Cover news reporter Wu Deyu Xun Chao
The movie "My Sister", starring Zhang Zifeng, has become a recent hit, with a cumulative box office of 451 million as of April 6.
With the movie's hot screening, it is suspected that the prototype in the film was pulled out by netizens - 8 years ago, a netizen posted a long post on a well-known forum "After the death of my parents, I raised my two-year-old brother", which received 777,000 hits and more than 1,000 replies. In the post: The girl sold two properties under her name, did not give her brother a penny, and sent her brother to the countryside.
"My Sister" is a hit whether to abandon her brother or not is controversial
The movie "My Sister" tells the story of a family relationship between her sister and the question of pursuing a personal independent life or raising her brother after the unexpected death of her parents. Anran, played by Zhang Zifeng, is a sister who was forced to grow up, who was beaten by her parents since she was a child, and was fostered in her aunt's house, in order to escape from this place, she was bent on going to Beijing to study for graduate school and live the life she wanted.
However, his parents left due to a car accident, and his younger brother, who had been hidden for many years, also appeared. On the one hand is his dream life, on the other hand, he is the younger brother left by his parents, how should Enron choose? Will she finally stay in her hometown to take care of her brother, or will she go to Beijing to pursue her dreams? This film has also caused a lot of discussion and deep thinking on social and family issues.
Compared with the warm ending in the film, it is suspected that the prototype story of "My Sister" is like this: the 2-year-old brother died in a car accident of his parents, and was given to a rural couple by the 23-year-old sister, and made a note that he would never come and go.
Some netizens commented: I heard that the prototype of "My Sister" was changed by the movie magic, and the real ending was that the sister sold the house and gave her brother to the poor family. Seriously, I would like to see the prototype of this version, minutes of brain to make up for the elderly parents secretly gave birth to their sons in secret, accidentally had a car accident and both died, the daughter was full of resentment, internal struggle, and finally respected the original intention, quick knife to cut the mess, sold the house to send away the younger brother, and lived his own life.
The film "My Sister" has two levels of criticism. Many viewers were poked in the storyline, in which the younger brother thought that his sister was going to lose himself in the subway, and the scene of crying while looking for his sister made many viewers feel distressed, and after finding his sister, his brother pulled on his sister's arm and said, "Go home!" The tear-jerkers pointed out: This is the movie I think is most worth watching since the Spring Festival, and it is very tear-inducing.
The opposition pointed out: My sister's archetypal story is not called a cool text, but can only say that the girl finally lives like a person. She was great, very good, very strong, very brave and hardworking. She's so nice.
Suspected original post: Sell the house and send away the younger brother
According to the reporter's research: "My Sister" The earliest source of this story has two, one is Zhihu, there was a hot question at that time, an anonymous "sister" asked questions in Zhihu, her parents died and had a newborn brother, but did not want to share the inheritance with the younger brother, so he sent his brother to the countryside to break off the relationship, asking "Am I right to do this?" At that time, the issue caused a large-scale discussion.
The other was a 2013 post on a well-known forum titled "After my parents died, I took my two-year-old brother out."
In the original post, the sister did not have the slightest affection for this brother who was 21 years apart. "I'm also glad I chose to give up this so-called brother." "The word brother, in the 21 years before me, never made me feel sick."
In the article, the author writes:
"I have been an only child for a lifetime, and when I should start a family for more than ten years, I will be like the eldest sister of feudal society with hard work and hard work to bring up a younger brother."
Sorry, I can't do it.
People are selfish, and human nature is inherently evil. Selfishness is nature, it doesn't matter whether you are an only child or not an only child. ”
She confronts human nature:
"I told them who was going to raise me, I had no conditions or interest, and my relatives said they were going to sue me."
She defends her rights with the law:
"I asked the lawyer, and in fact I have no obligation to raise my brother, and my brother has no obligation to support me."
The original poster was afraid of netizens at the time, many netizens felt that her parents gave her two houses, at least one set for her brother, felt that she was too selfish, and some people supported her to do so, but most of them opposed.
Many netizens were angry, saying that they read this post "chest stuffiness", and even some netizens said that the landlord's post made them firm in their determination to have a second child, saying that "the only child is too terrible, I don't want my daughter to become like that." Supporting netizens believe that this post can "let all parents who disregard family conflicts and disregard the happiness of their children reflect on it." ”
Some netizens also doubted the authenticity of this post, and some people pointed out that "at the beginning, it was clear that her parents divorced and gave her the only two houses!" Later, he was scolded and changed his mouth to say that it was given by his grandfather, and the description of the problem was inconsistent and even lying."
"22-year-old sister refused to raise 2-year-old brother was sued" attracted attention The prototype can not find the source
Coincidentally. In September last year, "parents have a second child and ask a 22-year-old daughter to raise" attracted attention, and a lawyer used this as a case to popularize the law in a video on the Internet. In the video: A couple living on low security, a few years after giving birth to their second child, because of the physical and economic situation of the two, they are unable to raise the child well, so they want to let their eldest daughter raise, but did not want their daughter to express strong opposition to this. In the end, the couple took their own daughter to court because of this incident. The court ruled in favor of her parents, and Li Li, as an older sister, had to raise her younger brother. The lawyer said: According to the provisions of our country's marriage law and the civil code that will soon enter into force, if the parents are not able to support the child, in this case, the brothers and sisters are obliged to support. Then for this two-year-old child, the sister's maintenance obligation cannot be refused.
This news exploded on the Internet, and many netizens believed: "Parents disregard the family economic situation to have a second child, give birth and do not raise, to the daughter who has just begun to live an unbearable burden, with the current economic situation for ordinary people, this is a devastating burden." What's the difference between that and giving birth to a son for a daughter? The daughter's whole life may be ruined by the burden of this so-called younger brother! In the end, the staff of the Guangzhou Bureau of Justice came forward to explain that this was a program cooperated by the law popularization department of the Bureau of Justice and the TV station, and the case was found by the production team on the Internet, but its authenticity could not be found at the source.
The screenwriter once said: Inspired by the opening up of the two-child policy
Earlier, "My Sister" screenwriter You Xiaoying talked about the original intention of creation, once said: Because of the liberalization of the two-child policy in 2015, there are some girls around who are experiencing the same things as the sister in the film, and the second child that their parents want to give birth to is more than ten years old or even more than twenty years old, and they will have some grievances and uneasiness. Family dramas are very difficult to write and difficult to shoot, and director Yin Ruoxin will have a sense of mission after getting the script, and she wants to tell everyone that they should be seen!
<b>[If you have a news thread, please report to us, once adopted, there is a fee reward.] Newspaper WeChat attention: ihxdsb, newspaper QQ: 3386405712].</b>