laitimes

"Water Margin": Is Gongsun Sheng's departure from the team twice really inconsistent with Song Jiang's concept?

author:Chivalry said

Ancient Chinese novels like to combine some stories with gods and strange things to write, the four famous novels are all like this, "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" has Zuo Ci, Yu Ji and others used immortal magic to tease Cao Cao, Sun Ce and other descriptions, "Journey to the West" needless to say that the whole novel is written in the form of myths and legends, "Dream of Red Mansions" also has the marriage between Shen Ying and Jiangzhu Xiancao in the previous life, "Water Margin", a novel about heroes in the rivers and lakes, actually has a plot of immortal magic and demon fighting. And in "Water Margin", Sun Sheng, the dragon prince of Zhuyun, is almost a half-immortal character.

"Water Margin": Is Gongsun Sheng's departure from the team twice really inconsistent with Song Jiang's concept?

Speaking of the character of Gongsun Sheng, he is also an earlier character in the novel, and he is also one of the founders of Liangshan's career. At the beginning, Chao Gai and others outwitted the Birth Gang, Gongsun Sheng was one of the initiators, and he also followed Chao Gai and others to Shuibo Liangshan to join the gang, participated in the fight against Wang Lun, and pushed the Liangshan cause to a new stage together. However, Gongsun Sheng is also one of the few heroes in Liangshan who finally died well, thanks to Gongsun Sheng's understanding of the overall situation and the general situation, it can be said that Gongsun Sheng knows how to advance and retreat, of course, this has a lot to do with Gongsun Sheng himself being a cultivator and having a powerful master. It is worth mentioning that Gongsun Sheng left the team twice on his own initiative, and never came back after leaving the team for the second time, and it was this time that he left the team so that he could have a good ending. Speaking of Gongsun Sheng's two departures from the team, it is quite a coincidence, the first time he left the team was when Song Jiang took his father and brother to Liangshan after going up the mountain, and the second time he left the team was when Song Jiang led the heroes of Liangshan to successfully conquer Wang Qing. Therefore, many friends on the Internet think that the reason why Gongsun Sheng left the team is that he saw through the essence of Song Jiang, or that he is fundamentally different from Song Jiang in concept. But if we look closely at the description in the novel, there seems to be no such description.

The first time he left the team, not long after Song Jiang went to Liangshan, he also went to Yuncheng County to pick up his father and brother up the mountain. At this time, not only Gongsun Sheng left the team, but there was also one person who left the team briefly, and that was Li Kui. The difference between the two people is that Li Kui left the team to take his old mother to Liangshan, while Gongsun Sheng took the opportunity to visit his mother and never returned. Leaving the team for the second time, Song Jiang led the heroes of Liangshan to send out to Wang Qing, and successfully escorted Wang Qing to Tokyo, but Gongsun Sheng never came back, and when leaving Song Jiang, he said: "Tell the Japanese Shi Luo Zhenren to send his brother back to Beijing, and then return to the mountains." Today, the elder brother has become famous, and the poor road will say goodbye to the benevolent brother today, bid farewell to everyone, and return to the mountains, learn the Tao from the teacher, and serve the old mother for the rest of the year. It can be seen that Gongsun Sheng left the team for two reasons: first, Gongsun Sheng's master Luo Zhenren had already said that he wanted him to return to the mountains to cultivate; second, Gongsun Sheng wanted to go home to serve his mother and send his mother to death. In this, Gongsun Sheng did not have the slightest dissatisfaction with Song Jiang, and when Song Jiang kept Gongsun Sheng, Gongsun Sheng also said: "If Xiaodao leaves Brother Ren halfway, it is unkind." Now that Brother Ren has become famous, he has to give permission. "What's more, in Liangshan, Gongsun Sheng also made great contributions to Liangshan's defeat of Gao Yu, if Gongsun Sheng is dissatisfied with Song Jiang, there is no need to do this, even if he wants to leave the team, he can float away, and he can not have any explanation for Song Jiang.

"Water Margin": Is Gongsun Sheng's departure from the team twice really inconsistent with Song Jiang's concept?

But this is not the case, and it can be seen that Gongsun Sheng's departure is not due to a difference in his philosophy from Song Jiang. So why is this? If we look at the positioning of Gongsun Sheng in "Water Margin", we seem to be able to see some clues. In the novel, Gongsun Sheng is one of the 108 generals, corresponding to Tianxian Xing. What is Tianxian Star? It is considered to be idle, and it will not be busy because of the world, even if it is for the great cause of Liangshan. Later, Shijie fell from the sky, and 108 will be ranked, and Gongsun Sheng is indeed a Tianxian star. Therefore, Gongsun Sheng did not participate much in the big and small battles of Liangshan, although Gongsun Sheng had high Taoist skills, he basically did not make a move, and he only shot when the other party appeared a mage. He is like Liang Shan's big killer move, and he doesn't make a move easily.

In addition, Gongsun Sheng is a Taoist priest, and the Taoist priest pays attention to leisure meditation and cultivation, if he has been in Liangshan, often facing fights and killings, he will not be able to cultivate the Tao. So, Gongsun Sheng went down the mountain for the first time.

"Water Margin": Is Gongsun Sheng's departure from the team twice really inconsistent with Song Jiang's concept?

As for the second descent from the mountain, it was because the master had warned him, "Stop when you meet the seclusion, and return when you encounter the river", because the destiny of heaven cannot be violated. If Gongsun Sheng does not leave after Song Jiang successfully conquers Wang Qing, he will definitely participate in the conquest of Fang La in the future, and Liangshan will definitely be able to lose some generals, but this will violate the mandate of heaven, which is very particular about the mandate of heaven in ancient novels, which is the setting of the original book.

In short, no matter from which aspect, Gongsun Sheng left the team twice before and after, and it had nothing to do with Song Jiang, and there was nothing different from Song Jiang's philosophy. Even Gongsun Sheng's master, Luo Zhenren, said that Song Jiang was a person who was loyal to the country and did the right thing for heaven, so how could Gongsun Sheng go against his master's view? If Gongsun Sheng and Song Jiang's so-called concept do not agree, with his skills, let alone killing Song Jiang, even if he raised his hand, Liangshan would also be reduced to ashes. Even if it is not good, it is okay to hide in a place where others can't find it, Gongsun Sheng really wants to hide, with his ability, how could Dai Zong and Li Kui find it.

"Water Margin": Is Gongsun Sheng's departure from the team twice really inconsistent with Song Jiang's concept?

What do you think?

Read on