There are at least two versions of "Water Margin", the ancient book is basically the same as the first seventy chapters of the popular version, and the last fifty chapters are completely different: "Ancient Water Margin" has neither Song Jiang being recruited, nor Wu Song's broken arm and Lu Zhishen's sitting.
At the beginning of the last century, Du Yuesheng, Huang Jinrong, and Zhang Xiaolin had moved the tomb of Wu Song, they had seen it from the gap in the coffin, but they did not say that Wu Song was missing an arm, on August 4, 2014, Wu Song's tomb was splashed with paint by a person who did not have the surname Ximen, and the first day committed the crime, and was arrested the next day, and I don't know what to do in the end.
Wu Song does have his own person in history, Song Jiang has been recorded in the "History of the Song Dynasty" more than once, whether it is a popular version or an ancient book, there are at least thirty-six of the one hundred and eight generals in Liangshan who have really existed, and even Song Jiang's self-described "Nine Heavens Xuannu Heavenly Book" is also described in the historical materials and notes written by the people of the Song Dynasty: "Song Jiang only unfolded and saw it, and recognized it as a book of heaven, and wrote thirty-six names, and inscribed four sentences, the poem said: Breaking the country because of the mountains and trees, the sabre and the water worker; ”
Whether Song Jiang has met the Nine Heavens Xuannu, whether the Book of Heaven is true or false, the Taoist masters who have always persuaded the world to "believe in science" will definitely give more interesting answers, even readers who don't believe in science will laugh when they see Song Jiang telling how he ate fairy dates, drank fairy wine, and obtained heavenly books in the Nine Heavens Xuannu Palace: Isn't this Chen Sheng Wu Guang's bonfire fox song, Yuan Shu's "Acting for the Han Dynasty should be Tu Gao"?
Yuan Shu wrote the word highway, Song Jiang character Gongming, Yuan Shu arrogated the emperor, and Song Jiang wrote anti-poems. Proverbs and the Book of Heaven are just a means for the heroes (Yuan Shu and Song Jiang do not seem to be the heroes) to gather people's hearts, and Mr. Li Zhuowu has a deep comment on the appearance of the Book of Heaven and Shi Jie: "Liang Shanbo is like Li Kui, Wu Song, and Lu Zhishen's class, they are all reckless men, and if they don't fool him with ghosts and gods, how can they make him die to the ground? ”
Li Zhuowu knew that Song Jiang and Wu Yonggongsun Sheng teamed up to fake, and the heroes of Liangshan at that time were not without suspicions, Jade Qilin Lu Junyi, Dadao Guan Sheng Guan Sheng, Double Whip Hu Yanzhuo Hu Yanzhuo, Golden Gunner Xu Ning, Choujun Ma Xuanzan, and Jing Mu Qian Hao Siwen had teamed up to challenge Song Jiang, and the name "Observation" was actually falsified, which almost made Song Jiang completely exposed.
After all, Song Jiang was the first thick-faced and black-bellied person in Liangshan, and he secretly ordered his henchmen to sing an empty city plan, which immediately blocked the mouths of Lu Junyi and the five former court officers.
How Lu Junyi and Guan Sheng and the others got to Liangshan, the description of the ancient book and the passage book of the Water Margin is completely consistent, so it is logical for Lu Junyi and the five officers to take action.
In the ancient book of the Water Margin, Lu Junyi discussed with a group of officers, including Qin Ming, who did not include the thunderbolt fire, and the Dadao Guan Sheng applied on behalf of everyone: "The younger brother also knows the gods and goddesses of the Heavenly Book, and they should not be taken lightly, but they are so different that they can't help themselves, and they don't know what the Heavenly Book says, and what is the wonder?
Hao Siwen beat the side drum and blocked Song Jiang's retreat: "Our brothers are named Shijie, people who belong to the same society, blessings and misfortunes depend on each other, life and death are shared, and there is no difference in heart, and we are one and the same. This time I seek to view the heavenly book, they are all benevolent and righteous brothers, people in the heavens and earths, and if they think of the goddess spirit of the Nine Heavens, they must not be held responsible. ”
If you want to say that Lu Junyi, Guan Sheng and others have not gone through the rehearsal in advance, it is estimated that even Song Jiang will not believe it: these six people have a little festival with me, but they talk without leaking a drop of water, if I refuse them to read the Book of Heaven, they will say that the Book of Heaven is pure fiction, and promise them to watch it? What will I show them!
The description of the first seventy chapters of the ancient book and the popular version is basically the same, and there is no circumstantial evidence for Song Jiang to "obtain the Book of Heaven", it is all his own words, and it is contradictory: "Niangniang's law decrees: 'These three volumes of the book can be well observed and familiarized. It can only be viewed with the Celestial Machine, and nothing else is visible. (After returning to Liangshan) Song Jiang and Chao Gai had a daily feast in the village, drank happily, and read the book of heaven with Wu Xuexue. ”
Seeing this, the question came out: when Song Jiang escaped from Huandao Village and returned to Liangshan, there were still dozens of one hundred and eight generals who did not go to Liangshan, and the stone jie was not carved, how did Song Jiang know that Wu Yong was Tianji Xing?
It stands to reason that Song Jiang drank immortal wine and ate immortal dates, it should be that all poisons do not invade and all diseases do not live, but after Chao Gai was inexplicably killed by an arrow, Song Jiang almost hung up on his back, and Chao Gai's words in Song Jiang's dream are also very interesting: "Now that the matter on his back has happened, only the Jiangnan Earth Spirit Star can be spared, and my brother once said: 'Thirty-six strategies, go is the best policy. 'What more should you do if you don't go away now?' if you make a mistake, what can you do? ”
Some versions delete the words "now the matter on my back has been released", but there are some in the commentary of Li Zhuowu, Jin Shengsi, Wang Wangru, Yu Xiangdou and others, and Chao Gai may have just said the words "the incident on his back" to Song Jiang, and the other words may have been made up by Song Jiang, which is called thinking about it day and night, and Song Jiang pleaded guilty when he saw Chao Gai in his dream, which also shows that he has a ghost in his heart: "Where did my brother come from? Revenge has never been avenged, and the center is restless day and night; and because there have been events for days, he has never offered sacrifices; and today's manifestation will be responsible." ”
Jin Shengsi's comments are more than Song Jiang's original words, and every word says that Chao Gai's death is difficult for Song Jiang to escape, and Chao Gai's dream this time is just to repay Song Jiang's favor.
Song Jiang has at least two or three faces, and it is like learning Sichuan opera for more than ten years, he suddenly "dares to laugh at Huang Chao's husband", and suddenly "looks at the king of heaven to send an edict to recruit peace early, and his heart is full", which made Lu Zhishen and Wu Song confused, and Lu Junyi, Guan Sheng and others could not help but have doubts, so there was the fact that Lu Junyi and the five officers wanted to "observe (check)" the Xuannu Book of Heaven.
Realistically speaking, the IQ and EQ of Song Jiang in time are among the top among the one hundred and eight generals in Liangshan, although they are not as old and spicy as Cai Jingzhi, but they are more than enough to deal with the rich man Lu Junyi and those former court officers who surrendered thieves to save their lives.
Just when Lu Junyi, Guan Sheng and others thought that Song Jiang had been forced into a corner and had no way to retreat, Song Jiang rolled on the spot and came to the spot: "What the two virtuous brothers said is extremely true, how can the foolish brother not allow it, and wait for the auspicious day to come, everyone will be bathed, and then enter the palace to watch." ”
Which day is an auspicious day, it has to be decided by Song Jiang. Finally waited for Song Jiang's notice, Lu Junyi, Guan Sheng and others took incense and bathed, ready to watch the book of heaven under the guidance of Song Jiang, but saw the minions guarding the Xuannu Palace running to the ground and reporting: "Suddenly, a gust of incense blew on the ground, and there was a golden light in the wind, which went straight into the library pavilion, and I saw a monster, shaped like a big bird, flying out of the pavilion and rushing to the sky, I don't know what the omen was." ”
What happened later, not to mention that everyone can guess, Song Jiang's acting skills were exerted to the extreme at this time, and Wu Yong, a gold medal supporting role, also performed very well: "Song Jiang was surprised: 'How can there be such a thing?' Wu Yongdao: 'Don't fight for the Xuan Nu Niangniang to appear again?' (After discovering that the heavenly book in the box was missing) Song Jiang was like earth below, and Wu Yong was dumbfounded. ”
Song Jiang's performance was even more wonderful than Zhuge Liang's singing of the empty city plan in Xicheng: "Trembling, I burned incense in front of the goddess Xuan, kowtowed and apologized." ”
Song Jiang put the responsibility for the "disappearance of the Book of Heaven" on Lu Junyi and Guan Sheng and other six people, and also threatened them: "I think Niang Niang was angry with me for disobeying my fate, and suddenly took the Book of Heaven to show punishment, I don't know if the gods will punish them in the future?"
Lu Junyi, Guan Sheng and the others sighed and dispersed helplessly, and Song Jiang's empty city plan was a great success, which also left readers with several questions that were difficult to answer: Is Song Jiang's Xuannu Book of Heaven true or false? If Lu Junyi and Guan Sheng did not give Song Jiang the opportunity to prepare, and directly rushed into the "Xuannu Palace" where the "Book of Heaven was enshrined", how could Song Jiang justify himself?