Many people felt sorry for Guan Yu, felt that it was not worth it, carelessly lost Jingzhou, Guan Yu and Guan Ping died in battle, thirty years later, Chengdu City was destroyed, Guan Yu's descendants were killed by Pang De's son Pang Hui, not even a remnant was left, it is not tragic!
Some people say that Guan Yu was murdered by Zhuge Liang and Liu Bei for the following reasons:
1. Deliberately withdraw jingzhou troops.
When Liu Bei attacked Liu Zhang, under the pretext of insufficient troops, he requisitioned half of the troops guarding Jingzhou, which was not the end of it, and he also transferred the military master Zhuge Liang away.
Although Guan Yu lacked soldiers and horses, he still had to guard a large area of territory in Jingzhou, because of the lack of troops, there were defensive loopholes everywhere, which undoubtedly gave Lu Xun an opportunity.
After Zhuge Liang, Guan Yu was equal to less of a think tank, and he had to make his own advice on everything, and Guan Yu was a warrior, known for charging into the battlefield, military diplomacy was a weakness, and later finally committed a diplomatic taboo, a sentence "My tiger daughter Can marry a dog", angered Sun Quan.
If Zhuge Liang had been present, this would certainly not have happened, and even if Guan Yu refused to marry his daughter to Sun Quan's son, Zhuge Liang would try his best to appease Sun Quan with his three inches of uncorrupted tongue and let him not do things.
Second, no troops were sent to support Guan Yu.
During the Battle of Xiangfan, Guan Yu and the Cao army were in full swing, and the war reports were frequently sent to Chengdu, and after Liu Bei received the war reports, he neither reminded Guan Yu to pay attention to Eastern Wu, nor did he send a soldier and a pawn to support, nor did he send Zhuge Liang to make suggestions.
After reading the above two points, it seems that Liu Bei really intends to let Guan Yu die, is this really the case?
Absolutely not!
Liu Bei and Guan Yu were brothers and brothers, so how could he cut off an arm? Guan Yu was loyal to Liu Bei and had no second thoughts.
At that time, Cao Cao was so kind to Guan Yu, sending beautiful women, sending red rabbit horses, sending gold, sending clothes, and also asking Emperor Xian of Han to make him the Marquis of Hanshouting, but when Guan Yu heard the news of the eldest brother, he immediately greeted him and left without fighting, looking for the eldest brother to go also!
It can be seen that Guan Yu has a deep affection for Liu Bei.
Guan Yu would not betray Liu Bei, and if he wanted to betray Him, he would not wait until now, and Liu Bei was also assured of Guan Yu's hundred, so he was assured to hand over Jingzhou to him.
At that time, Jingzhou was the land of four wars, Cao Cao was looking at the tiger, Sun Quan had been coveting for a long time, how could Liu Bei not know that when he was anxious to fight with Cao Cao in Hanzhong, the reason why Guan Yu launched the Battle of Xiangfan was also to share Liu Bei's pressure, and everything he did was for Liu Bei, not for himself.
The reason why Liu Bei did not send troops to support was that Chengdu was too far away from Jingzhou, and it was impossible to arrive in a month or two, and it was difficult to quench the thirst of the distant waters; moreover, Liu Bei had just conquered Hanzhong, the troops needed to rest, the grain and grass needed to be prepared, and everything was simply too late.