Should Feng Yuxiang expel Puyi from the Forbidden City?
Some people actually questioned Feng Yuxiang's expulsion of Pu Yi, such a person is definitely a descendant of the traitorous lackeys. Feng Yuxiang was reasonable, legal and reasonable in this matter. It has solved a legacy problem for the international community and done a good thing for the country.
[1] Talk about Feng Yuxiang's "reasonableness".
After entering the Republic of China, why did the Manchu Qing royal family still receive preferential treatment? That is the agreement of the Qing Emperor's abdication edict, also called "Preferential Treatment of The Royal Family". It is said that the Emperor of the Qing Dynasty favored the republican system, and only after abdication did he have preferential treatment.
What are the benefits? Emperor Qing's "honorific title" was retained... Give 4 million two sponsorships every year... Temporarily living in the palace, moving to the Summer Palace in the future... See clearly, the clause is clear, white paper and black writing "temporary residence is forbidden, move in the future."
Before Yuan Shikai, Li Yuanhong, Duan Qirui, these people, as Manchu Qing courtiers, could not pull down their faces to invite Puyi out of the palace, and the Manchu Qing royal family pretended to be deaf and dumb, and Lai did not move in the palace. Feng Yuxiang only carried out what the Beiyang government should have done but did not do. What's the problem with doing things according to the rules?
Moreover, all the "prerequisites" for the Manchu Qing royal family to enjoy preferential treatment were the abdication of the Qing Emperor.
What did Puyi do after abdicating? Didn't the Manchu Qing royal family have a compulsive number in their hearts? In 1917, Zhang Xun led the braided army into Beijing to support the restoration of Puyi, and Puyi appeared on the scene and sat on the emperor. Although Puyi is young and does not understand things, he can use it as an excuse. But after all, he was the protagonist of the restoration, and without the Manchu Qing royal family conspiring with Zhang Xun, the restoration could not be done.
Since the Manchu Qing royal family and Pu Yi broke the contract first, then the "Preferential Royal Conditions" should also be changed, first move out of the Forbidden City and then say.
[2] Talk about Feng Yuxiang's "legality".
Feng Yuxiang was the initiator of puyi's expulsion, but he did not directly send troops to bomb out. Feng Yuxiang submitted the proposal to the cabinet of the government at the time. How is it implemented? How can the preferential conditions be modified? They were all the result of the deliberations of the cabinet meeting of the government at that time.
That is to say, "expelling Puyi" not only represents Feng Yuxiang's personal behavior, but also represents the government's behavior at that time, which is a resolution with legal effect.
[3] Talk about Feng Yuxiang's "reasonableness".
Although the Qing Emperor abdicated, the appeal of the Qing Emperor was still there. As long as the Qing Emperor still stayed in the Forbidden City, as long as the Qing Emperor still had the "honorific title", all kinds of cattle, ghosts, snakes and gods would use the guise of the Qing Emperor to cause trouble.
The deposed emperor Puyi should be fortunate - ancient and modern, Chinese and foreign, there have always been dynasties and generations, and there are still fewer things in the former dynasty that the imperial chickens and dogs are not left and are exterminated?
After he participated in the restoration, no one held him accountable. Finally understood why the ancient emperors had to cut the grass and remove the roots of the previous dynasty.
In the government cabinet at that time, the crowd was agitated, and many people demanded that the perpetrators of the "restoration" be severely punished. Feng Yuxiang and the cabinet treated Puyi and the imperial family with kindness and righteousness in accordance with the "Amendment to the Preferential Treatment Clause of the Qing Dynasty". Not only to protect the private property of the royal family, but also to allocate 500,000 yuan to the royal family every year to ensure that he has no worries about food and clothing, and also allocates 2 million yuan to help the flag people.
What did Puyi do? When Japan invaded China, Puyi became an adult, right? No one forced him, right? Turning around, he sneaked from Tianjin to the northeast and made a lackey puppet for the Japanese.
[Finally] The Manchu Qing royal family should be thankful, Puyi still gave preferential treatment after the failure of the restoration, and still treated well after being a traitor and traitor - in the face of any ancient dynasty, the head was cut off several rounds.
Feng Yuxiang's expulsion of PuYi will of course offend many people, and it is more of a national praise. He told Duan Qirui this way: "In Beijing, there is only one thing that has been done well, that is, to expel Puyi, which is worthy of the country and the people and will be worthy of the world for future generations."
[Note] Put away your cheap sympathy, you can't pity the last emperor. Even after the abdication, there are still three or five hundred palace eunuchs waiting, and the living conditions are better than you are now.