The scene of the trial
Editor's note: At 9:30 on February 16, the second instance trial of Jiang Ge's mother Jiang Qiulian v. Liu Nuanxi (formerly known as Liu Xin) in the dispute over the right to life was held in the Qingdao Intermediate Court, and Liu Xin, who had not appeared before, personally appeared in court, while Jiang Qiulian did not appear in court for physical reasons. Liu Xin's lawyer is Hu Guiyun, and Jiang Qiulian's lawyer is Huang Leping. Liu Xin believes that he is not at fault and should not bear civil compensation liability. After nearly four hours of trial, the court announced an adjournment and adjourned the verdict at a later date. At about 18:00 on the same day, Liu Xin appeared in the conference room of a hotel near the court to participate in the press conference organized by the supporters who claimed to be witnesses, "My witnesses have been preparing for me for a long time since the beginning, staying up late with us and preparing together, the court will not let her testify, I am not very acceptable, tonight please listen carefully to some of the things she knows and understands." Liu Xin left 40 minutes after the reporter meeting began, cutting off with witnesses outside the words? Witnesses are questioned about their chickens and dogs, and the scene is angry that female reporters don't like to listen to you go? Jiang Qiulian's not appearing in court is a lawyer's strategy? The lawyer is not allowed to take pictures at the first meeting, and is most worried that Jiang Qiulian is a paranoid woman? How about the details, Xiaobian will analyze it immediately!
Jiang Qiulian did not appear in court due to ill health
40 minutes after the reporter meeting began, Liu Xin left, and cut off the witnesses outside the words? Liu Xin said at the press conference, "Regarding the witnesses, her testimony, I did not ask her or understand her before the trial. Xiaobian saw here and thought, Liu Xin is actually drawing a clear line with the "witness", implying that he did not know what the "witness" was going to say beforehand, and what happened to the "witness" in the future needed to be responsible for himself. But xiaobian has another confusion in his heart, didn't he still apply to let this witness appear in court? Don't know what she's going to say, let her be a witness and still appear in a serious courtroom? What about the law? Is the court the door of your house and you can enter it? The "witness's" statement was repeatedly questioned by the media at the scene, and Liu Xin left the scene 40 minutes after the meeting began.
Liu Xin (right) and "witnesses" (left)
Witnesses are questioned about their chickens and dogs, and the scene is angry that female reporters don't like to listen to you go? After Liu Xin left, the reporter will become a "witness" one-man show, which lasted more than an hour, I believe that many netizens are like the editor, before looking at it, they felt curious to think that there was a big news to explode, and after watching it, they felt that it was a waste of time, no wonder the court rejected the application of this "witness" to appear in court. Most of the media present listened impatiently, and if you had a real hammer, you would let it go, pulling around, "Is your current statement a witness identity?" "Your name?" "As a witness, please present your evidence, instead of questioning the previous verdict..." I didn't expect the "witness" to have a big temper, and after a small dispute with a female reporter, he angrily rebuked, "You don't like to listen, you can go out, I told other reporters!" ”
Jiang Ge (left) and Jiang Qiulian once had a happy time
Jiang Qiulian's not appearing in court is a lawyer's strategy? After the trial, Jiang Qiulian, who did not appear in court, posted on social media to thank her lawyer Huang Leping, "You and Lawyer Li have worked hard, all the way safe!" Lawyer Huang replied, "Thank you! You can also take a good rest. Xiaobian believes that Jiang Qiulian's non-appearance in court is a strategy given by the lawyer, because from Liu Xin's appeal, it can be seen that there is no valuable supplementary evidence, and the possibility of maintaining the original judgment is greater, and Jiang Qiulian appeared in court to see Liu Xin If she cannot control her emotions, it will bring hidden dangers to the situation of stable victory. Xiaobian also believes that she does not appear in court, and it is appropriate for a lawyer to deal with it. You must know that huang Leping was most worried about Jiang Qiulian's emotions when he considered whether to take over the case!
Liu Xin's lawyer, Hu Guiyun
The lawyer is not allowed to take pictures at the first meeting, and is most worried that Jiang Qiulian is a paranoid woman? Lawyer Huang Leping broke the news, "The first time we met on September 23, 2019, we were very cautious and said in advance that we were not allowed to take pictures. Before the meeting, I learned from the media that Ms. Jiang Qiulian was somewhat of a humble woman, and the perception was not particularly good, although I was very sympathetic to her. Since I started my career, I have seen too many petitioners and more paranoid defenders, and even some people have kneeled down when they see me, saying that I will not get up if you do not represent my case. This is a public case, and if she were a very paranoid and uncontrollable party, I would not have to take up her case, because the result would only be a failure of previous achievements. We met again on September 28. Ms. Jiang's two expressions are basically consistent and logical, including her propositions and emotions, without obvious changes, and can withstand our questions. Therefore, I think that Ms. Jiang is more likely to be more rational. ”
Lawyer Huang Leping (left) and Jiang Qiulian