Many people say that the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is more reliable than the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, but when we look at the first "Chronicle of Emperor Wu" of the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, we find a ridiculous thing: there is a hardcore fan of Liu Bei, the thief of Runan, who was killed twice by Cao Cao in five years - this can never be two people with the same name and surname.
In the Chronicle of the Three Kingdoms, Volume I, Wei Shuyi, and The Chronicle of Emperor Wu, it is recorded that such an event: "In the first year of Jian'an, There were tens of thousands of people in the Yellow Turban of Yingchuan, He Yi, Liu Pei, Huang Shao, He Man, and so on, and Taizu marched to break it, beheading and Shao. ”
When the Chronicle of the Three Kingdoms, Vol. XVII is introduced to the forbidden, Liu Pei is also mentioned: "(In the first year of Jian'an, Yu Ban) from the conquest of the Yellow Turban Liu Pi, Huang Shao, etc., Tunban Liang, Shao and other night raids on the Taizu camp, the forbidden marshal broke it, beheaded Shao, etc., and surrendered to his people. ”
In the first year of Jian'an, Cao Cao pacified Runan, and it is also described in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms that He Yi He Man was a brother, and his younger brother He Man had a nickname called "Fork in the Night of The Interception", and was beheaded by Cao Hong with a dragging knife in front of the two armies.
He Man, who was wrapped in a yellow scarf, wearing a green jacket, and carrying an iron rod, was beheaded by Cao Hong, Li Diansheng captured Huang Shao, and Xu Chu captured He Yi alive, with the result that "He Chu was worshipped as a lieutenant, and the reward was very generous, and He Yi and Huang Shao were beheaded." Ru and Yingxiping. ”
This is where the Romance of the Three Kingdoms is more reliable than the Romance of the Three Kingdoms: Chen Shou said that Cao Cao beheaded Liu Pei and Huang Shao, while Luo Guanzhong said that Cao Jun only killed He Yi, He Man, and Huang Shao, and that the Battle of Runan in the first year of Jian'an did not have anything to do with Liu Pei.
There is no doubt that Luo Guanzhong was right and Chen Shou was wrong, because in the fifth year of Jian'an, also under Chen Shou's pen, liu Pei, who was beheaded by Cao Cao, appeared again: "Runan's surrender of the thief Liu Pei and other rebels should be promised. Shao sent Liu Bei to help him, and the minister Cao Ren broke it. Ready to go, so I broke through the tun. ”
Zhao Yi, a famous scholar of the Qing Dynasty who wrote the Twenty-Four Historical Notes, pointed out this problem in the "Yu Yu Cong Kao Volume VI": "Although Chen Shou's "Romance of the Three Kingdoms" is called a good narrative and has a good historical talent, there are also mistakes... Liu Pei has been awarded the title. In the fifth year, there was another thief liu pei in runan, and others responded to Yuan Shao, and promised a little. In this article, there are also those who are in conflict with each other. ”
The Ru'nan bandit Liu Pei was destroyed by Cao Cao twice in the main history, the first time it was clear that he had been killed by Cao Cao, and five years later he died and reborn as a die-hard fan of Liu Bei, which is indeed puzzling - we do not need to question that these are two people with the same name and surname, because Zhao Yizhan's historical materials and archaeological discipline are beyond my generation's reach, and he can write a book to confirm Chen Shou's penal errors, which should be enough evidence.
Zheng Shi is bent and quite contradictory, let's take a look at the very wonderful "Romance of the Three Kingdoms", how to tell this Liu Bei hardcore fan.
Although Liu Pei had tens of thousands of troops, he could pay for Liu Bei's life.
In the fifth year of Jian'an, Cao Cao and Yuan Shao were at a standstill at Guandu, Guan Yu was made the Marquis of Hanshouting after beheading Yan Liang and Wen Ugly, Liu Beiqi did not know where to go, at this time, the remaining yellow turban of Runan, Liu Peigong, called out, gathered a group of soldiers and horses, defeated Cao Hong, and attracted Guan Yu as the main general and Yu Ban Lejin as the deputy general.
Liu Pei and Gong both showed Liu Bei's fan nature in front of the two armies, and Gong both also said bluntly: "Liu Xuande was at the beginning of Yuan Ben, but Ru was from Cao Cao, why not?" ”
Guan Yu had nothing to say, and he had to fight hard to move forward with the horse dance knife, but Gong Du pulled the horse and left, and Guan Yu chased after him poorly: "They all turned back and told Guan Gongyue: 'The grace of the lord must not be forgotten.'" Gong Dang fast forward, I let Ru Nan. 'Guan Gonghui will be aware, and drive the army to cover up the killing. Liu and Gong pretended to lose and scattered. ”
In order to reunite Liu Bei's brothers, Liu Pei even gave up the territory occupied by Runan, and Guan Yu returned to Xudu and did not tell Lady Gan and Lady Mi about this matter, until the two ladies cried, Guan Yu explained with a red face: "Brother is really in Hebei. Those who do not dare to teach their sisters-in-law to know, I am afraid that there will be leaks. Things must be slowed down, not fast. ”
Liu Bei in Hebei, is already a well-known thing, Guan Yu also has to keep secrets from the two sisters-in-law, this may be Guan Yu's caution, let's put aside, or go back to see Liu Bei's hardcore fan Liu Pei's later performance.
After Liu Bei reunited with Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, and others, Liu Pei and Gong Du sent people to invite him, and Runan became Liu Bei's territory: "Xuande wanted to abandon the ancient city to guard Runan, and it just so happened that Liu Pei and Gong Du sent someone to invite him." So he raised an army to camp in Runan, recruited troops to buy horses, and Xu Tu marched in. ”
Liu Bei recruited troops and bought horses in Runan, and before he could "march in", Cao Cao came to requisition.
Although there were tens of thousands of people in Wen, including Sun Qian, Jian Yong, Mi Zhu, Wu Xiangyu, Zhang Fei, Zhao Yun, Mi Fang, Guan Ping, and Zhou Cang, plus Liu Peigong's soldiers and horses, there were still tens of thousands of people, but in the face of Cao Cao's army, it was still stretched: Gong who was escorting grain and grass was surrounded, Zhang Fei went to rescue, and was also wrapped in dumplings, and finally even Guan Yu was also surrounded by Runan, and Liu Bei was left with only one Zhao Yun Gu before he could take care of it, and Liu Bei became the commander of the light pole: "Zhao Yun raised his gun to the Prancing Horse, killed a road, and Xuan De followed with a double-stranded sword." Between the battles. Xu Chu chased after him and fought with Zhao Yunli. Behind the ban, Li Dian arrived again. Xuande saw that the situation was in danger and left in the wilderness. Hearing the shouts behind him, Xuan De looked at the deep mountain and the secluded road, and escaped on a single horse. ”
Liu Bei ran from dark to dawn, Guan Yu Zhang Fei Zhao Yun disappeared, just when he was calling the heavens should not be called, a Biao army horse rushed out - a hardcore fan Liu Pei with a thousand remnants of soldiers, protecting Liu Bei's family and strategist Sun Qianjian Yong chased up, and the Mi Fang who did salt and vinegar was also there.
Mi Fang chattered and told Liu Bei that "Xiahou Huan's army was very strong, so he abandoned the city and left. Cao Bing rushed to the scene, fortunately, Yun Chang blocked it, so he had to get out" When Zhang Gao was in front and Gao Lan was in the back, the two large armies wrapped up, "Xuan De had no way at both ends, and shouted to the heavens: 'Heaven why have I been so embarrassed!'" At this point, it is better to die! "I want to draw my sword and kill myself."
Liu Bei wanted to wipe his neck, and his men were all frightened and stupid, and no one actually came forward to stop it, and finally the real hardcore fans stood up: "Liu Pei's urgent end: 'Rong Mou died in battle, took the road to save the king.'" Then he came to confront Gao Lan. ”
Liu Pei was loyal and courageous, but his martial skills were not good, and he was cut off by Gao Lan in three rounds, this loyal fan, even if he fulfilled his promise, bought time for Liu Bei, Zhao Yun only then killed Gao Lan with one shot from behind, killing Zhang Gao in thirty rounds, at this time Zhang Fei also killed his uncle Xiahou Yuan, Guan Yu also came with Guan Ping and Zhou Cang, and the three brothers plus Zhao Yun Andi Zhu Mi Fang rushed to Jingzhou to take shelter under the contact of Sun Qian.
Liu Guan, Zhang Zhao, did a great thing in Jingzhou, while Liu Pei and Gong Were buried in Runan (Gong was all killed by Xiahou Yuan), at this time, while we were sorry for these two fans, we could not help but have this association: Liu Pei can give up everything including life and territory for Liu Bei, if they live to the zhang wu years, that is, after Liu Bei became emperor, can they also be crowned marquis and worship general?
Liu Peigong can not be crowned marquis and worship general, the power is between Liu Bei's thoughts, but the author believes that this is a very difficult thing: Liu Bei claims to be the empress dowager, and does not mention Liu Peigongdu's name at all, which is like the relationship between stars and fans now: with the object of worship, they also lose themselves and lose their self-esteem, and such people are not valued by idols.
A star travels, dozens of bodyguards raise their eyebrows and shout five or six, they are not passers-by A and B, but precisely the star's fans. Readers who read this article, seeing the stars traveling, did not bother to go to the crowd to take pictures...