January 2nd
Music blogger @Acoustics, who once reported Mayday lip-singing
Published themselves on
Hunan Satellite TV's New Year's Eve party
Authenticity and falsetto identification
"It was one of the most painful evaluations I've ever had, and the larger the chorus, the shorter the dwell and the more difficult it was to judge," it wrote. According to the radio of a few real singers, there is a high probability that real-time sound repair will be started at this New Year's Eve party. ”
According to its identification, Li Ronghao, Phoenix Legend, Chen Chusheng, Wang Lixin, Jolin Tsai, Zhang Yuan, Wang Zhengliang, Chen Jiaye, Hua Chenyu, Wang Yaoqing and other true singers. Its appraisal said that Li Xian, Yu Shuxin, Zhao Lusi, Yang Zi, Tan Jianci, Wang Yibo, Wang Hedi, Song Qian, Lu Yuxiao, Meng Huiyuan, MAME Group, Wei Daxun, Wang Qiming, Pu Xia, Qi Wei, Li Chengxuan, Times Youth League, etc. are lip-synching.
He said that the opening show chorus was a mixture of true and false, and some of the songs, the chorus could not be identified, the soloists were all fake singing, and some singers such as Da Zhang Wei, Huang Xiaoming, and Han Hong were suspicious.
The original text is as follows:
#New Year's Eve Party True Lip Singing Identification# of Hunan Satellite TV:
Warm and good six groups, riding the wind forward group "Opening Show": a mix of truth and falsehood.
Liu Yiyun, Cheng Xiao, Li Sidanni, Jin Chen, Yuan Yonglin, Chen Bing "Sister and Sister Dance": The chorus part cannot be identified, and the solo part is all lip-synching.
Li Ronghao's "Model", "Li Bai", "Composer", "The King of Comedy", "Uncompromising", "Mom and Dad", "Quit Smoking", "Young and Promising", "Sparrow", "Plum Sauce": real singing.
Zhang Tianai, Sun Yi, Qiao Xin "Splitting Your Thunder is on the Road": Female singers in evening dresses and female singers in short skirts are suspicious (partial lip singing), and female singers in wedding dresses are lip synching.
Song Qian's "Functional Domination": Being like this is lip-to-lip singing in my personal standards.
He Jiong, Xu Song "Why not": The chorus part cannot be determined, and He Jiong's solo part is doubtful.
Xu Song's "Customs Clearance" and "Superfluous Explanation": Doubtful (Partial True Singing).
Phoenix Legend "Lady of Luxury", "The Most Dazzling National Style": True singing.
Da Zhang Wei and Wang Yibo "Songs That Can Never Be Sung": Da Zhang Wei small mat, Wang Yibo big pad, the latter is lip syncing in my personal standards.
Chen Chusheng "The Original Me": True singing.
Chen Chusheng, Wang Lixin, Zhang Yuan, Wang Zhengliang "Deserved": True singing.
Yao Anna "To a Windy Place": Doubtful.
Li Xian's "When the Stars Shine": Lip-synching.
虞书欣《Gwalla》:假唱。
Xie Na, Chen Jiahua, Liu Yiyun "Who is the MVP": doubtful (biased).
Zhao Lusi's "Crescent Bay": lip-synching.
Song Qian, Wang Hedi "Roof on Fire": Lip-synching.
Cheng Yi's "Just Above the Rivers and Lakes" and "The End of the World": The former song is doubtful (biased), and the latter song is falset-sung.
Yang Zi "Sauvignon Blanc": Lip sync.
Times Youth League "Love to 1440": Being like this is lip-synching in my personal standards.
戚薇、李承铉《狂恋》：假唱。
Wei Daxun's "Orchid Pavilion Preface": Lip-synching.
Da Zhang Wei's "The Law of All Things in Bloom": Doubtful, suspected of being a mixture of truth and falsehood.
Tan Jianci's "Can't Wait" and "Mona Lisa": the first song is doubtful (the main song is true, and the chorus is false);
Huang Xiaoming, Zhifu "Rainbow Smile": Doubtful, Zhifu is seriously biased.
Xie Na, Mario, Xiao Yuner "My Paper Airplane": True singing.
He Jiong, Wang Han, Times Youth League "Float Show": The chorus cannot be identified.
Han Hong's "Millennium Covenant": Doubtful.
Wang Yibo's "Spectator": Being like this is lip-synching in my personal standards.
蔡依林《热冬》、《大丈夫》、《怪美的》、《马德里不可思议》、《I'M NOT YOURS +舞娘》、《OH LA LA》:真唱。
Wang Hedi's "Shanlan": Falsetto singing, you can hear two shouts from time to time.
Wang Hedi, Wang Qiming, Pu Shark "Tango by the Sea": lip-synching.
陈嘉桦《愿望清单》、《热带雨林》、《Super Star》:真唱。
Cai Guoqing, Wang Yaoqing, and the Times Youth League "Miracle Reappearance": Cai Guoqing and Wang Yaoqing are suspicious, and the chorus of the Times Youth League cannot be identified.
Hua Chenyu "Sea of Wind", "Ordinary to Extraordinary Life": True singing.
Phoenix Legend, Zhao Lusi "It's All Love": Phoenix Legend is really singing, Zhao Lusi is suspicious.
Wang Yaoqing "Uncle Like This": True singing.
Cai Guoqing, Lu Yuxiao, Meng Huiyuan, MAME group "365 Blessings": lip-syncing.
Big wave people "cross": lip-syncing.
……
This is the most touching and painful authenticity identification in history, otherwise there would not be so many "doubts". First of all, there is a large number of choral repertoire, and the larger the number of singers, the shorter the stay time of each person, and the more difficult it is to judge. The chorus part, in particular, has little way to identify.
In addition, according to the radio of a few real singers, this Hunan Satellite TV New Year's Eve party, there is a high probability that real-time sound repair will be opened, so that the gap between the true and false singing sound field is not so big, and it is very easy to be confused when watching for a long time and judging fatigue. It can be said that this party has indeed updated and iterated the lip-syncing technology through various methods, and the difficulty of identification has become greater. It's hard to put into words.
However, after its appraisal was released, it was questioned by many netizens, saying that its credibility was not high.
In addition, this morning the blogger released the authentic and fake singing appraisal of Dragon TV's New Year's Eve party, the original text is as follows:
#New Year's Eve Party True Lip Sync Identification# of Dragon TV:
Tengger's "Invisible Wings", "Love You", "The Sun Never Sets": doubtful (biased); "Black Plum Sauce", "Courage Explosion": fake singing.
Awakening, Land Rover "The Daily Life of an Old Singer": Real Singing.
Awakening, Land Rover, Fu Longfei, Zhao Rang, Xu Zimo "Longli Electric Wire": The rap part is really sung, and the melody part of the first part is sung in doubt (it should just turn on the effect).
苏醒《Rising Land》：真唱。
Zhang Xincheng "The Appearance of Dreams": Real singing.
Su Huilun, Yang Kun "Every Day in My Life": True singing.
Yang Kun "Today is Your Birthday": True singing.
Huang Minghao's "One Many": Lip-synching (singing and dancing have no privileges).
黄景瑜《逆光前行》：存疑。
Gong Jun "Clear Sky Tomorrow": Doubtful.
Huang Ling's "Wang Zhaojun": If it is a live performance, it is lip-syncing, and if it is a recorded performance, it may only be done in the later stage.
Guangliang "Fairy Tale": True singing.
Ah Niu "Peach Blossoms": Real singing.
Guangliang, A Niu, Ren Xianqi "Waves and Flowers": True singing.
Zhang Qi "Cage": True singing.
萧敬腾《在无名指有你的名字》、《Can You Feel The Love Tonight》：真唱。
Zhan Wenting "Crescent Bay": Real singing.
Mei Yi Liya, Teku "Pure Land": True singing.
Zhan Wenting, Mei Yi Liya "Blue Bird": True singing.
张信哲《悬溺》、《太想爱你》：真唱。
Tian Xiwei and Cheng Lei "Sweet": lip-syncing.
Huang Qishan and Man Shuke "To the Clouds": True singing.
Huang Qishan "My Beauty": True singing.
王子浩《A· I.BAE》：假唱。
BOYHOOD《圆地登陆》:假唱。
Zhang Shaohan "Flowers in Dreams" and "The Farthest Place to See": True singing.
In other words, it's not.
Huang Bo "Lin Sujuan": True singing.
'??
Zhang Ruoyun's "Pushing Open the Door of the World": Doubtful (the pitch is like real singing, the sound field is not like real singing, and the whole is true singing).
李健《如愿》、《Marine玛琳娜》:真唱。
Tengger, Bai Jugang "The Lonely Brave": doubtful.
刘雨昕《63EBE9》、《节奏病》:真唱。
Land Rover, Chen Caoxu "The World is Strange and Strange, You Can Be Cute and Love": The recording and broadcasting do not participate in the identification.
Wu Qingfeng's "The Wind Rises", "What Are You Worried about": Really sing.
Wu Qingfeng, Lisa Ono "(Brown-haired Girl)": True singing.
Lisa Ono, Wu Qingfeng "I Do": True singing.
胡歌、唐嫣《再回首》：假唱。
"Ode to Joy" by the stars: the chorus cannot be identified.
Ayunga and Pan Hangwei "Phantom of the Opera": True singing.
Zhang Xincheng's "Movement of the Night": True singing.
赵超凡《别无他求》：真唱。
Ayunga, Zhang Xincheng, Zhao Chaofan, Pan Hangwei, Miao Mengchu, Jing Yanqiao, Zhu Hanbin, Shi Yifei "We Are Musical": Although the chorus cannot be identified, the duet chorus considering the higher difficulty coefficient is all real singing, and there is no reason to fake sing in the chorus.
In other words, it's not.
Man Shuke, Wu Mochou, Fu Longfei, Naiwan "Mountains and Rivers": True singing.
Tang Jiuzhou, Cao Feiran, Zhang Wanqing "The Evening Wind Meets You": Lip-synching.
Yunfei and Gong Shuang "China in the Lights": Real singing.
PS: This qualification is only for the live TV version, as for the live version, whether to replace the sound source (which is extremely unlikely) is not within the scope of the discussion.
Source: Urban Live Comprehensive Cover News, Minnan Net, @声理学 Weibo