The comparison of the value of force between the fierce generals is an eternal topic for the majority of fans of the Three Kingdoms, and the work "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" provides everyone with a variety of talking points for evidence of different views.
Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are both brothers of Taoyuan Jieyi and both Shu Han
"Five Tiger Admirals"
, the same is invincible
"Ten Thousand Enemies"
, also on the three-point force ranking list
"Super Smash Bros.
Who among them has better martial arts is a matter of concern to everyone. Because the views and evidence presented are particularly valid, they are often controversial.
In fact, through the content of the original work, we can all be sure that if the five tiger generals of the Shu Han Dynasty fight each other, it is often a stalemate battle, and the strength of the lilies is equal, and no one can help each other, just like Guan Yu outside Changsha City vs. Huang Zhong, And Zhang Fei fights ma Chao under Ye Meng Guan, and the difference in the value of force between them is very small, and it is difficult to distinguish between them.
But we also have to admit that the equivalent of martial arts does not mean that the results are the same, and the performance on the battlefield is still very different. Guan Yu was good at beheading famous generals, Hua Xiong, Guan Hai, Che Ji, Yan Liang, Wen Ugly, Cai Yang, these famous heroes all threw blood on the Qinglong Yanyue knife head, guan Yu was worthy of it
"The heroic wind shook in China"
Zhao Zilong killed all sides, brilliant achievements, from the teenager out of the mountain to the age of seventy is so capable of fighting, is the largest number of fierce generals in the three-point era; Zhang Fei is a fierce general with a fierce and brave fight, anyone who wants to be the first in the world can be, but to think about Zhang Fei's level, it is difficult!
So, which of Guan Yu or Zhang Fei is more powerful?
Let's analyze it today from a different perspective.
First, Guan Yu's point of view
Everyone knows that Guan Yu has an arrogant and self-effacing temperament, and there are few people who can look at him in this life. Especially as a martial artist who fights on the battlefield all day, the level of martial arts is a very important measure, Guan Yu thinks
"Fantastic place to stay"
Even in a draw with Huang Zhongbaiyu under changsha city, the opponent's sword technique"
No flaws at all
Guan Yu is still full of self-confidence,
"In the coming day, we will slash and slash with a knife to win"
Battle of Xiangfan, Guan Yu and Pound who came with the coffin
"There are more than a hundred in battle, and the spirit is multiplied"
After collecting the troops, Guan Yu lamented the bravery of Pound,
"The knife technique is familiar, really
My enemies
”
, but still decided to fight again,
"If I don't kill this person, why should I hate him?"
Guan Yu only once in his life was he willing to bow down with satisfaction. It was the Battle of Baimapo, Guan Yu's Army of Ten Thousand Horses rode a single horse to break through the formation, killed the enemy general Yan Liang, and returned to the battle with his head, and the Cao army generals were shocked by the gods and greeted each other, but Guan Yu said modestly,
"What a foot! My brother Zhang Yide took the head of a general in a million troops, such as probing the bag to take the ear. ”
It is relatively rare that Guan Yu, who has always been vain and arrogant, actually thinks of himself
"Ho Zu Dao Ya"
Admit that the martial arts are not as good as Zhang Fei.
Second, Zhang Fei's point of view
Guan Yu thought that his martial arts were inferior to Zhang Fei's, so what did Zhang Fei think? In the 65th episode of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, there is such a plot: Zhang Fei learned that the Western Liang general Ma Chao was ordered by Zhang Lu to lead an army to attack Ye Mengguan, and Zhang Fei took the initiative to volunteer and asked Liu Bei and Zhuge Liang to fight, hoping to compete with Ma Chao. Zhuge Liang used it in order to ignite Zhang Fei's fighting spirit
"Radical Method"
He told Liu Bei that Ma Chao had come to attack and that no one was invincible
"Unless you go to Jingzhou to take Guan Yunchang, you can fight the enemy."
Zhang Fei listened and was very unhappy,
"Why is the military master small?"
Zhuge Liang ranked Guan Yu's martial arts before Zhang Fei, and Zhang Fei felt that this was too small to look at him. At the same time, it also means that in Zhang Fei's heart, he will never admit that anyone else is stronger than him.
Third, Liu Bei's point of view
As Liu Bei, who knows both brothers very well, who is better than Guan Yu or Zhang Fei? There are also clues in the original book. Everyone remembers that after Liu Bei occupied Xuzhou, Cao Cao issued an edict in the name of Emperor Xian of Han and asked him to attack Yuan Shu in Huainan, and Yuan Shu was furious when he learned of this, and ordered the general Ji Ling to lead a heavy army to meet it.
Liu Bei and Guan Zhang discussed countermeasures and decided that Liu Bei and Guan Yu would lead their troops to meet the battle, while Zhang Fei would stay in Xuzhou. Why let Zhang Fei stay behind? Because Xiao Pei outside Xuzhou City was still crouching with a tiger-eyed Lü Bu. Leaving Zhang Fei to defend the city is because Zhang Fei is brave and courageous, Lü Bu has always been jealous of it, and with Zhang Fei, the guard of this outlaw, Lü Bu will never dare to act rashly. Guan Yu could not achieve this effect and could not stop Lü Bu.
Therefore, the consensus of the three Taoyuan brothers is that Zhang Fei's combat effectiveness and deterrent power are above Guan Yu.
If your own people think so, what do the enemies think? Let's list a few more enemies.
Fourth, the enemy's point of view
At that time, the world's first warrior Lü Bu and Guan Yu and Zhang Fei had all fought, and Lü Bu was more afraid of Zhang Fei, even if Zhang Fei was drunk and unable to fight, Lü Bu was still there
"Su Zhi Fei Yong, do not dare to force"
This shows the degree of Lü Bu's jealousy of Zhang Fei; Zhang Fei pretended to be a robber and robbed Lü Bu of three hundred warhorses, lü Bu couldn't bear it, and led a large army to Xiao PeiCheng to ask for guilt, and as soon as he opened his mouth, he was full of grievances:
"Ring-eyed thief, you have looked down on me many times!"
"Blame Zhang Fei for not respecting him and not giving him face." Lü Bu, such an arrogant person, was actually bullied by Zhang Fei to such a point, which was sad.
Xu Chu was the strongest martial artist in the Cao Army. He and Guan Yu and Zhang Fei both had fights. In the Battle of Tushan, Xu Chu and Xu Huang joined forces to attack, two hits and one, and guan Yu was killed
"Fight back"
And in the Battle of Hulukou, Zhang Fei intercepted the defeated cao army fleeing north, and Xu Chu was not alone in the battle.
"Riding a SaddleLess Horse"
Come to fight Zhang Fei, while Xu Huang and Zhang Liao
"Even the horses come to attack"
, three dozen one. After a scuffle,"
They will all get out of their own way."
After running away, Cao Cao
"Looking back, many people have been injured"
。 Whether it was the number of people fighting or the combat effect, Zhang Fei was slightly stronger than Guan Yu.
Ji Ling also fought with Guan Yu and Zhang Fei respectively. The Battle of Xuyi, Ji Ling and Guan Yu fight,
"Thirty in a row, no matter whether you win or lose"
, Ji Reiki is not able to continue,
"Scream for a break"
In the Battle of Xuzhou, Ji Ling confronted Zhang Fei,
"Dou Wu He, Zhang Fei shouted loudly, and stabbed Ji Ling under the horse"
。 Compared with the two, Zhang Fei's performance is undoubtedly better.
Of course, a high value of force does not mean that the record is necessarily brilliant.
If we only talk about the record, Guan Yu has more slashes than Zhang Fei. Lü Bu was even less, just killing two people and injuring two people, not as good as Gan Ning and Sun Ce, but Lü Bu
"The world's first warrior"
The throne is still unshakable.
Therefore, the level of force value between fierce generals cannot only be based on the standard of record, but must be considered from many aspects and angles. From all aspects, Zhang Fei's combat effectiveness should be above Guan Yu, but it is also an indisputable fact that Guan Yu's record is better.