Recently, several videos released by social media accounts "Zhao Juying's Family Education", "Home Visit to China" and "Zhao Juying Talking about Education" have sparked heated discussions. In the video, Zhao Juying hit the boy's palm with a ring ruler in her hand, and asked the girl to throw her toys and comic books into the trash. This series of behaviors was complained by netizens as "bullying" education.
The reporter noticed that during the home visit, Zhao Juying asked a junior high school boy to tell his dream, and also beat the boy with a ring ruler. "You don't brush the questions, how can you do well, you scored 100 points in physics for the first time, 99 points for the second time, and 96 points for the third time, stretched out your hand and took the initiative to put your hand on my ring ruler."
Picture/Screenshot of network video
In another home visit video, Ms. Zhao sits at the girl's desk, looking at the knick-knacks on the table, which she thinks will distract the girl. "You're in the second year of junior high school, how can you make it look like a kindergarten class, this is simply a baby in diapers, what is your dream? What about your goals? What about your study plans? What about your schedule? She then asked the girl to bag the knick-knacks and cards on the table and throw them in the trash can downstairs.
Picture/Screenshot of network video
Zhao Juying's social account shows that these videos were co-created and released by "Zhao Juying's Family Education", "Home Visit China" and "Zhao Juying Talk about Education", and the latter two accounts have relatively many fans, with 65,000 and 284,000 fans respectively. One of the accounts introduced Zhao Juying as follows: 33 years of senior family education expert, 33 years of senior language teacher, more than 1,000 lectures across the country, two books, a 3-year-old child who memorized 150 pure English world classics, and 7-year-old proficient in four Chinese.
Picture/Network screenshot
In the comment area, many netizens left messages saying that education is inspiration, not control. Some netizens bluntly said that they were very angry after seeing Zhao Juying's home visit video, "I don't think it's like education, it's like bullying."
Picture/Netizen message
According to Jimu News, on May 6, the staff of the Education Bureau of Jiayuguan City, Gansu Province, responded that Zhao Juying will retire from a primary school in the city in 2023, and the Education Bureau will intervene in the investigation in response to the problems reported by netizens.
On May 7, a reporter from Jingshi Live tried to contact Zhao Juying herself through three online accounts that publicly posted home visit videos, but as of press time, the other party has not responded.
In this regard, the reporter of Jingshi Live interviewed Ye Xianfa, a professor at the School of Education of Hubei University. Professor Ye said that he did not approve of Zhao Juying's education method. "I think Mr. Zhao adopts the most typical traditional education method in China, that is, if you don't fight, you can't become a talent, with the progress of society, the psychological needs of children and the change of our educational concepts, this traditional education method is not only not recognized in the society, children will also have a resistance psychology, this teacher's educational concept has been relatively backward."
Professor Ye believes that the education of children should be based on the concept of teaching students according to their aptitude and enlightening them. "Children have different levels of intellectual and character development, so they should be taught according to their aptitude. The first thing to do with a child should be to take care of him, so that he thinks that the teacher really loves him. If the child is disciplined like this, the child may be in awe of the teacher, and it will be difficult to develop love for the teacher, and in the long run, the child may resist and disagree with the teacher. ”