Under one person: Feng Baobaoren and Zhang Qiling collided, is there any plagiarism in this?
"Under One Man" is also one of the most popular national comics in recent years, but for our national comics, it may be due to our high expectations, so there are many friends whose requirements are relatively high, so for Feng Baobao in the works and Zhang Qiling in "Notes from the Tomb Robber", the problem of human crashes has also become the focus of discussion for many people, mainly because the two people do have similarities, so will it be plagiarism in the end? Here I would also like to talk about my personal opinion.
Feng Baobao and Zhang Qiling have lost their memories, and both of them have appeared in the deep mountain area, but the location is different, for example, one is in Sichuan, and the other is in Yunnan, in addition, these two people are also very lacking in human feelings, social experience in all aspects, and even do not have the ability to take care of themselves, but they have very strong combat effectiveness, as if they are animal-like fighting instincts, and they are not old and immortal, even their faces have not changed, so it seems that, Basically, except for the difference in gender, the rest seem to be very similar, so in terms of human design, "Under One Man" is indeed a copy of "Notes from the Tomb Robber"?
Whether the author has absorbed nutrition from "Notes from the Tomb Robber", we don't know, but as far as the human settings are concerned, in fact, similar characters are innumerable, especially the characters under the same kind, taking the Japanese juvenile comics we are most familiar with as an example, as far as the protagonists in "Dragon Ball" and "One Piece", Sun Wukong and Luffy, in fact, these two people also have a lot of similarities, such as they are very edible, they are all a tendon, they can all be desperate for dreams and partners, They all have their own righteousness in their hearts, and they are all very simple, but sometimes they are also very dark.
In terms of combat, Sun Wukong has super one, super two, super three, etc., while Luffy has block one, block two, block three, etc., so if you think about it, can you say that Oda is copying Toriyama Akira? Although Oda does openly admit that he worships Akira Toriyama, so it is reasonable to have similarities in the shaping of the characters, but in essence, these are indeed two different characters, because they only coincide in terms of some external settings, which is very common in works of art, the core of the story is completely different, and the beginning and turn of the story is completely different, so at best it can only be a reference to the setting, not a copy.
Just like in the past, people often ridiculed the three-piece set in Korean dramas, "car accidents, amnesia, cancer" is to think that many Korean dramas can not fall, but the stories told by these works are different, and the conflict and logic of the plot are different. For the work "Under One Man", in fact, the author has a certain ambition, it is obvious that the author combined many Taoist stories, integrated, hoping to shape a huge world, and the reason why the setting of Feng Baobao's character is naïve, giving people the feeling that it is not a worldly affair, and at the same time has a strong fighting force, to a large extent, it also represents the so-called "naked son" image of The Taoists.
The so-called naked son, in fact, has been expounded in Lao Tzu's "Tao Te Ching", the original text is "Camp to hold one, can there be no separation?" Dedicated and soft, can baby care? The meaning is very simple, that is, to stay alive like a baby, to maintain a pure heart, and finally to return everything to the state of the baby, then Feng Baobao's behavior can be understood. And we will find that many similar settings on the market are not plagiarized Tao Te Ching? The answer is naturally not like this, in fact, it is inevitable that all works that are related to literature and art, whether it is novels or comics, certain things will have similarities.
After all, in the development of human beings for thousands of years, the creation of many stories has also developed to a peak, and it is almost impossible for you to find a completely different work, even if it spans the eastern and western cultures, the most typical examples are Mr. Jin Yong's "Tianlong Babu" and the Western "Song of Ice and Fire". Among them, many scenes even coincide with the development of the story, do you say that the author copied the "Eight Parts of the Heavenly Dragon"? Therefore, two completely different stories, but it is very normal for people to be coincidental in some aspects, and it cannot be said to be plagiarism at all.
I don't know what you think? Welcome everyone to say their ideas, if you like, I hope to be able to click three times, thank you for your encouragement and support.