When it comes to lü bu of the three kingdoms, we will always think of the word three surnames of family slaves, although their bravery is abnormal, but their character is not good, they have changed hands many times in their lives, and there is no loyalty to speak of. It is worth mentioning that Liu Bei also changed masters many times in his life, changed the court, and successively attached himself to Gongsun Zhan, Tao Qian, Cao Cao, Yuan Shao, Liu Biao and many other princes, but his reputation was very good.
So the same is the same many times to jump ship, why is the evaluation of Lü Bu and Liu Bei very different?
This is not a double standard, Liu Bei and Lü Bu are indeed different. Although it is also a many times to jump jobs, Liu Bei is excusable and belongs to the normal flow of personnel, while Lü Bu is ungrateful and capricious.
Let's first look at how Lü Bu, the name of the three-surnamed family slave, came from, the first company to work was the Hezhou Group, and the Hezhou Assassin Stingyuan was very important to this local warrior, promoted many times, and finally became Ding Yuan's confidant. Therefore, Ding Yuan is no different from Lü Bu's Bole and has great kindness to him.
However, Ding Yuan believed that lü Bu was not a man, and he did not know that Lü Bu was a white-eyed wolf. At Dong Zhuo's instigation, Lü Bu took advantage of Ding Yuan's trust in him, eliminated him, and took over his army and switched to Dong Zhuo's command. Transformed into the righteous son of Dong Taishi, he was promoted by Dong Zhuo to be a general of Zhonglang and the Marquis of Fengduting, thus becoming famous and becoming a well-known "Flying General".
Lü Bu stepped on Ding Yuan's corpse and gained glory and wealth.
And this is not the end, after being put into Dong Zhuo's command, Lü Bu was added to the rank of knight, obviously mixed very well. However, he was not satisfied, and later, at the instigation of Situ Wang Yun, he took advantage of Dong Zhuo's trust in him and eliminated him. At that time, Lü Bu ushered in the peak of his political career, and he stepped on Dong Zhuo's corpse to the top of the power of the Eastern Han Dynasty. He served as the general of Fenwu, False Festival, Yibi Sansi, jinfeng Wenhou, and wang yun in charge of the imperial government.
Judging from the encounters of Dong Zhuo and Ding Yuan, although they were not good people, they had nothing to say to Lü Bu, but they were betrayed by Lü Bu, and it was Lü Bu who stabbed them in the back and got rid of them. Killed by his own most trusted, it is estimated that anyone who thinks of this is wronged.
Therefore, after Lü Bu was captured by Cao Cao, Liu Bei would use dong Zhuo and Ding Yuan's encounter to remind Cao Cao.
Liu Beijin said: "Ming Gong did not see the cloth ding Jianyang and Dong Taishihu! ”
Speaking of this, I have to say that he and Liu Bei have a grudge. In that year, Lü Bu's soldiers defeated Yanzhou and fled to Xuzhou, where they fell to the extreme. It was Liu Bei who sent charcoal in the snow and took him in so that he could make a comeback. However, how Lü Bu later confronted Liu Bei, he took advantage of the battle between Liu Bei and Yuan Shu, sneaked up on Xia Pi from behind, and destroyed Liu Bei's old lair, causing his army to be confused and unable to keep up with logistics, and finally fled to Haixi.
On the way to escape, Liu Bei's army suffered a lot because there was no supply. At its worst, the soldiers had to survive by eating the corpses of their comrades who had starved to death first.
The garrison was in Guangling, hungry and sleepy, the officials ate each other, and the poor and hungry invaded
In the end, the desperate Liu Bei could only lead his army to surrender to Lü Bu, because he and buqu's family members were in Lü Bu's hands. After that, Lü Bu occupied the magpie's nest and robbed Liu Bei's Xuzhou.
Although some consciences during the period found that Yuanmen shot the sword and helped Liu Bei break the siege, if there was no unjust act before him, why did Liu Bei fall into the role of fearing Ji Ling, knowing that he was once the lord of a state and could wrench his wrist with Yuan Shu, the lord of Ji Ling.
In the end, it was also because of Lü Bu's attack that Liu Bei was defeated and displaced, and he had to defect to Cao Cao. Therefore, Liu Bei and Lü Bu had a great vendetta, and in the past, under the White Gate, he would risk being jealous of Cao Cao and remind him to get rid of Lü Bu.
To sum up, Lü Bu, a family slave with three surnames, is worthy of the name.
As for Liu Bei, he also worked for others in the early stages of his career, but he did not betray him.
Initially, he took Zhang FeiGuanyu with him to quell the rebellion in the army, and was later made a lieutenant of Anxi County for military merit. However, the official field was dim, and Liu Bei finally resigned and left. Similar things have happened many times in Liu Bei's body, either resigning and not doing anything, or being broken by the rebels and dying in the end of the world.
These can't be considered betrayals, can they?
Later, Liu Bei threw himself into the hands of his friend Gongsun Zhan and became a sima of his own department, which was considered to be the master of the Eight Classics of Zheng'er. But from beginning to end, he did not betray Gongsun Zhan. Whether it was as a general under Gongsun Zhan or sending Qingzhou and Tian Kai to partner against Yuan Shao, he did a very good job.
As for later joining Xuzhou and parting ways with Gongsun Zhan, that is also a normal job-hopping behavior. First of all, he did not take away gongsun Zhan's soldiers and pawns, and his men were all the parts he had collected over the years and the starving people he had collected along the way. Even Zhao Yun, who had already "slept with his feet", Liu Bei did not poach him. Zhao Yun defected to Liu Bei, and that was already after the defeat of Gongsun Zhan.
Therefore, Liu Bei and Gongsun Zhan did not have a relationship of betrayal.
In Xuzhou, Liu Bei took over Tao Qian's class and has always been conscientious and conscientious, after all, it is his own industry. If it were not for Lü Bu's stab in the back, Liu Bei would inevitably leave a strong mark in the north. Therefore, for Tao Qian, Liu Bei is not a betrayal.
The only person Liu Bei was suspected of betrayal was actually Cao Cao. When Liu Bei was expelled from Xuzhou by Yuan Shu and Lü Bu and displaced, it was Cao Cao who accepted him. But here is a detail to tell, at that time Liu Bei was defeated by Lü Bu, and when he fled, he just happened to encounter Cao Cao to attack Lü Bu.
The so-called enemy of the enemy is the friend, so at that time Liu Bei and Cao Cao were more of a cooperative relationship, similar to the Sun Liu Alliance. Of course, after all, Cao Cao occupied absolute dominance, Liu Bei belonged to the fence, and from a personal point of view, he owed Cao Cao.
However, Liu Bei's identity was very delicate, and at that time Cao Cao recruited Liu Bei in the name of the Eastern Han court, that is to say, Liu Bei was attached as a Han chen at that time, and cao Cao was a colleague of superiors and subordinates, not his subordinate staff.
This is also why Liu Bei would later participate in the Yidaizhao incident, because his identity position is actually similar to Dong Cheng's. He was loyal to Emperor Xian of Han and not loyal to Cao Cao, so there was no betrayal.
Later, when he came under Yuan Shao, Liu Bei did not betray Yuan Shao. That was when Yuan Shao was defeated by Cao Cao, and Liu Bei naturally could not mix with him. Moreover, like Cao Cao before him, Liu Bei at this time had a certain attachment relationship with Yuan Shao. But the two are not the relationship between the protagonist and the ministry, they are an alliance, they are collaborators. In the end, the parting of the way is at best a breakdown of cooperation, not a betrayal.
Finally, there was Liu Biao, who helped a lot, and when Liu Bei was chased by Cao Cao and was exhausted, it was Liu Biao who accepted him. But Liu Bei did not betray Liu Biao. When Liu Biao was alive, Liu Bei was conscientious in helping him to watch the door. After Liu Biao's death, he no longer needs to rely on anyone, and can only fight the world by himself.
Therefore, in general, although Liu Bei had many job-hopping actions in his life, he did not have unjust actions, let alone betrayal. It is completely incomparable with Lü Bu's villainous behavior of selling the lord and seeking glory.
In fact, it wasn't just Liu Bei, in the history of the Three Kingdoms. There are many people who have changed hands many times, such as Zhang Liao, Zhang Xuan, Jiang Wei and so on. They all surrendered, but they all had a good reputation. Obviously, this behavior was acceptable at the time. The reason why Lü Bu was belittled was because of his character, even if he jumped ship, he still had to take the pit master and sell the master for glory. Such behavior is naturally despised by people, and it is no wonder that he bears such a name as a family slave with three surnames.