Hello everyone, I am squid Jun, I love the history of the Spring and Autumn Warring States period, but also like the related film and television works, for some time, I am updating the "Fission of the Great Qin Empire" commentary video, but I decided to stop explaining this series, because and some of the details of the historical Shang Martingale transformation method are quite different.
01 The first point: the image of The pious son is beautified
In "The Fission of the Great Qin Empire", the first half of Gongzi Qian's life is the pillar of the Great Qin Empire, and the second half of his life is the gravedigger of Shang Martin. In the Fission of the Great Qin Empire, because the prince was killed indiscriminately, the prince Qian, who was the prince's wife, was sentenced to death by Shang Martin, and has since gone into darkness. However, in the records of the "Chronicle of Shang Jun", Gongzi Qian was not sentenced to death by Shang Martin when the prince violated the law, but was sentenced to this punishment after committing another crime.
02 The second point: there are discrepancies in the former capital of the Qin Kingdom
The Chronicle of the Shang Emperor records that "he lived for three years, and as a palace in Xianyang, Qin Ziyong migrated to the capital. It is forbidden to let the fathers, sons and brothers of the people rest in the same room. ”
This shows that the capital of the Qin state before the capital was moved to Yong in 677 BC, which is today's Baoji Fengxiang, which lasted for 300 years, and in 350 BC Shang Martin proposed to move the capital to Xianyang. In "The Fission of the Great Qin Empire", the former capital of the Qin State became Oak Yang, and the Xianyang City was actually built by Shang Martin, which is inconsistent with history.
03 The third point: The martingale's human settings are too glorified
It is a fact that Uncle Huan persuaded the King of Wei to use a martingale, and at the same time advised the King of Wei to kill Shang Martingale, and it is also a fact that Shang Martin entered Qin, but the story in between was romanticized. In the story, Shang Martin also went to the nations before entering Qin, and even got acquainted with Shen Buhao, and agreed with each other to prove the correctness of his own change of law. Moreover, after Shang Martin entered Qin, Jing Jian, the favorite minister of Qin Xiaogong, wanted to directly introduce Shang Martingale, but was rejected by Shang Martin, who said that he wanted to take the right path and then go to the Zhao XianGuan. And the martingale in the film and television also said that only this is the right way. However, after Shang Martin entered Qin in history, it was through Jingjian, the favorite minister of Qin Xiaogong, that he could meet Qin Xiaogong.
04 Fourth: Contrary to historical facts, what happened after the death of Qin Xiaogong was even greater
After the death of Qin Xiaogong in "The Fission of the Great Qin Empire", Shang Martin originally had a new army of protectors arranged by Qin Xiaogong, which was strong in combat and very admired and grateful to Shang Martin. However, in order to prevent civil unrest in Qin, Shang Martin took the initiative to order the withdrawal of the new army, and he finally went to the capital to be tortured, which can be described as a hero.
However, the historical Shang Martingale is not like this, after King Hui of Qin succeeded to the throne, Gongzi Qian joined forces with Ganlong and other old clans of the Qin State to falsely accuse Shang Martingale of rebellion, originally King Hui of Qin was dealt with by Shang Martingale in the early days of the Shang Martingale Reform Law, and at this time he did not maintain Shang Martingale, and Shang Martin fled from Xianyang after that, but because the Shang Martingale legislation stipulated that the people of the Qin State could not take in people without credentials, finally Shang Martin had no way and wanted to flee to the State of Wei. However, because Shang Martin won the victory by cheating Gongzi Jie during the conquest of the State of Wei, the Wei people hated it, so they refused shang martingale entry, and Shang Martin finally had to go back to the fiefdom to rebel, and as a result, because of the disparity in strength, the soldiers were defeated and killed. After Shang Martin's death, his body was transported to Xianyang to be executed by the car splitting.
05 Summary
The historical status of Shang martingale is beyond doubt, and the Qin state can eventually unify the world, and Shang martingale is indispensable. However, his personal disposition was not as flawless as depicted in "The Fission of the Great Qin Empire", and Shang Martin was a representative of the great Dharma, but he was not a saint, and he himself did not think of being a saint.