Loading...
Ying's live broadcast debut: real charm in the midst of tension
In Na Ying's live broadcast debut, her nervousness was like that of a dancer who made her debut on stage, touching the stage with her toes, but her heart was turbulent. Her nervousness was not a secret, but like a transparent piece of paper, gently covering her singing. When she opened her mouth to sing the first note of "Silence", the tension seemed to be transmitted to everyone in the audience through the screen. But as the melody progresses, her voice gradually unfolds, like a flower slowly blooming in the morning dew, with a hoarse warm color, delicate and full of human touch.
Netizens reacted differently to Na Ying's nervousness, and some people joked: "Na Ying started coughing before she sang, is this to take the lead in making a noise?" Some people also said: "The nervous Na Ying is more attractive, and every trill of her is like an echo of a heartbeat." This real tension made the audience feel Na Ying's fragility and strength as a singer, and also made the live broadcast more vivid and interesting.
Loading...
Live vs. Recorded: The Battle of Truth and Perfection
The charm of live streaming lies in its immediacy and unpredictability, allowing viewers to hear the singer's breathing and feel the burrs and grains in their voices. This sense of realism is incomparable to the meticulously polished perfection in the recording. Some netizens commented: "I can finally hear Na Ying's real voice again, I feel like I have returned to the era when there was no sound repair." ”
However, this reality also brings controversy. Some people believe that small imperfections in the live broadcast are an intimate connection between the singer and the audience, while others believe that these imperfections affect the perfect presentation of the music. But in any case, the live broadcast allows the audience to see the side of the singer as an ordinary person, and this kind of closeness cannot be provided by the recording.
Loading...
Na Ying's ranking: Steady performance in the midst of tension
In that live broadcast, although Na Ying's performance was nervous, her stable performance won the recognition of the audience. Her ranking is constantly changing in the hearts of netizens, some people rank her second, second only to Miss F, and some people think that her performance is enough to make her number one. This controversial ranking reflects the audience's complex emotions about Na Ying's performance.
Some netizens commented: "Na Ying's nervousness makes her more down-to-earth, and her singing voice is full of emotional fluctuations, which is an effect that Xiuyin can't achieve." While others argue: "Nervousness should not be the criterion for evaluating a singer's performance, we should pay more attention to her music itself." ”
Ending: The truth and controversy of the live broadcast
The authenticity of the live broadcast allows the audience to see the unknown side of the singer, and this realism brings intimacy and controversy. Na Ying's live broadcast debut is like a mirror, reflecting the audience's different expectations for the authenticity of music. Some people strive for flawless studio effects, while others crave to hear the singer's most authentic voice.
In this controversy, we can't help but ask: should the authenticity of the live broadcast be the only criterion for evaluating a singer's performance? Perhaps, we should be more open to different ways of presenting music, whether it is the tension and reality of the live broadcast, or the perfection and delicacy of the recording, which are all part of the diversity of music. Na Ying's live broadcast is not only a feast of music, but also a profound discussion about the authenticity of music.