orthodoxy and unorthodoxy, the tragic cause of Baoyu lies in the so-called apocalyptic luck in which unorthodox takes the orthodoxy and replaces it. Baoyu has reached the realm of "reluctance", instead of beating itself up, breaking the jar and breaking it, and becoming a "ceramic fragment" of society, perhaps Yu Qing should remember a great achievement.

"Flower qi attacks people know the warmth of the day" [Note 2], the original sentence "Flower qi attacks people know sudden warmth" comes from Lu You's famous poem "Village House Shuxi", the author changed it to day, with its own deep meaning When the attack had to leave Baoyu, the orthodox "warm day" ended, and the unorthodox dark night began.

Although in the end, only Shi Xiangyun, who "only feared to sleep in the middle of the night", and Lu Yue, a dream person who also had a realistic prototype, accompanied the author and stayed up through the long night, but Fat Critic pointed out that Baoyu is the author's "self-parable", so whether it is a real person who has existed in the author's life, or just a dream phantom in the text presented in a dream form, the attack is a beautiful woman cherished in his heart, affecting his words and deeds, and even shaping his way of behaving in the world.

The author is undoubtedly a victim of the end times, and the last days will destroy the pearl (the original name of the attacker), and the pain of the author's heartbreak is self-evident. Years later, how many "bitter tears" the author will shed in the mourning Hongxuan in order to artistically reproduce this woman who has both character and profound influence on his life.

Note 1, the seventy-seventh time, the attack to appease Baoyu, who was grieving because Qingwen and others were taken away, Baoyu said that a good begonia flower under the steps died half of it for no reason in the spring, and sure enough, it should have reached Qingwen, and the attacker responded: "Even if he is good, he can't destroy my order", which is definitely not her boasting or playing any trick.

Note 2: Baoyu changed the flower pearl to flower attack because of this poem. As a symbol of the perfect wisdom in the text, Baochi is deeply attacking, and the fat critic points out that the meaning of its symbolic "cold incense pill" is one by one, "this side is the right meaning of the flower fragrance attacking people", which corresponds to the "flower qi attacking people" that attacks people.

In the twenty-eighth time, he wrote Jiang Yuhan's wine order, picked up a wooden tree, and read: The flower qi attacks people and knows the warmth of the day. Muxi, that is, the four seasons of laurel, bloom in all seasons, so this poem is a metaphor for the fact that when the flowers hit people, the wealth like "warm day" is like the wood tree that blooms in all seasons, and it seems to never wither.

Author: Guo Cheng, this article is an original work of reading the Red Chamber.