Miss Shang from Hangzhou originally wanted to make her appearance more attractive, and under the leadership of others, she came to Shanghai Gemkang Medical Beauty Clinic (hereinafter referred to as "Gemkang Medical Beauty") to do rhinoplasty surgery.
Unexpectedly, the nose becomes inflamed after surgery,
In the past two years, Xiao Shang has traveled from place to place, looking for experts, hoping to repair her nose, but experts have said that the possibility of repair is very small, and suggest that Xiao Shang give up repair. This made Xiao Shang feel fiercely depressed, and he endured the psychological pressure of not daring to see people every day.
Listening to the "girlfriend" rhinoplasty result was tragically broken
On the afternoon of December 1, when Xiao Shang came to see Lao Ye's true reporter, he wore a dark mask that covered his entire face, leaving only two eyes under his forehead.
I really don't want to take off my mask and just keep wearing it!
When Xiao Shang took off the mask, he said that there was such a deep "pit" on the tip of the nose, and as soon as he raised his eyes, everyone could see it, and she couldn't cover it without wearing a mask.
The scientific name of this pit is "scar". The diagnosis certificate provided by Xiao Shang of Zhejiang Provincial People's Hospital on December 24, 2020 showed that xiao Shang had a low collapse on the back of his nose and the root of his nose, a sunken puncture mark at the tip of the nose, and the soft tissue scar contracture was more obvious and the elasticity was poor, and the diagnosis was "saddle nose".
▲The hospital diagnosed it as "saddle nose"
Previously, on March 10 of that year, Xiao Shang felt a discomfort in his nose and came to this hospital for treatment. The treatment records show that at that time, the doctor found that the back of her nose was red and swollen, the pressure was fluctuating, the local pain, and the diagnosis was "post-rhinoplasty infection", and the hospital performed nasal implant removal for her under local anesthesia.
Xiao Shang suffered so much pain, and he had to start with a rash move in 2018. In early October of that year, a "girlfriend" asked her to go to Shanghai Rhinoplasty with her, saying that she had a friend at the Shanghai Gemkang Medical Beauty Clinic. Because Xiao Shang had previously told his "girlfriend" that he was not very satisfied with his nose. Xiao Shangyuan wanted the "girlfriend" to do it first, and if it was done well, she would go again. Later, she could not withstand the persuasion of her "girlfriend", so she came to this medical beauty clinic with her "girlfriend" on October 12.
▲ Fan Li medical beauty
During the preoperative examination, Xiao Shang was still good: the nasal root was low and flat, the tip of the nose was hypertrophied, the bilateral nostrils and nostrils were asymmetrical, the nose was not swollen, ruptured, bleeding, the jaw was fat accumulation, the diagnosis was low nose, and the facial jaw fat accumulation.
Shortly after the general anesthesia was done with "rib cartilage rhinoplasty + facial liposuction", Xiao Shang returned to Hangzhou. Xiao Shang's understanding of the operation is like this: the doctor took a small piece of bone from her rib and implanted it at the tip of her nose, and the implants were silicone nose prosthesis and facial prosthesis.
According to Xiao Shang, one month after the operation, her nose began to be red and swollen. She called Gem Kang Medical Beauty, who said that this was a normal postoperative reaction, as long as she took anti-inflammatory drugs and injected anti-inflammatory injections, usually six to eight months can be cured.
So Xiao Shang went to the hospital near his home from time to time to get a drip and anti-inflammatory.
Over time, anti-inflammatory injections could not relieve the symptoms on her nose. At the beginning of September 2019, the prosthesis on Xiao Shang's nose was completely exposed, and she rushed to Shanghai to find Gemkang Medical Aesthetic Treatment, but found that the institution had been renamed "Shanghai Fanli Medical Beauty Clinic", and the medical staff who had previously operated on her were gone.
On September 6, 2019, Fan Li Medical Beauty performed nasal prosthesis removal surgery on Xiao Shang.
When the reporter searched for "Shanghai Gemkang Medical Beauty Clinic Co., Ltd." in Tianyancha, the page jumped out of "Shanghai Gemkang Medical Beauty Clinic Co., Ltd.", and clearly recorded the former as the "historical name" of the latter.
The forensic evaluation found that the medical institution was at fault
After leaving conspicuous scars on his nose, Xiao Shang almost collapsed at first.
I wanted to look better, but I thought I was disfigured! No one can accept this reality!
Xiao Shang said that at the beginning, she did not want to see anyone, once wanted to take her own life, and was persuaded by her friends. A diagnosis provided by Xiao Shang showed that she suffered from major depression.
In June 2020, Xiao Shang sued Fan Li Medical Beauty in court, demanding that the latter compensate for medical expenses, nutrition costs, nursing expenses, lost work expenses, transportation costs, appraisal costs, etc. totaling more than 200,000 yuan.
▲The court ruled
During the trial, the court entrusted an appraisal institution to conduct a judicial appraisal of Xiao Shang's diagnosis and treatment process in accordance with law.
Appraisal opinion written:
The repeated infection of the nose after the identification of XXX performed autologous rib cartilage rhinoplasty + facial liposuction, etc., which was related to the defendant's failure to pay close attention to the infection problems that may occur after the operation and to avoid obligations, and the defendant was at fault for this. After the infection occurred, the defendant was at fault for improper handling, resulting in an extension of the illness and the persistence of the infection. The defendant bears the main responsibility for the consequences of the current damage of the appraisee, and the cause force is about 75%-85%.
The court held that if Xiao Shang suffered damages in the course of diagnosis and treatment, and the medical institution and its medical personnel were at fault, the medical institution shall bear the liability for compensation. According to the appraisal opinion recognized by both parties, the defendant's medical behavior was at fault and the main responsibility, the plaintiff Xiao Shang claimed that the defendant should bear 85% of the compensation liability, while the defendant only recognized 70% of the compensation liability, which combined with the conclusion in the appraisal opinion and the defendant's degree of fault, the size of the causal force and other factors, it was decided that the defendant should bear 80% of the compensation liability for Xiao Shang's losses.
Later, the court pronounced a one-time award of compensation to Xiao Shang for various losses totaling 70,229 yuan.
The invoice provided by Xiao Shang shows that on October 12, 2018, he paid 66,200 yuan of "life service * treatment fee" to Gemkang Medical Beauty, and on September 23, 2019, he paid 710 yuan of "medical service * treatment fee" again, a total of 66,910 yuan.
More than a dozen plastic surgery experts find it difficult to repair
Xiao Shang said that in order to repair the scars on her nose, she has traveled almost all over the best third-class hospitals in China, as well as experts specializing in nose repair in China, and she has also participated in the Shanghai Ninth People's Hospital Special Needs Repair Case Meeting.
More than a dozen plastic surgeons present at the time said that my nose repair was difficult, and the risk was also very large, one operation could not be completed, and the repair process was also very long, so I had better not get it, the risk was too big.
What makes Xiao Shang even more anxious is that the court judgment almost does not mention the costs related to scar repair. The reporter saw from the judgment that the costs involved by the two sides included nutrition costs, nursing fees, lost work costs, transportation costs, appraisal fees and lawyer fees, etc., and indeed did not involve the repair of scars.
On December 9, the reporter came to Fanli Medical Beauty at No. 328 Huashan Road to ask for an interview on Xiao Shang's encounter, but the agency refused.
Source: Thoughtful