Water Margin, as one of China's four famous works, may be the most disgusting one, even worse than the ending of the Dream of the Red Chamber, Song Jiang was hated by people with itchy teeth, so good team, hard to be made by Song Jiang to go to Zhao'an, the final death, injury, no matter how many times you see it will be angry seven tricks smoke.
Jin Shengsi also once cut off the Water Margin and deleted the part of Zhao'an in the back, but after all, there is a full version, and the current popularity is still this kind of whole book with zhao'an plot.
Many people have such an idea, if liangshan is a good man, has been insisting on not commanding an, then what will happen to the end, this is a relatively large brain hole, let's follow this line of thought to see, liangshan if it has been resisting, the final outcome will be.
First look at the general trend of the world, the novel is about the last years of the Northern Song Dynasty, when there was no great chaos in the world, of course, there are still people like Fang La Song Jiang who occupy the mountains as kings, and this basic condition is very important.
Under normal circumstances, when the world is in chaos, many people will pull up the team to do it alone, hoping to do a career, because the imperial court has not enough troops to deal with so many rebels, so the early development is not so rare.
In the era of water margin, there was no great chaos in the world, which meant that the imperial court could constantly mobilize troops to deal with the good men of Liangshan, which was a fundamental, which was the basis of the game between Liangshan and the imperial court.
We read the novel, at every turn, drink in large bowls, eat large pieces of meat, but these things can not appear out of thin air, good men do not care about these, readers look happy, but in fact, these things are robbed, some are robbed of property, some are directly robbed of materials.
There is no production on Liangshan, so the only way to eat and drink can be robbed, and the target of robbery is the big landlord, the big bad guy and other people identified by the good men of Liangshan.
This mode of robbery, although it can gain a lot of wealth for a while, but in fact it cannot last, after the surrounding large manors are finished, what to do, is it impossible to let the good men of Liangshan go to the land.
The only way is to continue to expand the base area, expand the scope of rule and radiation, but expanding the scale means that it is necessary to face the army and encirclement and suppression of the imperial court, and eventually it will evolve into a military force.
Judging from the descriptions in the book, Liangshan Shuipo is indeed a good place that is easy to defend and difficult to attack, and the establishment of the Song River they defeated a large-scale official army, relying on defensive battles.
But once you want to expand your sphere of influence, it is different, it is a siege battle, this time is the time to reflect their level, and Song Jiang's group of people are actually not very good.
In the face of the court's continuous dispatch of troops, it is still difficult to expand the territory, and the biggest possibility is to use the superior terrain to launch a defensive counterattack, but it is more likely that the turtle is shrunk in Liangshan.
This is mainly determined by the previous fundamentals, there is no great chaos in the world, the imperial court has a steady stream of troops and resources to suppress Liangshan, and Liangshan is to kill one less, and with the cruelty of the war, there is basically no material to plunder around, Liangshan's economy is bound to face the danger of collapse.
On the whole, the possibility of Liangshan being completely destroyed is still relatively large, so Song Jiang also saw that there was no hope and a way out of rebellion, zhao'an at least had a way to live, and also found a serious errand for the brothers, at least he had been a bandit, and the possibility of a future was very small.
Although many people did not like Song Jiang, but perhaps Song Jiang's approach was the only feasible, and later the brothers recruited Fang La, proving that the thief would not last long, Song Jiang died, many people died, but after all, among them, there are still people alive, they and their descendants, there is hope, no longer what bandits are born, this is the most fundamental difference.
The reality is very cruel, although this is a brain hole, but even if Song Jiang insists on not surrendering, the result may be worse than Zhao'an, and Fang La is their fate.