Cui Hao, "Yellow Crane Tower"
The people of the past have gone by the Yellow Crane, and the Yellow Crane Tower is empty here.
The yellow crane is gone, and the white clouds are long in the air.
Harukawa calendar Hanyang tree, yerba buena parrot island.
Where is the Nippori Pass, the Yanbo River makes people sad.
There are three kinds of evaluations of this poem by previous generations, one is positive, all say good, more; one is negative, bad is not, less; one is neutral, and it is not enough to say good. They are listed separately today.
First, positive evaluation, said good:
Among them, Yan Yu, Wu Changqi, and He Zhuo are the most serious. It is said that this poem is the first Tang poem, and it is a thousand autumns that are uniquely sung, and it is comparable to Du Fu.
1, Yan Yu's "Canglang Poetry": Seven laws of poetry, when Cui Hao's "Yellow Crane Tower" as the first.
2, Liu Chenweng's "Commentary on The Poetry of the Sheng Tang Dynasty": But with its recklessness and recklessness, it is called ingenuity.
3, Fang Hui "Yingkui Law Essence": The first four sentences of this poem are informal, and the momentum is majestic.
4, Xin Wenfang's "Biography of Tang Caizi": Cui You Wuchang, Denghuang Crane Tower, generous poetry. And Li Bailai, who said: "There is a scene in front of you, and Cui Hao's inscription poem is on the top." "Go away without doing anything, and collect hands for the philosopher."
5, "Tang Poetry Selected Pulse Will Pass the Commentary" Li Mengyang said: One breath, pure and bright, too white so see the bend.
6, "Tang Poetry Selected Pulse Will Pass the Commentary" Zhou Jingyue: The whole passage is sparse, the place is tragic, and the wonderful nature is complete.
7, Gu Xuan's "Batch Point Tang Yin": This article is too white to be convinced, I think it is a momentary landing, happy to flow out, may not often have this work. The first four sentences describe the reason for the name of the building, and the last four sentences allude to the feelings of emotion, and the starting sentence is high and realistic.
8, "Tang Shigui" Tan Yuanchun yue: This poem is wonderful in the ease, everything is written. Too white and wasteful, humble and respectable.
9, Xu Xueyi's "Poetry Source Discernment": Cui "Yellow Crane", "Wild Goose Gate", read with Jinshi, the Voice of the Palace Merchant, Gai Later Zuoye.
10, Feng Ban's "Only Mobilized Reading Book": momentum is overwhelming.
11, Xing Fang's "Tang Fengding": This song is also in the style, and the rhythm is more into the divine realm. Yunqing (Shen Qi) "Ancient Yi" is like a exercise, which is the highest.
12, Jin Sheng sighed "Selected Tang Caizi Poems": This amazing pen also.
13, Fan Dashi's "Poetry of the Past Dynasties": This is like nineteen ancient poems, which are space yuanqi, suddenly teased into the pen, the author does not know it at first, the viewer is amazed by the masterpiece, and also appreciates the clumsy ear of the meaning.
14, Wu Changqi's "Deleting Tang Poetry Interpretation": not ancient and irregular, also ancient law, a thousand autumns singing, why li tang alone?
15, He Zhuoyun's "Tang Three-Body Poetry Interpretation": This body posture can be matched with Lao Du's "Dengyue Yang Lou".
16, Zhu Zhijing's "Excerpts from The Supplementary Tang Poems": Majestic and proud of the shore, all won with qi, straight as the text of the "National Policy", and its method is extremely meticulous.
17, Qu Fu's "Tang Poetry into the Law": the law is free, the rhythm is adjusted to the leaves and the leaves, and the Qinglian (Li Bai) immortal talent, the pen is immediately shelved, and it has been high for eternity.
18, Shen Deqian's "Tang Poetry": Meaning is like first, outside the divine line, written in a vertical pen, so that it is good at the wonders of eternity.
19, Wang Jizhi's "Continuation of The Poetry of the Whole Tang Dynasty": Although the Tang people are legal poems, they do not work on the food. The two sentences of "Harukawa Calendar" are transcendent, not bound by the law, and have their own aftertaste.
20, Wang Minyun's "Xiangqilou Saying Poems": There is a sense of fluttering.
Second, negative evaluation, bad to say:
21, Wang Shizhen's "Quan Tang Poetry Sayings": Cui Qifa is the tang song line, such as weaving palace brocade, one foot embroidery between, brocade is brocade, such as full width?
22, Hu Yinglin's "Shi Wei": Cui Hao "Yellow Crane", song line short chapter ear. Taibai did not like haiku in his life, and Cui Shishi was suitable for it. Because of this, the Yan clan agreed. It is not as good as pushing Shen (Shen Qi period) as a de facto.
23, Hu Zhenheng's "Tang Yin Decoction": Now Guan Cui Shi is a short chapter of the song line, the law of the unfinished, An can be too white to taste the effect, so take the pressed scroll?
24, Fang Dongshu's "Zhao Ming Zhan Yan": This body can no longer be learned, learning is tasteless, not as good as the "Lu Family Young Woman" (Shen Qi period poem) has a degree of law, can be the law of thousands of years.
25, Pan Deyu's "Yang Yi Zhai Poetry": Cui Shi te refers to the ancient tune, which is not the right of the law poem.
Third, neutral evaluation, saying good is also insufficient:
26, Lu Shiyong's "Tang Poetry Mirror": This poem is high in style and as if it were natural. The First Lawyer is not as good as he is. The law of ancient style is still not possible in the five houses, let alone the seven words? Posterity was pushed by Taibai, and did not dare to be obedient.
27, "Tang Shigui" Zhong Yu said: This is not the first Tang master can not. Reading Li Taibai's "Phoenix Terrace" body is not regarded as a poem of "Yellow Crane Tower".
28, Wang Fuzhi's "Selection of Tang Poems": Pengfei Elephant Line, amazing and far-reaching. Even from the beginning of nostalgia, it is an inscription building poem, not a climbing building. A knot is not as good as "Phoenix Stage", in order to mean more to hinder the qi also.
29, "Yingkui Law Essence Publication Error" Ji Yunyue: Occasionally, it becomes a unique tune, but it must not be without one, it cannot have two, and once it is copied, it will become a trap.
30, Wu Yan's "Tang Poetry Selection": This poem is all endowment, and the first four sentences are inspired by climbing the stairs.
Fourth, attached, the positive evaluation of the near and present people:
31, Yu His Majesty's "Poetry Brief Commentary": Setting up Cui Zhuan Yong Jiang Jing may not be able to go out of the Du (Fu) Meng (Haoran) range. And Cui Du thought about it from the three words of "Yellow Crane Tower", saying that he looked forward to Yun Si Xian Guke. It is said that it is unknowable because of the immortals, and it is vast and full of mixed feelings, especially the infinite taste.
32, Cheng Qianfan's "Ancient Poems and Present Selections": because of the scenery and homesickness, the theme is habitual, and the weather is broad, the style is exquisite, and the second link also breaks through the general law poems to be flat and between each other, and the dual sentences are stipulated. Li Bai read it, admired it very much, and repeatedly copied it in the few seven laws he wrote.
Above, excerpts 32 comments by the ancients, recent people, and present people on Cui Hao's "Yellow Crane Tower" poem. Among them, most of the negative evaluators are criticizing Cui Shi's jaw connection for not being dual, not being in line with the level, and not being the seven laws of integrity. However, Mr. Cheng Qianfan, a modern person, has put forward this kind of "breaking through regulations" as an advantage or a strong point. It can be seen that the times are different, and people's evaluation of Cui Shi has also changed. However, the biggest change in ancient and modern times is that the negative evaluation of Cui Shi has completely disappeared.
Eight pictures: Yellow Crane Tower
