What is history: it is the echo of the past to the future, the reflection of the future on the past. - Hugo
Ming Yingzong Zhu Qizhen killed Yu Qian is really unjustifiable, because Yu Qian helped Zhu Qi Zhen a lot, and at the same time did not harm Too Qian, why did Ming Yingzong want to kill Yu Qian?
(Zhuqi Town)
Saying that Yu Qian helped Zhu Qizhen a lot, this sentence is not excessive at all.
First, the Jiangshan that Zhu Qizhen almost lost was recovered by Yu Qian for him. If Yu Qian had not been able to turn the tide of the war and lead the War of Resistance, then Daming Jiangshan would have been lost, and Daming Jiangshan would have been lost in the hands of Zhu Qizhen, who was Daming's sinner for eternity. Yu Qian helped him save face and save his reputation. Besides, if Yu Qian hadn't saved Daming Jiangshan, would Zhu Qizhen still be emperor later?
Second, Wa Lai wanted to release Zhu Qizhen back to China, but Zhu Qiyu did not agree at that time. The reason was simple, because Zhu Qizhen was put back to be a big trouble, and there was no way to deal with him. But Yu Qian firmly agreed to let Zhu Qizhen come back. At that time, the only person who agreed to let Zhu Qizhen return was probably Zhu Qizhen's mother, Empress Sun. If Yu Qian did not agree, even if Zhu Qizhen's mother wanted Zhu Qizhen to come back, he would not be able to come back.
Third, when Zhu Qiyu was seriously ill, Yu Qian strongly advocated the restoration of Zhu Jianshen's position as crown prince. Zhu Jianshen was the son of Zhu Qizhen, and Yu Qian asked Jiang Shan to return to Zhu Qizhen's descendants, what else could Zhu Qizhen say?
Some people believe that Zhu Qizhen wanted to kill Yu Qian, because Yu Qian had harmed him, and the evidence was that Yu Qian did not agree to The Blackmail of Vala and resolutely honored Zhu Qizhen as the Emperor Taishang, which was not to take Zhu Qizhen's life seriously.
In fact, as we said earlier, Yu Qian did this to help Zhu Qizhen save Daming Jiangshan. And even if Yu Qian did this, Vala would not kill Zhu Qizhen. At that time, the Jin State had not yet killed the Second Emperor Hui Qin, not to mention that It was Wa Lai, which was originally a vassal state of the Ming Dynasty, and would not do anything to Zhu Qizhen.
(Yu Qian)
Some people will also think that Yu Qian did not keep Zhu Jianshen's position as crown prince, and let Zhu Qiyu change the crown prince, which made Zhu Qizhen very angry. But this is certainly no wonder to Qian, Zhu Qiyu is the emperor, he is bent on changing, Yu Qian has some way.
In fact, the reason why Zhu Qizhen wanted to kill Yu Qian was recorded in the "History of Ming".
At that time, Zhu Qizhen was also unwilling to kill Yu Qian, and he also believed that Yu Qian was meritorious and could not kill him. However, Shi Heng, Cao Jixiang, Xu Youzhen, and others who launched the change to seize the door at that time said to Zhu Qizhen that if you did not kill Yu Qian, then there would be no reason for you Zhu Qizhen to "seize the door". At that time, Zhu Qizhen was silent for a long time, agreed with the statements of these people, and then agreed to kill Yu Qian.
And this statement is also generally accepted by history.
However, I think that in fact, this is not the real reason why Zhu Qizhen wants to kill Yu Qian. If it is because of this killing Yu Qian, there is no benefit to Zhu Qi Town, but it is very harmful, why do you say so?
The reason is very simple, if posterity knows that Zhu Qizhen killed Yu Qian on this reason, then isn't it "if you want to add to the sin, why bother with it"? Isn't it more detrimental to the image of Zhu Qizhen?
In fact, Zhu Qizhen has a better method, that is, to "unite the front" yu Qian. If he can gain Yu Qian's support after becoming emperor, then his historical image will certainly be very good. This is experienced in history, and after Li Shimin became emperor by killing the crown prince, he did a good job of "united front" Wei Zheng. Although Wei Zheng has always maintained an "unyielding" posture. It is precisely this kind of "unyielding", so Li Shimin's image of being good at receiving advice has been highly praised in later generations. Why didn't Zhu Qizhen adopt this method?
(Zhu Qiyu)
Therefore, the reason why Zhu Qizhen must kill Yu Qian will not be this reason.
I think that the reason why Zhu Qizhen had to do that at that time was the result of persecution by Shi Heng, Xu Youzhen, Cao Jixiang and other ministers who participated in the change of the door.
The first thing we have to understand is that the desire to win yu qian, Shi Heng and others is definitely more urgent than Zhu Qizhen. Because their purpose in seizing the door is nothing more than to get ahead. And if after taking the door, Yu Qian is still the boss in the imperial court, then didn't they do it in vain? Only by taking yu qian could they ascend to power.
And Shi Heng and others wanted to take yu Qian, and zhu Qizhen was powerless even if he wanted to protect Yu Qian.
Because the throne of Zhu Qizhen was completely opportunistically "operated" by these few people. Without the help of these few people, Zhu Qizhen would not have been able to become emperor. Since Zhu Qi Town was run by these people, it meant that if Zhu Qi Town did not listen to them, it was likely that they would take Zhu Qi Town down. Therefore, Zhu Qizhen was very afraid. If he had to make a choice between humility and the safety of his own life, he would definitely choose his own life.
Of course, although Zhu Qizhen was subject to Shi Heng and others, he had to kill Yu Qian. However, he did not tie his hands because of this, and when he sat on the throne, he immediately attacked Shi Heng and the others, and quickly took them down. However, although he had expressed his appreciation for Qian, he could not rehabilitate Qian in his lifetime. And this task was handed over to Zhu Qizhen's son Zhu Jianshen.