Let's go and photograph a rich man's day!
Recently, actor Han Xue's short film directed on a variety show sparked a discussion. The short film is based on Cinema Paradiso, which features a story between the delivery guy and his sick grandfather.
Originally, it should be the main grandfather, but the film is like a running account to shoot the life of the takeaway brother, and the sick grandfather only appears on the phone at the beginning of the film.
Grandpa just spoke on the phone in the morning, and suddenly died in the evening, until the end of the film, the little brother did not see the grandfather's side, only he was embarrassed and crying, which made everyone confused, why can't I go back to see the old man? Danmu also felt that Han Xue was moving himself.
The most controversial point is that the audience believes that Han Xue's shooting of the life of the takeaway brother is full of the rich people's false imagination and overlook of the life of the bottom people.
The takeaway brother casting is selected according to the style of the flower beauty male idol drama, clean and refreshing dress and style, the scene is beautiful, the big filter is up, like shooting MV, even hit by a car, it makes people feel that the next second to meet a beautiful woman to start a relationship.
Han Xue has always flaunted her attention to details, thinking that there should be no low-grade books, online novels, etc. in the home of the takeaway brother, and we don't know why she thinks the takeaway brother does not read online texts.
Therefore, the little brother in her eyes must be a literary and artistic man who loves movies and can play guitar after watching "A Beautiful Life", which is really Bourgeois.
The room was also clean and tidy and spotlessly clean, as if urban white collar workers. Since it comes to the house, then look at the brother's home, finely decorated large open room, independent bathroom, visually estimated to be 40 square meters.
Some netizens saw the appearance of the building and said that this is the Xincheng Building at No. 337 North Chengdu Road, the downtown area of the city, and the house price is 8,000 per month.
The real takeaway brother lives in the suburbs in order to save money, and even some people live in bunk beds of 700 per month.
Speaking of the brother's electric car, the takeaway will buy a large battery in order to receive orders, and generally will enlarge the box to load the takeaway, and then look at the brother in the film, the battery is small, send three or four trips to the takeaway is out of power, and he has not charged the day before.
Help me... Go to war without a gun.
As one of the screenwriters, Han Xue also caused people to complain in the design of the lines, and the little brother called the customer to be delivered in advance, on the grounds that there are many orders behind, what is the relationship between this and the customer?
After delivering the meal out of the community, shouting security guards your community is really difficult to find, waste ten minutes, what is this security guard? Isn't this really a black delivery man?
And his setting is "only 30 singles a day", which can live in a big house in the city center, so that netizens have complained "Is Wang Sicong going to experience life"?
It is not Wang Sicong to experience life, but as Han Xue, who obviously has a sense of superiority, to experience it, it is almost the same.
Han Xue himself felt that this work was his own sincere work, and as soon as he took the stage, he cried and recalled his grandfather and his own growth experience.
Li Chengru smiled when he saw Han Xue crying.
The judges on the scene felt that this was self-touching, and the whole film had no storyline.
Hao Lei said bluntly, I want to see the story you made, not your story.
She also feels that Han Xue's crying is an irrational act, as an actor needs sensibility, but as a director, it needs to be rational, and this state cannot complete a work with the team.
Despite this, she still advanced, and Cai Kangyong, who has always been able to speak, believes that this is an expression of prose poetry, and some judges think that she is just out of sensibility and shoots what she wants to shoot.
In the previous preview of the show, Han Xue was considered a dark horse, and she not only found Zhang Yimou's royal photographer to assist in shooting, but also invited Han Hong to handle music production. It is really disappointing to occupy such resources and hand over such works.
The error between Han Xue and the audience is precisely that she believes that she has paid sincerity and effort, and this sincerity cannot be felt by the audience. In the face of doubt, she is not only completely unaware of the difference, but also asks you why you don't cry like them, why do you have to pick faults in the work.
But the audience feels that you occupy the resources to shoot such a hypocritical work, which is disrespectful to everyone.
This kind of "princess" forcibly imagining the life of the bottom people is also reflected in Wang Wenye, who is the daughter of Huayi's boss, and the short film directed this time tells the story of a father encouraging his sick daughter.
But because of the lack of life experience, being complained about is a story that will not happen in China at all.
The father sold the house for his daughter's medical treatment, but the daughter lived in a warm and gorgeous VIP ward.
Wang Wen also said that he did not go to the hospital for field investigation because of the short time. When asked what the ending of the short film was, she said she didn't know either.
The story is also sensationalizing for the sake of sensationalism, and film critics pointed out that the tears caused by the film are too cheap.
Shooting works with realistic themes, if the director himself does not understand their lives, how can the audience believe and empathize? It is useless to only touch yourself, the sincerity of the mouth is useless, you "princesses", instead of taking pictures of the underlying life in your imagination, it is better to show us the day of a successful person, maybe more real.