<h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" data-track="1">
</h1>
On September 21, the public number "Yihai Gossip" published an article "Is this award-winning work of Lanting Award winner Wang Xi plagiarized?" In the "Yan Zhenqing Calligraphy Art Award Exhibition" held by the Shandong Book Association in 2018, Wang Xi's winning works were copied from xie Quansheng's winning works of the fifth Lanting Award.
On October 1, the public number "Yihai Gossip" published an article "OK! Lanting Award winner Wang Xi's "Yan Award" works plagiarized! From the content of the transcribed text, it is discussed and concluded that Wang Xi's "Yan Award" works plagiarize Xie Quansheng's works.
After the publication of the two articles, most readers and calligraphy insiders were positive about exposing the counterfeiting and condemning the counterfeiting itself.
However, there are also many "wonderful people", at the end of the article there are "wonderful people" message, which I call "no right and wrong, no logic and no shame", and several examples are recorded to entertain readers:
"You copy a copy and try it, you don't write and you're still blind!" ”
[Cheng Xin Tang] "If the author wants to become famous, he will work harder on writing, or several Lanting Awards, of course, he will also be famous throughout the country, so why use famous artists to hype himself?" ”
[a Wen Feng Tang 0099] "First: I can't write without the ability to write. Wang Xi is a textbook major, don't be jealous, his writing ability and artistic talent are difficult for many people to reach his level. Second: with his ability and achievements, do we still need to copy, we should not attack others like a frying pan for a little thing, each of us should be hearty to step down to the Ancient Post, this is the hard way. ”
[Cultivating ink] "Does the strength of the teacher still need to be copied?" It's hilarious."
"Calligraphy works are actually plagiarized? It can be seen that the freedom of speech has reached a bad point! ”
【-Zhou Junxiu】"Xie won the third prize and Wang won the first prize, so why not say that Wang's work is a life extension of Xie's work?" There is only one person in yan script! For example, the microscope was discovered a long time ago, but it did not insist, can it be said that the latter invented the microscope as plagiarism? Being able to bloom on the basis of others is also a kind of beauty! ”
……
Did the readers laugh and cry?
Such a commenter, there are only two situations, either bad or stupid, are incurable.
Why?
If he is a bad person, then no matter what you say and how you come up with conclusive evidence, he will not be convinced. A person who pretends to be asleep cannot wake up, a person who pretends to be blind, can you make him admit to seeing the facts?
If you are a fool, you don't have to try in vain to convince him or her.
The flowers of evil, growing from their rotten and fertile soil, flourished, and then burned into the world, and finally, counterfeiting seemed glorious.
In the face of these onlookers, do you want to turn the tide? Don't dream. Think of Zhou Xingchi's version of "Ji Gong", he bet that he could persuade the wicked people of the Ninth Dynasty to be good, and the prostitutes of the Ninth World to be good...
Turning back to the main topic, I wanted to make a detailed technical analysis of the plagiarism of Xie Quansheng Lanting Award works by Wang Xiyan Award works, but I felt tired and did not do it.
Let's choose a few examples, screenshots, and compare techniques.
What example to choose? That's the ligature (word group) in the work. If you want to send eight, choose 8 groups.
See:
First put the original picture of the work [White is Xie Quansheng's work, composed in 2014, which won the 5th Lanting Award; yellow is Wang Xi's work, composed in 2018, Yan Zhenqing's calligraphy art exhibition won the award. 】
【The picture above is Xie Quansheng's work】
【The picture above is Wang Xi's work】
The following is a comparison chart of 8 groups, white (picture right) is Xie Quansheng's original work, yellow (picture left) is Wang Xi's plagiarism, the division of the word group, the treatment of the pen, the treatment of light and heavy, the same, is simply a twin brother. [Due to the author's technical reasons, the screenshot can not reach the average size]
[1, the size of the word, weight and weight treatment is the same, "two, month" two words ligature]
[2, the orthography, the direction of the word, the division of the word group, the treatment of the pen, all the same]
[3, "Yongji" group, Yongzi small, Ji character typing, "Honshu" pen, "defense" pen, all the same way of processing]
【4. The orthography, word group, and ligature are the same】
【5. The same orthography, word group, stroke, light and heavy processing】
[6, word group segmentation, continuous pen processing, all the same]
【7, look at the twins】
[8) Are the twins so similar? 】