In the Chinese Football League, there have been more than a dozen obviously controversial penalties in the first 9 rounds of the Chinese Super League alone, and there are even more in the Chinese Football League. Of course, some penalties were found to be correct by the referee committee of the Football Association, and some penalties were found to be wrong.
Before the start of the 2024 season of the Chinese Super League, the Chinese Football Association held a special opening ceremony for the training of referees before the league season, and trained the referees in the 2024 season, especially for the unified league penalty scale. The training was attended by 13 referee instructors, 33 referee supervisors and 99 referees, and the main content of the training involved VAR intervention rules, handball fouls, offside, scrambles, tactical fouls and other standard penalty rules.
This season, the Chinese Football Association and the referee team have made a very meaningful innovation, that is, the introduction of a referee penalty evaluation mechanism. In other words, after the match, the club has the right to appeal the disputed decision, which will be received by the referee committee and organized by experts to make an official evaluation. Wushuang Sports has sorted out that as of today, a total of 14 misjudgments have been mentioned in the 5 league judging and evaluation announcements issued by the referee committee. The teams involved in the review mainly include Beijing Guoan, Shanghai Shenhua, Zhejiang, Shanghai Port, Shandong Taishan, Chengdu Rongcheng and other teams, and the controversy points involve not only ordinary assistant referees, but also individual international referees and VAR referees.
On April 30, 2024, the Chinese Football Association officially announced the 5th phase of 10 referee evaluation cases, and finally determined that 6 cases were correct and 4 cases were wrong, of which 4 were wrong by the head referee, 1 was wrong by the assistant referee, and 2 were wrong by VAR intervention. A partial screenshot of the ruling is below:
On April 23, 2024, the Chinese Football Association officially announced the fourth phase of 2 referee evaluation cases. The first case had correct VAR intervention, and the second case had wrong VAR intervention.
On April 17, 2024, the Chinese Football Association officially announced the third phase of 8 referee evaluation cases, in which 1 Chinese Super League referee was found to have misjudged. In the match between Qingdao West Coast and Tianjin Jinmen Tigers, VAR intervened correctly, and the referee showed a red card and made an error, and the original decision was still wrong after VAR intervention.
On April 2, 2024, the Chinese Football Association officially announced the second phase of 5 referee evaluation cases, of which 4 referees missed judgments and only 1 was correct.
On March 11, 2024, the Chinese Football Association officially announced the first phase of 3 referee evaluation cases, of which 2 penalties were finally ruled correct and 1 was wrong.
There is a unified standard for refereeing penalties, but sometimes it is necessary to analyze the specific situation on a case-by-case basis, and it is relatively normal to involve some controversial penalties, not only in the Chinese football community, but also in other associations, and the international arena is no exception. The key is to be able to unify the standard scale of punishment as much as possible, be fair and just, be less subjective, and be less presumptuous. The red and yellow cards are Shang Fang's sword, but they cannot be used indiscriminately. To be a referee, you must be worthy of the referee's armband and Chinese football.
Knowing that mistakes can be corrected, and good is great. Let's not talk about whether all the rulings are fair, reasonable and convincing to the public, but the referee committee can respond to the club's appeal application in a timely manner and respond to hot issues in a timely manner, which is very worthy of praise. It's just that the referee may be punished internally if the penalty is wrong, but the one who pays the bill will always be...
The original code word is not easy, thank you for your support and please leave your wonderful comments.
Pay attention to Wushuang Sports, and share with you the latest and most complete sports information and original reviews for the first time.