I analyze the main reasons for Feng Yuxiang's hacking: first, although Feng Yuxiang is very good to ordinary soldiers and ordinary people, they have no right to speak; second, Feng Yuxiang basically offended the upper echelons who hold the right to speak, so no one spoke for him.
First of all, why do I say that Feng Yuxiang is a patriotic general with standard standards:
First, Feng Yuxiang has always maintained a hard-working, simple and people-friendly style.
Feng Yuxiang served as the brigade commander of the 16th Mixed Brigade of the Army from 1914, and began to claim to be a warlord to become the leader of the Northwest Army, and then the leader of hundreds of thousands of Northwest Army. Even after the defeat in the Central Plains War, Feng Yuxiang held the position of vice chairman of the Military Commission of the Nationalist Government in Nanjing for a long time, second only to Chiang Kai-shek in the military.
It can be said that after Feng Yuxiang's debut, no matter whether he wins or loses, his status has never been lower, and he cannot lack money to spend. Some people say that it is a show, but for decades I can only say that this is a good habit and quality.
It was also Feng Yuxiang who shared weal and woe with the soldiers, so the soldiers of the Northwest Army have always had a tenacious style, good at close combat, night combat and white-knife warfare, and it is impossible for a unit without courage to be good at this style of play.
And some people black Feng Yuxiang coarse cloth clothes inside is a brocade, coarse rice under the cover of mountain treasures and seafood, this statement has neither evidence nor common sense. Is it possible that decades of doing this day without showing the horse's feet?
Feng Yuxiang has always been a coarse tea and light rice, sharing weal and woe with soldiers and the people. This is what countless sources can prove, and it is also seen by countless soldiers and ordinary people. Feng Yuxiang frequently goes to the streets and alleys to the fields, eats the rice cooked by the villagers, and then adds mountains and treasures to the seafood?
Feng Yuxiang's rong costume photo
Second, Feng Yuxiang's stand on the major issues of right and wrong in patriotism has always been firm.
The Luanzhou Uprising of 1911 was a military operation launched by Feng Yuxiang in response to the Wuchang Uprising on the edge of Beijing, which is a typical warrior action that knows that it cannot be done.
When the Beijing coup d'état broke out in Tianjin, Feng Yuxiang sent Lu Zhonglin up to do it, and the foreign devils immediately confessed, and could only vigorously support Zhang Zuolin to oppose Feng Yuxiang.
In the face of Japanese aggression, Feng Yuxiang practiced what he preached and ran directly to the chahar anti-Japanese front to form a team to resist the war.
After the outbreak of the All-out War of Resistance Against Japanese Aggression, Feng Yuxiang actually had no military power and served as vice chairman for a long time, which is supposed to be the position of high-ranking official Houlu Xiangfu.
However, Feng Yuxiang had no military power, so he went to collect donations, went to the streets and alleys of the city, the fields of the countryside, and his footprints were all over the rear, facing the citizens and peasants to give speeches, to sing anti-Japanese songs, to raise materials and troops for the anti-Japanese resistance, and to do what he could do.
Feng Yuxiang also went to our hometown to collect donations, saw the farm work to help, when the meal was brought by the villagers Feng Yuxiang took a big bite to eat, when resting, he sat on the ground like the villagers and preached the War of Resistance, this kind of skilled action is definitely not a person who can be driven out by people who are dressed in fine clothes and jade.
It can be said that Feng Yuxiang, whether he gained power or fell into Pingyang, never gave up on himself, did not spend days and days enjoying life like other warlords, but always did his best to contribute to the country. This is definitely an outlier among the warlords of the Republic of China and the upper echelons.
Feng Yuxiang was collecting donations for the anti-Japanese speech
Why would such a Feng Yuxiang be so miserable?
First, Feng Yuxiang's subordinates would not help him say good things.
The reason is Feng Yuxiang's arduous and simple style, Feng Yuxiang himself is hard and simple and shares the hardships with the soldiers, and also requires his own generals to do so, which is a severe crackdown on Feng Yuxiang, who violates the law.
Of course, this style of work is very welcome to grass-roots officers and men, and when the early forces were small, everyone was not of high status, and they all hated the corruption and corruption of the officials and the blood of the soldiers. On the contrary, this style of work makes the army brave and good at fighting, and its combat effectiveness is extremely strong.
However, after the Northwest Army controlled Shandong, Henan, and the vast areas of the northwest, the financial resources became abundant. These high-ranking generals were indispensable to covet pleasure.
Feng Yuxiang cracked down this kind of hedonistic behavior, and Feng Yuxiang's crackdown methods were too paternalistic, making these high-ranking generals very faceless, and natural contradictions intensified. The Northwest Army was basically crushed by Chiang Kai-shek's sugar-coated shells.
After these generals betrayed Feng Yuxiang, could they say that they betrayed because they coveted pleasure? Nature is impossible, it is definitely necessary to find the reason from Feng Yuxiang, and their descendants are even less likely to say good things for Feng Yuxiang.
Han Fuyu, who was bribed by Chiang Kai-shek
Second, the descendants of the nobles of the Qing Dynasty could not say good things for Feng Yuxiang.
After the 1924 Beijing coup d'état, Feng Yuxiang expelled Puyi from the Forbidden City as a point of intensification of the contradiction. Feng Yuxiang's anti-Qing attitude can be seen from the Luanzhou Uprising in 1911, and Puyi's restoration itself violated the agreement with the Republic of China, and Feng Yuxiang's expulsion of Puyi had sufficient legal and moral basis.
Their reason for blacking Feng Yuxiang was that Feng Yuxiang wanted to sell the cultural relics of the Forbidden City. But if you think about it, is there any evidence that Feng Yuxiang resold cultural relics? The vouchers for these Manchu nobles to sell cultural relics were very large.
Moreover, the hard and simple Feng Yuxiang sold cultural relics and the Manchu Qing nobles who sat on the mountains and ate the mountains to protect cultural relics, is this logic in line with people's common sense?
Zhang Xun's Restoration (Pictured is Puyi)
Third, chiang kai-shek of the Kuomintang is even less likely to say good things about Feng Yuxiang.
Chiang Kai-shek and Feng Yuxiang were sworn enemies, military opponents during the warlord period, and political enemies during the government period. I think that Feng Yuxiang's death is most likely to be done by Chiang Kai-shek.
However, chiang kai-shek's remnants have great influence in public opinion, and these people have spared no effort to boast about Chiang Kai-shek and the Kuomintang, and Hei Feng Yuxiang has done everything to the extreme.
He actually arranged All the passages that Feng Yuxiang was greedy for and afraid of death. It was difficult for Feng Yuxiang, who encountered foreign enemies and resolutely attacked himself, was greedy and afraid of death. Can Chiang Kai-shek, whose bones are soft in the face of foreign forces, be brave and good at war?
Looking at Feng Yuxiang's Northwest Army, which has always been famous for hand-to-hand combat with large knives and grenades, what did Chiang Kai-shek's Central Army rely on? It can only rely on firepower superiority.
Does this logic make sense?
In order, Yan Xishan, Feng Yuxiang, Chiang Kai-shek, and Li Zongren
Fourth, the so-called centrists will not speak for Feng Yuxiang.
The reason is similar to that of the generals of the Northwest Army, and even more so, because Feng Yuxiang has always been hardworking, simple and pro-people style. Although these centrists do not deal with Chiang Kai-shek, they are all from a big family. Whether it is other warlords or big intellectuals, whether they are politically powerful or not, their own food and clothing is still no problem.
These people have a lofty attitude toward the ordinary people, even intellectuals are also this attitude to criticize the common people at every turn, do you think that even Lu Xun is this kind of concept and behavior? When the country is in trouble and the people are in trouble, they are talking from on high, and Feng Yuxiang mingles with soldiers and people in the mud in the water.
Feng Yuxiang's behavior was first incompatible with them, second, they could not understand, and third, they also set off their diminutity. Therefore, their black Feng Yuxiang is also perfectly normal.
Fifth, foreigners will not speak for Feng Yuxiang.
This point of reason is too simple, Feng Yuxiang has always opposed the great powers, the British, French, Japanese, and Americans have not dealt with Feng Yuxiang, basically they have all been beaten by Feng Yuxiang, they must black Feng Yuxiang. The only Soviet Union with whom Feng Yuxiang had a good relationship disintegrated, and the Soviet Union itself was blackened.
The Northwest Army's large knife squad with grenades
The most popular people who can say good things about Feng Yuxiang are ordinary soldiers and peasants, but most of them have no culture, let alone the right to speak. Their descendants grew up to contact the viewpoint of the previous five kinds of people, so they also became the ones who shouted the slogan Hei Feng Yuxiang.
In fact, Hei Feng Yuxiang's most reason is to turn against him, and a little historical common sense knows that this statement is untenable at all:
First, Feng Yuxiang did not act treason but always acted patriotically.
Second, Feng Yuxiang debuted with Lu Jianzhang, and then set up his own portal, Feng Yuxiang not only did not betray Lu Jianzhang, but risked killing Xu Shuzheng to avenge Lu Jianzhang.
Third, the division and merger between the warlords is perfectly normal, whether it is the old warlords such as Duan Qirui, Wu Peifu, and Zhang Zuolin, or the new warlords such as Chiang Kai-shek, Yan Xishan, and Li Zongren, all of whom are fighting back and forth in the face of Qin Anduchu, and Feng Yuxiang just has not departed from the limitations of his own warlords, and there is no difference.