Was the red card for Paul Pogba harsh? Should Cristiano Ronaldo be sent off for his grumpy kick against Liverpool? Should spurs get penalties at West Ham United? Is Rafinha's game-ending tackle worth red?
Was Cristiano Ronaldo lucky not to be sent off for old Trafford against Liverpool midfielder Curtis Jones?
Former Premier League referee Demot Gallagher made the rules for the weekend's big events and asked Cristiano Ronaldo if he should follow Paul Pogba away from the pitch in United's crushing defeat to Liverpool...
Manchester United 0-5 Liverpool
Referee: Anthony Taylor
Paul Pogba's frantic challenge to Nabi keita forced the Liverpool midfielder to injure and win a red card for the Manchester United men
Event: Manchester United midfielder Paul Pogba burst into Nabi Keita, missed the ball and connected to the tibia of the Liverpool midfielder. The yellow card was originally a yellow card, but before Keita left the venue on a stretcher, after a VAR review, the yellow card was upgraded to red.
Demot's verdict: "It was absolutely the right decision. The referee thought it was a yellow card because of where he was on the pitch, but when you saw it coming back, Pogba clearly crossed the ball, arrived from a distance and made contact with Keita's studs, and you get even more nervous when you come from a distance. The fact that Keita had to lie on a stretcher and leave the pitch shows how bad its tackles were and pogba was right to be sent off. ”
Flashpoint: The Liverpool player confronted Cristiano Ronaldo after trying to kick from curtis Jones' feet while he was on the ground
Event: Cristiano Ronaldo tied Curtis Jones up and made two attempts to kick the ball out while Liverpool midfield was on the pitch. Ronaldo made contact with the ball on both occasions, but there was power behind his attempt to get the ball back and he was shown a yellow card.
De Motte's verdict: "Cristiano was lucky that the ball was there, which saved him from being shown a red card. What also helped was that he stopped when he did so. It wasn't the wisest thing to do, there was power behind the kick, but the fact that the ball was there helped him a lot.
"When you finally see it, the yellow card is the right decision. It's hard to say if things wouldn't have been different if Jones had rolled around on the floor, but he didn't, and he was very nice and very professional. ”
Bruno Fernandez was cautioned for a yellow card for challenging Liverpool's Curtis Jones
Event: Bruno Fernandez was still far from the ball when he blatantly cleaned curtis Jones when Liverpool midfield broke the right wing at Old Trafford. Jones was blocked in the tibia by Fernandez's assault challenge, but the Portuguese were only shown a yellow card for the incident.
Demot's verdict: "A lot of people think it should be a red card, but it doesn't fall into this category. Fernandez entered on one foot; he went into the low post, he didn't follow up, and his nails didn't "touch the calf or calf like a typical red card foul." I don't think it's a great challenge, but it's a yellow card instead of a red card. ”