After the fall of the Shu kingdom, Pang De's son Pang Hui privately led troops to kill Guan Yu's descendants, was Pang Hui doing this to avenge his father? When Guan Yu attacked Xiangfan, the flooded three armies were captured by the forbidden Pang Dewei to shock Huaxia, but Guan Yu did not say that Pound's descendants were cleanly killed, but he did not expect to be treated like this by Pang Hui. However, posterity did not have a high evaluation of Pang Hui's move, because this is something that a small talent will do, "the crime is not as good as the parents, the disaster is not as bad as the wife and children", the matter on the battlefield is solved on the battlefield, and it is really not a gentleman's work to take the elderly and women and children.
In 263, the State of Wei sent a large army to attack shu, with Zhong Hui as the commander and Deng Ai as the deputy.
The Wei army of more than 100,000 people collapsed in Hanzhong, leaving only the three cities of Han, Le, and Jin to hold on, and the rest of the Hanzhong City Pass all fell.
Although Jiang Wei was surrounded by several large armies, he still led his army thousands of miles to the Sword Pavilion Pass and blocked Zhong Hui's army.
Sword Pavilion Pass is the throat of Izukawa, and it is easy to defend and difficult to attack, and the army cannot take it, so Zhong Hui prepares to retreat.
Who knew that at this time, Deng Ai detoured 700 miles, took the river oil directly, defeated Zhuge Zhan, and the soldiers came to Chengdu, and Liu Chan, the lord of the Shu kingdom, surrendered, so the Shu state perished.
After the death of Shu, Zhong Hui falsely accused Deng Ai of rebellion, Deng Ai was arrested, and Zhong Hui took Deng Ai's military power.
With a large army of more than 100,000 troops, plus 50,000 soldiers and horses of Jiang Wei's headquarters, Zhong Hui had 200,000 troops at this time, and his ambitions began to swell, wanting to rebel.
Who knew that the soldiers of the State of Wei were all thinking of returning and did not want to follow Zhong Hui to cause trouble, so there was a mutiny, and both Jiang Wei and Zhong Hui died in the mutiny.
At this time, Pang Hui, who followed Zhong Hui to Shu, took the opportunity to kill Guan Yu's descendants in Chengdu in the name of revenge.
Fortunately, later, the overseer Wei Ou restrained the generals, and the military turmoil was quelled.
However, the descendants of Guan Yu, the famous general of Zhongyi, have all been killed by Pang Hui, how to view Pang Hui's behavior?
Is this an act of loyalty to avenge the Father, or an act of shamelessness in killing the unarmed?
Let's first analyze the authenticity of this matter, Guan Yu's family members are mostly in Jingzhou, and after the fall of Jingzhou, his wife, children, old and young were abducted by Eastern Wu. So who is the family of such a famous figure as Guan Yu in Chengdu? In the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, the whereabouts of Guan Yu's descendants are recorded. Flipping through the books is effortless. Even the great name in the New Book of Tang is related to who is the descendant of the person. Let's calculate that Guan Yi, the son of Guan Xing, probably lived in the era of the fall of the Shu Han Dynasty. Guan Yi is described in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms as being killed by Wei Bing. There is no mention of this person at all. We are very skeptical. There is no biography of Pang Hui in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, and we even doubt whether Pang Hui followed Zhong Hui and Deng Ai into Chuan. The Chronicle of the Three Kingdoms records that Pang Hui and others pursued Jiang Wei.
Why there is a saying that Pang will kill Guan Yu's descendants, its intention is self-evident. Wasn't it the Jin Dynasty's intention to disparage the Shu Han in order to obey Cao Wei?
As far as the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is concerned, it is also impossible for Shu Hanping to push Cao Cao's basic disk.
Politics: The change of the King of Wei was very stable, and Cao Pi had long been made a son of the world. There was no civil unrest in Cao Wei.
Moving the capital: Avoiding its sharp edges, moving the capital has abounded in the past and the present. And there are Several ready-made places in Xuchang and Yecheng that can be used as capitals. Lin Fengxiang's Northern Expedition of the Taiping Heavenly Kingdom also greatly shocked the Qing government, but those who understood a little bit knew that it was not necessary to go deep alone.
Logistics: Cao Wei's Tun Tian was very efficient. Peacetime farming, wartime gathering. Enough to the state. The rest of your own. And the Tuntian of the Shu Han Dynasty is not doing well, and the cultivated land is limited. Cao Cao's team was me farming and I was fighting. The spirit of ownership. Guan Yu's team is, you plant grain for me, I fight. All of this is a wartime economic system.
People's hearts: This is what I want to say most, after nearly 20 years of recuperation in the north, the living environment is relatively stable. The common people hate war from the bottom of their hearts. Was Shu Han really wang shi to liberate the common people in the north?
Military: Guan Yu won both tactical and strategic victories in the Battle of Fancheng. Tactical victory cannot fundamentally change the situation on the battlefield. For example, Fancheng was fenced off. Strategic victories such as flooding the Seventh Army. This down-to-earth siege and reinforcement met strategic expectations. But how many people are there in these seven armies? 10,000 people. Pound's team was no more than a thousand. Such results were compared to the battle of Guandu, which annihilated 70,000 Yuan Shao and defeated Cao Cao by 200,000 at the Battle of Chibi. There was no way to fundamentally shake wei jun's superiority. Jizhou, Qingzhou, Xuzhou, and Yanzhou can also continuously support Fancheng.
Expectation: Guan Yu wanted to fight how large-scale battle he did not think about at the beginning, is it to take Fancheng? Or take advantage of the situation to seize the Central Plains? Thinking of the huge victory of killing 400,000 Zhao troops in the Battle of Changping, and wanting to take advantage of the situation to take the capital of the Zhao state in one fell swoop, the Qin army was defeated and returned. Guan Yu couldn't do better than Bai Qi. Rommel began in North Africa with a leap of miles. Very few troops hit Egypt. But what? The battle line has been stretched. Supplies can't keep up. It's really too easy to be pushed back.
United Front: Chairman Mao said that Guan Yun did not understand the united front in general, and this person was not very clever, and he did not pay attention to the policy of the allied forces. This is not to take Chairman Mao's words as the most reasonable words. Rather, it is to say this truth: who is our friend and who is our enemy. Or who are our temporary friends. Dress up. Guan *River Crab* is a posture that solves Cao Cao's return and then cleans up your Eastern Wu. No one in Eastern Wu would have a heart with Guan Yu.
Personality: I don't want to talk about this. Successful people are right about everything, and failed people start to make a fuss about their personality.
In the past and the present, it was only Liu Bang and Zhu Yuanzhang who really counterattacked. Moreover, these two people are generals with heaven and earth. Liu Bang had Han Xin. Zhu Yuanzhang has Xu Da and often encounters spring. Compared with the above people, Guan Yu is still one level behind. Not much is expected to be achieved in terms of military achievements.
God's perspective is not boring, but there is a different view of the thinking of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms.