Wu Song, as a classic character in "Water Margin", after making a TV series adaptation, he extended two different versions of the classic Wu Song, that is, Wu Song played by Zhu Yanping in the Shandong version of "Water Margin" and Wu Song in the 98 version of "Water Margin". For these two versions of Wu Song has actually been a better debate, Zhu Yanping's Wu Song has been 38 years ago, and there is Ding Haifeng's version of Wu Song in the middle, but he can still leave an indelible impression in people's hearts. The reason why Zhu Yanping's version of Wu Song can have a far-reaching influence has a lot to do with his appearance and temperament.
The description of Wu Song in "Water Margin" is: his body is frozen and his appearance is magnificent. A pair of eyes shot towards the cold star, and the two bent brows were like brush paint. The chest is wide and has the majesty of the invincible. And Zhu Yanping because of a meter eight large, raw thick eyebrows and big eyes four square chinese character face, eyebrows between the exudes a heroic righteousness, and the novel of Wu Song is very similar, when starring in the role of Wu Song is even more considered to highly restore the image of Wu Song in the original work, coupled with the Shandong version of "Water Margin" broadcast one step ahead, Zhu Yanping version of Wu Song has had an immeasurable influence on the limelight so far.
However, since Zhu Yanping's version of Wu Song has a deep influence on the audience, why didn't he ask him to star when preparing for the 98th edition of "Water Margin"? If such a classic role is played again, it should bring a wave of heat to the 98 version of "Water Margin".
In fact, when the 98 version of the "Water Margin" project was launched, the crew invited Zhu Yanping at the beginning, and the staff should have been the supporters of Zhu Yanping's version of Wu Song, and they all unanimously suggested that Zhu Yanping be asked to play Wu Song again, but they were rejected by Zhu Yanping. Zhu Yanping's reason for refusing is simple: Wu Song is a character he has already played, and he does not want to repeat it!
To tell the truth, Zhu Yanping doing this is actually a correct decision, as far as the current point of view, in terms of TV series remake, but everything that involves re-acting, remakes of such works, the probability of throwing the street is very high, and the 98 version of "Water Margin" has been fifteen years since Zhu Yanping played Wu Song, he also entered middle age from a vibrant young man, if he really played Wu Song again at that time, there may be an embarrassing situation such as Ding Haifeng playing Wu Song again in the near future, although the appearance and the heroic temperament that comes with it are consistent with Wu Song. However, the obvious old state will still become the topic of criticism, so Zhu Yanping's refusal to perform at that time is also a wise move. However, for the dispute between The good and bad of Zhu Yanping's version of WuSong and Ding Haifeng's version of Wusong, there is actually not much need.
Although the Shandong version of Zhu Yanping version of Wusong is deeply popular, but because compared with the distribution channel of the CCTV version of "Water Margin", the limitations are still very large, so the fan base is a big difference from the beginning, plus Ding Haifeng's version of Wusong is as good as Zhu Yanping's version of Wusong, so it naturally gained a lot of fame and more supporters, so if you vote, Zhu Yanping's version of Wusong is unable to compete with Ding Haifeng's version of Wusong.
But if you say it from the content and acting skills, both are excellent, first of all, the image and temperament of both are consistent with the image of Wu Song in the original work. Ding Haifeng can enter the CCTV version of the "Water Margin" crew just after his debut, it is by virtue of his own tough, righteous, and arrogant image, after Zhu Yanping refused to act, the crew also found a lot of muscle men to audition, and finally boldly used the newly debuted Ding Haifeng. It is estimated that the crew did not expect ding hai summit to become the most successful wu song actor in film history.
Speaking of the most successful Wu Song actor, why only mention Ding Haifeng's version, this is related to the presentation effect of the TV series.
From the perspective of TV drama effects, Zhu Yanping's version of Wu Song can be described as early in the broadcast, defeat also played early, Shandong version of "Water Margin" because the shooting time is too early, so the shooting techniques to catch up still stay in the mode of the model play, so that the fight scene has its own drama effect, and now looking back, it feels like a board at a glance, the posture is more, there is no kind of fist to flesh real fighting addiction.
On the other hand, the 98 version of "Water Margin", in terms of people's evaluation, is that as long as the screams together make people get goosebumps, coupled with the action design of Yuan Pingwu, every fight scene of Wu Song is a good fight, fist to flesh, it can also be said that no one can defeat our Wu Erlang in the scream! So in this regard, Ding Haifeng's version of Wu Song has the upper hand, speaking of which we have to mention Yuan Heping's guidance, the success of the 98 version of "Water Margin", his merits are high and high, the biggest attraction of this group of good men on Liangshan is the wonderful play, so Yuan Baye has worked hard for the filming of "Water Margin", and several classic martial arts clips have been worshipped as gods: such as making a big fuss about Wutai Mountain, the Temple of Fengxue Mountain, beating the head of the Hong Sect with sticks, drunkenly beating Jiang MenShen, and so on.
Let's go on to say Zhu Yanping's version of Wu Song and Ding Haifeng's version of Wu Song, in terms of plot comparison, it seems that the CCTV version of Wu Song is more full, Zhu Yanping because this face is too righteous and awe-inspiring, from beginning to end is a mature and brave image, it is inevitable to feel thin, and in the original work, Wu Song actually had a kind of anger at the beginning, from him stunting secrets on Chai Jinzhuang to Song Jiang, to playing Sun Erniang, to drunkenly flirting with Jiang Men's god daughter-in-law, all of which also revealed the anger of not knowing the world. Before being framed by Zhang Dujian, Wu Song was still a kind and simple barbarian, and Ding Haifeng also performed the image of Wu Song's simple righteousness, and even played with sticks at His sister in Zhang Dujian's mansion, asking for praise like a child. However, when he was framed by Zhang Dujian and was physically and mentally injured, he made a big fuss about Fei Yunpu's blood splashing the Mandarin Duck Building, and then the whole person's temperament became cold and took off the previous childishness, and this change in image indicated that Wu Song had become mature. After becoming Liangshan, after seeing through the thoughts of those people on Liangshan who were moving closer to the imperial court, he began to become indifferent, which was a kind of disappointed indifference, and this change in temperament and mentality was also the process of gradually seeing through the red dust, and finally became a monk at Liuhe Temple, obtained a good death, and lived to the age of eighty.