The second issue of "Singer" evaluation: Na Ying is second, Rainie Yang's second-hand roses are eliminated, and they all sing down?

Konoh E-Renko

2024-05-18 00:20Published in Hong Kong, China

Tonight's hot search was basically slaughtered by "Singer".

Let's talk about the results first, the first place is Fan Xiya, Na Ying is second, no matter what, Yingzi has improved by one place, which is worth encouraging!

But this time, the general perception of netizens is different from the first issue, I always feel that everyone is more relaxed than the first issue, but everyone doesn't sing so well? It's even "ugly" on the hot search!

And Hailai Amu, who everyone thought should be eliminated in the first issue, actually rose to the fourth place, and second-hand roses and Rainie Yang were eliminated, what is going on?

Let's give you another evaluation!

According to the order of appearance, the first Chante_Moore chose the song "Superwoman", which has advantages and disadvantages, the advantage is that "Superwoman" has been covered by many singers, including Lin Yilian, Zheng Xiuwen, Cao Ge, Faye Wong, etc., which are familiar to the audience and will not be very unfamiliar. But the problem is that there are so many versions of this song that they will inevitably be compared.

Chante_Moore seemed to have a little problem at the beginning, but it quickly adjusted back to a relaxed and natural state, and the singing is still in the big devil mode, but this arrangement is a little slower, which always makes people feel that they are not energetic enough, and it all depends on the singer's interpretation to support it.

And the second one to appear on the list is the Hang Gai band, singing "Reincarnation", it is indeed a feeling of galloping horses, as always, it gives people a sense of majestic and vast atmosphere, and it is no problem to fight against the big demon Chante_Moore, if you have to say something, we have also seen Hang Gai's performance on the show before, and the performance of "Singer" is expected to be amazing, and there are no unexpected surprises.

Therefore, the battle between Hang Gai and Chante_Moore is a strong duel, and it depends more on what type of music the public judges like.

After Hanggai, Wang Sulong sang "Flesh and Blood", and in the short film, he mentioned his mother, and decided to add a recitation to this song to express his heart to his mother. The idea is very good, the performance is much more relaxed than the first issue, the emotions are very sincere, if it is the first season of the first issue of "Singer", there is no problem, but the problem is that everyone has seen too many sensational interpretations on the "Singer" program before, Wang Sulong's version of "Flesh and Blood" is regarded as too sensational. And there are a lot of repetitive paragraphs, which doesn't sound very fresh, and the abrupt stop of the last part is very flavorful, and there is a sense of beauty of blank space.

But singing this song on this competitive stage, many netizens still feel that it is inappropriate, and there is even an "ugly" on the hot search. But I think this hot search is going on quickly, because there are still a lot of "ugly" ones behind......

After Wang Sulong finished singing, the unveiling singer Huang Xuan came. This rookie in Taiwan Province takes the route of R&B+ jazz, and the body language of the performance is very relaxed, but the feeling of singing is still a little nervous, and the pitch is a little run, and it is getting better and better in the back, and "Huang Xuan's relaxation" has also been on the hot search.

However, his song, just like durian, likes it very much, and those who don't like it completely accept incompetence. The quirky tone and words that don't seem to match will make it difficult for many people to accept, and I personally think it's more acceptable to listen to the CD version alone, which is in cooperation with Fan Xiaoxuan, the solo version is missing a female voice, and it will be more difficult to sing, and the up and down tune may also be the reason why netizens feel "weird".

Judging from the reaction of the audience shouting "Huang Xuan" after the performance, the scene should be more experiential, Huang Xuan may belong to a live singer, and the live broadcast is still slightly restricted.

Interestingly, the phrase "old woman" in his lyrics was also taken out by netizens to play with memes, contacting Wang Sulong's "mother", and then the "sister-in-law" of second-hand roses, which was played by netizens into "sister-in-law, mother, are all old women......

So let's talk about the second-hand rose's "Ode to Sister-in-law", in the last issue, everyone said that the soul of the second-hand rose was restricted by the black suit, and their soul still hasn't let go in this issue, they are still black, and Yao Lan's absence is even less flavorful.

As soon as the suona sounded, the soul of the second-hand rose came back, but the overly deep arrangement and the strange red lighting, netizens complained one after another, this is to send "sister-in-law away"?

This joke can't be opened, "Ode to Sister-in-law" is the theme song of the 1991 TV series "Zhao Shangzhi", Zhang Qianyi, who wrote the lyrics, knows that the Northeast people compare the sister-in-law to the mother, and the sister-in-law actually assumes the responsibilities of the mother, so he integrates the intention of "sister-in-law" into the song, so that the sister-in-law becomes a kind of call and shout for the nation in this song, and the song is praising the sister-in-law and the martyrs.

And the version of the second-hand rose does not sing the clear and lofty of the original Li Na version, nor does it have the same layering as Han Lei in the second season of "Singer", that is, the "deep feeling" is carried out to the end, although after understanding the background of the song, you can better understand their motivation for changing the song to such a deep one, but the original version and Han Lei's version can also resonate without being so deep.

In the end, because of this "Ode to My Sister-in-law", the second-hand rose was eliminated miserably, and before in "The Summer of the Band", the second-hand rose won the championship all the way, it can only be said that the stage of "Singer" does not match the aura of the second-hand rose.

Immediately followed by the second-hand rose, Hailai Amu sang "Could it be", there is no problem in singing, he is quite stable, and it is understandable that he ranks fourth only with the flawless performance content, but his singing method of clenching his back molars, coupled with various angry sounds, netizens instantly played the stalk "Hailai Amu invited God to invite Yang Kun"...... It's funny, isn't it? I don't know how many more periods of this kind of singing can last?

 The other one who was eliminated was Rainie Yang.

The Taiwan media was so excited that they repeatedly sent quick news reports.

As far as the song is concerned, Rainie Yang's choice of "Song Not for Anyone" finally makes people feel that they have returned to the popular stage in one second, the song is good, Rainie Yang also improved her expression management this time, smiling throughout the whole process, it is estimated that she has practiced a lot silently behind the scenes.

But the old problem still exists, the first word was almost sung wrong, slightly out of tune, and some high notes are also considered to be "hidden", these are also small flaws, the problem is that Rainie Yang used to feel sweet, and the little girl who sang a small song suddenly looked very hard to soar the big song, which made people feel unaccustomed.

Sometimes, it's a good strategy to stay in your comfort zone.

And Na Ying, who everyone is looking forward to the most, is still a little nervous when she sings Cui Di's "Break Free", but the advantages of her voice are all brought into play, and the treble part is also perfect, just be familiar with the song, I have been reading the lyrics, and I still forgot the words, and it was a little messy in the back. Giving the second place is encouragement, Yingzi don't be too proud.

Faouzia Fanxia, who appeared at the end, sang "Set Fire To The Rain" more relaxed than last time, I can only say that it is terrible relaxed, and the treble is also terrifyingly strong, and I feel that her first place is absolutely stable halfway through the singing.

If anything, she has always had no expression and looks like an AI.

To sum up, the main problem in this issue of "Singer" is still in the selection of songs and arrangement, and it is understandable that through completely different music styles and through the window of the show, it is excellent to show our completely different possibilities, diversity and inclusiveness in music;

But the idea is excellent, but in fact the display is not the same thing, there are some stages that do not exceed people's expectations, and some are lower than everyone's expectations, maybe the singer and the program team should try to find a balance between "public" and "hearing".

As for the various small flaws sung by the singers, I think it is still very vivid and natural, much better than those who don't open the microphone and fully repair the sound, and those who dare to go on this show to open the microphone to accept the challenge are courageous, so Second-hand Rose and Rainie Yang are also worth encouraging. Judging from the current ranking, the first, second and third places are reasonable, and the rest ...... Fight for it!

There will be Adam to fill in the next issue, I'm looking forward to it, let the smell of gunpowder be a little stronger!

View original image 413K

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

• 

Personal opinion, for reference only