The blue sky and the sea are no different,
Langya Mountain Yin Ben same root,
Where is the spirit of the book,
Cuckoo cried blood and asked Lan Ting.
This is the sigh of Mr. Wang Xi, the winner of the Lanting Gold Award, after winning the Gold Award and losing it again!
This matter is indeed emotional, and everyone who changes it will sigh!
After all, such a grand prize, such a high honor is gone, how sad! What a lament! The cuckoo cries blood!
The origin of the matter is understood by many people, and it is not verbose.
In response to the emergence of such a moth, A few points of view:
First, is Wang Xi unjust?
Second, is it appropriate for the organizing committee to play so well?
Third, how will calligraphy people play in the future?
<h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" data-track="5" > first say the first thing, Wang Xi is not wronged. </h1>
Wang Xi's skill level is absolutely indisputable, and many works can be seen in his profound skills, and from this point alone, he has also been recognized by the judges of the Lanting Award.
The problem is a "unsolved case", and suddenly, before receiving the award, there is a "result", there is a "decision".
This "unsolved case" is the competition three years ago, is it plagiarism?
Saying that it is a "suspense case", whether it is a "suspense case", I am also hearsay, originally did not understand that matter, read some information on the Internet, including some conversation content of Wang Xi himself and his friends, probably understand the situation is: the organizing committee did not give a clear result, but the bonus was withdrawn.
Therefore, does Wang Xi himself approve of this treatment result? It's up to him.
The content of his conversation with his friends may be peeping into one or two.
If plagiarism is hammered, then depriving the gold medal is not unjust. If it is considered to be a "reference", it is wronged.
Unfortunately, there is no clear statement, until this time the seventh Lanting Award, there is no official public statement.
Alas, it is gaogu that borrows from the ancients, and it is to be advocated, but to learn from the present, that is plagiarism, which is calligraphy.
<h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" data-track="5" > let's talk about the second thing, is the organizing committee playing it right? </h1>
Looking back, here's the thing: the official announcement of the winner list has its name - the opening ceremony is announced, there is no name.
It's that simple, two steps! Kill crisply and neatly, and the knife falls in your hand.
At least two steps to the public, as if there were no other statements.
This is the highest standard event in the book world, and everything done should be reasonable and legal.
"Should", note that I said "should".
But whether all this is reasonable or not is in accordance with procedure may be understood differently by different people.
The author does not understand the rights and obligations of the organizing committee, and I think they must have the right to do so, otherwise this situation would not have arisen.
It is plagiarism, there is a previous crime, there should be vigilance, after all, the Lanting Award advocates the unity of books, which is very important.
No, some time ago, the chairman of the American Association was punished for plagiarism?
But if you have the experience of plagiarism, should you also deal with it so crisply? Probably to avoid suspicion.
Then again, only Wang Xi's gold medal was removed, but it was not clear that there was a problem of plagiarism, and not giving him a characterization was not protecting him? Don't you want to push an artist into the abyss inexorably?
Is it appropriate to do this? Can Wang Xi figure it out?
Will Wang Xi still be able to participate in the Lanting Award from now on? Can you participate in other national calligraphy competitions?
That's a problem.
<h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" data-track="5" > there is a third thing, how will calligraphy people play later? </h1>
How else can you play?
The unity of people and books, the unity of people and books, the unity of people and books!
Say important things three times!
I don't have much to say, but the connotation of the four words "unity of people and books" is very rich, and everyone understands it by themselves.
(Statement: I don't know or understand Wang Xi, and I have nothing to do with the organizing committee, that is, my brain is hot, I comment on a hot spot, and I hope that there will be no insults and no harm to each other... ）