Introduction: Caught alive? Zhu Di did not dare, because the banner played by Zhu Di, the King of Yan, was the side of the Qing Dynasty. The purpose of the rebellion was the treacherous Huang Zicheng and the like next to his nephew Zhu Yunjiao of the Qing Dynasty. Therefore, he certainly did not dare to kill Zhu Yunjiao on the surface, but he did not dare to let Zhu Yunjiao go. Because as long as Zhu Yunjiao was in the position of emperor, he could punish Zhu Di for this rebellion at any time. Therefore, the best way should be to let Zhu Yunjiao leave the edict of "Zen Position", and then imprison him in the same way as the change of the door or imitate the song Taizong Zhao Guangyi to first seal a high-ranking official and then get a sudden violent death a few years later. Maybe Emperor Jianwen's death in the fire or a long way overseas is a good ending, at least for both uncles and nephews to leave a step back. However, this left Zhu Di with hidden worries about usurping the throne, so Xu Huizu, Fang Xiaoru and others have always accused Zhu Di of being in an improper position.
The background of the outbreak of the "Battle of Jingnan" by Zhu Di, the King of Yan, was:
The emperor of the Ming Dynasty was in charge of the government, and the pattern of dividing the town and the fence for the emperor as a relative was a rule left by the old man of Zhu Yuanzhang, the ancestor of the Ming Dynasty. In the eyes of this Hongwu Wanzai, any confidant minister was not as reliable as his own family, so he went against the tide and divided the world into the kings of the clan. After the death of crown prince Zhu Biao, in order to protect the emperor's grandson Zhu Yunjiao, who was selected according to the ancestral training, ascended the throne of Ming Taizu and set off three major cases. In the case of countless meritorious generals being killed one after another, Zhu Yuanzhang willingly put the heavy responsibility of assisting Emperor Jianwen on the king of the domain. Perhaps he did not have to make up for the picture of the lord between the king of the clan and the emperor of Jianwen, but the irony is that neither the emperor jianwen nor the king of the clan did act according to the script set by Zhu Yuanzhang.
At the suggestion of Huang Zicheng, who was both a Master of Confucianism and an emotional intelligence stick, the Jianwen Emperor Zhu Yunjiao came to power without saying a word and vigorously began a simple and rough forceful withdrawal of the domain. The kings of Zhou, Qi, Xiang, Dai, and Min were successively deposed as Shuren, and Zhu Yunjiao personally broke the ancestral precepts. The DaiWang was placed under house arrest, and the Xiang King set himself on fire with his family. The tragic image of the slashing of the clan made the kings of the clan want to move, and it should be known that the ming dynasty clan kings at this time had soldiers and generals and armies.
In particular, Zhu Di, the King of Yan, who was the head of all the princes of the clans, bore the brunt of the attack and became the first target of Emperor Jianwen's attack. PS: The eldest prince Zhu Biao died, and the second and third elders died early. Therefore, Zhu Di, the fourth oldest king of Yan, became the head of the kings of the various domains. Emperor Jianwen's simple and crude realization of cutting the domain was also purely a brain-dead act, and there was an example of the Xiang King, and the kings of the clan inevitably died of rabbits and foxes. Therefore, under the suggestion of Yao Guangxiao, Zhu Di, the King of Yan, raised an army in the name of "Qing Jun's side, Jingnei Difficulty" to launch the Battle of Jingnan. Note that this slogan is the slogan of almost all the kings of the clan who started the civil war, and has been used since the Rebellion of the Seven Kingdoms. More crucially, it is fully in line with the provisions of the Ming Emperor's ancestral training on the responsibility of the king of the domain: to assist the emperor in eliminating adulterers. Therefore, Zhu Di's army can also be regarded as a famous division, and cannot be regarded as a rebellion.
After Zhu Di raised his army, he followed the attitude of his uncle and nephew towards each other
The talent of Zhu Di, the King of Yan, is obvious to all, and even Zhu Yuanzhang insists that "those who are different from the country will be the King of Yan." Of course, Zhu Yuanzhang did not expect the final outcome, but there was no problem in recognizing the ability of the Yan King. Coupled with the persecution of Emperor Jianwen, the capable and courageous King Yan raised an army.
We will not dwell on the process or the focus of this article, let's look at the attitudes of each other. Zhu Di's banner was the Qing Jun's side, which meant that it was not aimed at Zhu Yunjiao; and Emperor Jianwen's explicit order to the forward troops was not to harm the emperor. It seems that the family has no problem, but how did this battle start? That is to say, no matter how much the uncles and nephews hate each other in their hearts, they cannot verbally express that this is the imperial power.
But let's speculate on the outcome of What if Zhu Di was defeated. If Zhu Di was defeated and captured, then the King of Yan would definitely be cut down. Then there will definitely be a full door full of people who will be killed for the crime of rebellion, otherwise the other clan kings will not calmly accept the result of cutting the clan and raise an army (anyway, there will be no problem).
After the success of zhu dijing, the king of Yan, if he really grasped the analysis of several attitudes held by Emperor Jianwen
The comparison of the old emperor Emperor Ming Zuxun by the courtiers found that the original Yan King Zhu Di also conformed to the plot of the ancestral training. That is to say, this is a family affair, not a national war. Coupled with the attitudes of Zhu Di and Zhu Yunjiao's uncle and nephew, they all made the ministers very entangled. The result of the Jing disaster is very clear to us, Emperor Jianwen set himself on fire. So let's speculate about the outcome if Emperor Jianwen was captured alive:
The first, if you plan to murder, you will never be caught alive, but take advantage of the chaos to let Emperor Jianwen die in the rebellion and then push out the scapegoat to face the crime. Second, forcing Zhu Yunjiao to ascend the throne is reasonable and legal, which is relatively reasonable. The third is to let Emperor Jianwen exist in the form of a puppet and find an opportunity to attack. The fourth is this situation in history, where Emperor Jianwen 's "self-immolation" is actually unknown. Therefore, even if Zhu Di did not kill the king, the usurpation of the throne was still resisted by Fang Xiaoru, Xu Huizu and others. This is one of the reasons why Zhu Di had to complete the relocation of the capital even after many years of being called emperor.
brief summary:
To sum up, if Zhu Di really captured Emperor Jianwen alive and killed him directly on the surface, he would not dare to. According to the speculation of the editor, there are roughly the above three situations, but no matter which situation will not completely convince the people of the world. Therefore, Even if Zhu Di had been in power in Nanjing for many years, he was not at ease, and eventually moved the capital to Beijing.
I am the emperor of history, welcome your attention; if there is a flaw, the axe is right.