The tenth anniversary of this year's "The Voice of China" is really unpredictable, whether it is the lineup of students or mentors, it seems to be changing every day. A few days ago, the lineup of mentors was basically determined, saying that it was Liu Huan, Wang Feng, Li Ronghao and Li Keqin, the four male mentors, plus Zhang Bichen, Yuan Yawei, Ji Kejunyi and Huang Xiaoyun.
However, near the time of recording, another change occurred, and it is said that Liu Huan did not come due to physical reasons and was replaced by Na Ying.
Hooray, here she is again! For Teacher Na Ying, the good voice is the same as the one opened by his own family, all the elders of the Seven Dynasties, oh, no, this year is the Elders of the Eight Dynasties! 10 seasons of good voices, only 2018 and 2020 did not come, great! But I didn't expect her to become the last spare tire this year.
Na Ying replaced Liu Huan, and many netizens expressed disapproval. Over the years, every time Na Ying became a mentor, there was a certain degree of controversy. Part of the controversy may be that some people don't like her, including the remarks involving Daolang in the past; but there are also some people who question Na Ying's vision and ability as a mentor, because she personally eliminated excellent students such as Zhou Shen, Yao Beina, Xilin Nayi Gao, ai Yiliang, and these students have developed well in the circle in the future.
Is Ying's vision so bad? Today we will objectively come to level a "reverse" for her.
From 2012 to 2020, 9 seasons of Good Voice produced 9 overall champions, of which Na Ying sat in 7 seasons and brought out 3 champions (Liang Bo, Zhang Bichen, Zhang Lei). If nothing else, this ratio is already proud. After all, Haring sat in 6 seasons and Jay Chou sat in 4 seasons without bringing out a championship.
So, what happened to the championships she brought out? The 9 champions of The Voice, who is the most popular in the music world in the end? Something like this:
Zhang Bichen> Liang Bo> Shan Yichun> Others (Li Qi, Zhang Lei, Jiang Dunhao, Tashi Phuntsok, Danzin Nyima, Xing Hanming)
From the above, it can be seen that the first two of the redest are still Na Ying's students after all; the next 6, including 1 of na Ying's group, are almost reduced to ordinary beings.
As for the students other than the champions, in addition to the popular students in the first season, there are more popular students, and yuan Yawei, Ping An, Ji Ke Junyi, and Jin Zhiwen have come out. In the next 8 seasons, since there are not even a few red champions, students other than champions are even less popular, probably Zhou Shen, Yao Beina, XilinNayi Gao, Ai Yiliang and Huang Xiaoyun.
We were surprised to find that these red beads, except for Huang Xiaoyun, who were Wang Feng's students, the first few were precisely Na Ying's students. From another point of view, doesn't this just prove that Na Ying's vision is very poisonous? Hong's basics are all primary second class students, but she can't send everyone to the championship throne.
Liang Bo
Looking at all the students of Good Voice, from the perspective of singing strength and long-term development potential in the music world, in fact, I think the first person in the ranking is liang Bo, the first good voice champion. There were many excellent students at that time, and Na Ying attached great importance to the young and old Liang Bo, and brought out the champion in a "free-range" manner;
After winning the championship, Liang Bo did not follow suit, and he was not as good as those students who ranked low. But years later, it turned out that Na Ying did not look away at the beginning, and taking him to the championship position was the most worthwhile thing.
Yao Beina
When Yao Beina and Xuanxuan fought, Na Ying eliminated Yao Beina. In terms of strength, Yao Beina certainly has nothing to say, and under normal circumstances, the champion is none other than her. At that time, Yao Beina did not sing the best, and then some people questioned that Na Ying intended to dig a hole for her in the selection of songs, so as to eliminate her in the group competition and prevent her from entering the final.
Whether it is intentional to dig a pit is difficult to say, at the same time, the program team does not let Yao Beina win the championship is also expected, after all, Yao Beina is already a mature signed singer, not the object of the production party. Even if Yao Beina was hacked, she couldn't rely on Na Ying.
Zhou Shen
After Zhou Shen became popular, many fans began to mock Na Ying for not knowing the goods. In fact, there is no need, I believe that Zhou Shen is also grateful in his heart. There are too many accidental factors in an artist's popularity, and not every powerful person has the opportunity to become popular. You can't say that Zhou Shenhong is a treasure destined to be red, and Li Wei's obscurity so far proves that he is only a generalist.
At that time, Zhou Shen and Li Wei were put together, and if one had to be eliminated, it would be a dilemma decision for any tutor. Li Wei's voice is indeed a treasure, but it is not the same type as Zhou Shen, and the ethereal spirit of Zhou Shen's voice allows him to cross the gender boundary, while Li Wei does not, but it is also extreme enough. As a female singer, Na Ying finally tearfully chose Li Wei and gave up Zhou Shen after tangling and nearly collapsing, which is also understandable. Elimination is not equal to denial, the palms of the hands and the backs of the hands are all meat, and no matter how cruel the format is, there must always be trade-offs.
Ai Yiliang
Ai Yiliang is also a Naying student in the same season as Zhou Shen, she went further than Zhou Shen, and lost to another student Chen Bing when she was PK in the group. At that time, when Ai Yiliang was eliminated, there were also doubts on the Internet, saying that Na Ying gave Chen Bing the most brilliant SOLO part of the song, and also designed a transposition and treble for her, carefully guided, and was not so attentive to Ai Yiliang. It means that Na Ying intends to black Ai Yiliang out.
Some people also say that because Ai Yiliang is Luo Dayou's apprentice, and Na Ying and Luo Dayou had an unpleasant experience with their original mentor Luo Dayou in this season, they deliberately eliminated his apprentice.
Hey, in fact, Chen Bing is not bad, the two have their own characteristics, PK well always win or lose, the outside world speculation is not enough, I don't think that Na Ying is such a sinister person who must be rewarded. Moreover, if it were not for Ai Yiliang winning the Best Female Singer Award at the Taiwan Golden Melody Awards later, perhaps everyone would not have questioned Na Ying's vision again a few years later, and winning the Golden Melody Award had little to do with the elimination of the original competition, Ai Yiliang himself also publicly said "I will always only be grateful to that sister!" ”
Shirinayi Gao
Xi linnayi was a student in the British group of "New Song 2" in 2017, when she lost to Guo Qin in the championship battle in the group, and passed by the finals. There were not many strong students in that season, but most of them were in the British group, such as Guo Qin, Xilin Nayi, and Ye Xuanqing, but the final overall champion was Tashi Pingcuo of Liu Huan's group. Liu Huan returned to a good voice after a few years, and it seems impossible to say otherwise.
I remember that when the battle in the Naying group was fought, Na Ying invited the three champions of the second class and Zhou Shen to come to help. Xi Lin Nayi first defeated Li Ya by an absolute advantage with the help of Liang Bo, but lost to Guo Qin by 7 points in the second round.
This time should not have attracted much doubt, but 3 years later, Xilin Nayi participated in the singing and dancing draft again and debuted in the C position, becoming the captain of the girl group "Hard Candy Girl 303", so many people once again questioned Na Ying's vision.
This is also not a crime, one is a pure singing draft, one is a singing and dancing girl group draft, there is no comparison. Can't say that because Xilinayi debuted in the C position here, she should have won the championship in The Voice, right?
In general, Na Ying sat in the good voice 7 times and became the champion mentor 3 times; in a 9 good voice champions who were more than a paste, she had at least 2 champion students who developed well; even among the students who had been eliminated by her, there were multiple headwinds... All these achievements just prove that Na Ying's vision and ability are no problem, and she is an excellent mentor!
So this year, can Na Ying continue to be brilliant and bring out the fourth champion student? We'll see.