Introduction: Wen died in a traffic accident, and his extramarital lover Ling then gave birth to a baby boy, which sparked a controversy over whether he should inherit the estate. This case involved a dispute over the identity of the deceased's biological children and the right to inheritance, which gave rise to two different views in society.
The first point of view: equal civil rights
Proponents argue that as long as it can be proved that a baby boy is the biological child of the deceased, he should have the same civil rights as a legitimate child, including inheritance. In their view, the mode of procreation should not be a reason to deprive children of their legitimate rights. After all, births outside of wedlock do not affect the blood relationship between children and their parents and should be treated equally.
The second point of view: to defend public order and good customs
Some, on the other hand, insist that there is often a sinister motive behind unnatural pregnancies. They fear that if the law supports such an approach, it will set a dangerous precedent that could lead to abuse. For example, someone may use similar means to obtain an inheritance or settle a claim, which would pose a serious threat to social order and fairness.
Analysis & Perspectives:
The first point emphasizes the principles of equality and justice, and advocates that inheritance rights should be determined on the basis of consanguinity. The second viewpoint, however, is more concerned with protecting public order and good morals in society and preventing abuse and moral hazard. In this case, it is necessary to weigh the relationship between the rights and interests of the individual and the interests of society as a whole.
Conclusion:
In similar cases, the law should weigh the interests of all parties and make a judgment based on the specific circumstances. While protecting the legitimate rights and interests of children, it is also necessary to prevent the abuse of legal loopholes. Therefore, there is a need for stricter legal systems and norms to ensure that fairness and justice are achieved.