"Water Margin" is a story about the rebellion of the people during the Song Dynasty, in the world of Water Margin, everyone is described as flesh and blood, we are often moved by their loyalty, everyone will be happy when they go to Liangshan, and we will be happy every battle victory.
In the "Water Margin", the leader of Liangshan is Song Jiang, who was originally a court official, but because he was framed by someone to lead to Liangshan, so Song Jiang always hoped to make some famous names through the uprising, and then join the imperial court, it can be said that he already had the idea of participating in Zhao'an from the moment he went to Liangshan.
Song Jiang made many friends through his generosity, it can be said that many people on Liangshan are willing to join the company because of his name, and Song Jiang also unites the good men of Liangshan from all over the world through his personality charm. But it is such a big brother who leads the good han of Liangshan to recruit security, but in the end it leads to the death and scattering of the Liangshan people, so we all hate Song Jiang's cowardice and incompetence, but if we seriously think about it, if Song Jiang does not recruit security, what will the fate of Liangshan be?
First, the Song Dynasty was strong and powerful
Although we can often see in the "Water Margin" that the good han of Liangshan led the army to win the army of the regular imperial court, but in fact, these battles are some local armies that are not strong in combat effectiveness, if the Song Dynasty really attaches importance to Liangshan, it will send a strong army to encircle and suppress, such as the Western Army, there are many powerful good men in Liangshan who come out of the Western Army, and the victory or defeat is not necessarily the same.
And at the time of the Liangshan uprising, Yue Fei and others in the Song Dynasty had already emerged in the army, so if Liangshan encountered such a famous general as Yue Fei, the victory or defeat was not certain. Once the Liangshan army lost, they had no way to retreat, so when the good men on Liangshan had only one way to die, if they followed Song Jiang zhao'an, they might still have a chance to live.
And the imperial court will not wait for Liangshan to strengthen its own power, and will definitely extinguish it in its infancy before the flames rise. Although the imperial court said that they were officials, in fact, the darkness inside the imperial court was unimaginable to Song Jiang, so his brothers were killed one by one, how could some people from grassy backgrounds fight the old fox of the imperial court?
Second, Liangshan is not united internally
There are many good men in Liangshan who revolted to break the unequal treatment, but there are also those who are forced to go to Liangshan, for example, there are many people who have to go to Liangshan because they have to go to Liangshan because of their entire families. There are also some pits and deceptions to find people to go up the mountain, themselves they are not a right way to be a mountain thief, and Song Jiang is certainly not the only one in Liangshan who submits to the imperial court, so if Liangshan is defeated, human nature will be exposed, and when everyone is pregnant with ghosts, the end of Liangshan will not be certain.
So on the whole, no matter which road the good men of Liangshan choose to submit to Zhao'an, the final outcome will be defeat, although the Song Dynasty lost more than a few foreign wars, but it is still okay to attack a small mountain thief, so if you do not recruit An, the end will only have two words: annihilation. It's just the same destination.