#头条创作挑战赛#新三国距离开播已经十四年, it's not new, the play says that the official history is not the right history, that the romance is not the right, and that the whole thing is nondescript, but there are always people who say that the real history knows and the adaptation is good-looking, but even if the official history and romance are put aside, the play also has a lot of illogical and contradictory plots, this article will talk about this issue, about the drama review of the new Three Kingdoms, this number has been written before, if you are interested, you can refer to: The New Three Kingdoms Broadcast Ten Years: The Palace Fight Drama in the Three Kingdoms.
Ordinary creeps and squires were deaf and blind
In the first episode, in order to express that Cao Cao was different from other ministers who hated Dong Zhuo but were submissive, Cao Cao shouted "Dong Zhuo!" in front of Yuan Kui, the problem is that if you only do it in front of Yuan Kui, the countless guards around you are Dong Zhuo's people, and your ghost crying wolf howls in your voice, at least anyone with ears within a radius of 100 meters can hear it. As a result, none of the guards went to arrest Cao Cao, and none of them went to Dong Zhuo to inform, saying that Cao Cao was pretending to defect to Xiangguo.
After that, Cao Cao assassinated Dong and ran away, but Wang Yun and others opened champagne in advance on the way to the palace, and conspired loudly in front of a group of Xiliang troops, but in the end there was still no one to inform, Dong Zhuo went to Wang Yun's house to search around and no longer suspected Cao Cao if he didn't find him.
And the plot of Cao Cao's murder in his dream, Cao Cao was also in the heroic plot of Qingmei Cooking Wine, telling Liu Bei in person that he killed people in his dream to prevent others from assassinating, and then Liu Bei sighed that it was not the prime minister in the dream, but the world in the dream. There are many slots, first of all, Cao Cao trusts Liu Bei so much, will it not be passed on? And with the previous problem, even if Liu Bei disdains to pass on this kind of thing, can you not be a soldier or an attendant is an NPC, but there are attendants next to him, are you not afraid of them leaking secrets?
Who's suspicious?
Catching and releasing Cao is a famous allusion in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms, Cao Cao attempted to assassinate Dong Zhuo, disguised and fled, and was captured by Chen Gong in Zhongmu County. Hou Cao used his words to impress Chen Gong and caused Chen to flee with him. When they arrived in Chenggao, they went to find Cao's father's old friend Lu Bohao, and Lu Bohao killed pigs for hospitality. Cao Cao smelled the sharpening of his knife and mistakenly thought that Lu Bo wanted to cause harm, so he killed the entire Lu family, burned the village and fled. Chen Gong was very remorseful when he saw that Cao Cao was ruthless and killed innocent people in vain; when he stayed at the hotel, he wanted to assassinate Cao Cao while Cao Cao was asleep and then gave up and left alone.
And in the new Three Kingdoms, Cao Cao was originally asleep in bed, and it was Chen Gong who woke up Cao Cao suspiciously when he heard the sound of sharpening the knife before he started to kill, if he hadn't been suspicious and woke up, it is estimated that Cao Cao would have slept a lot, but after the two of them killed people together, Chen Gong backhanded - "Mengde, you are too suspicious", who is suspicious?
In addition, in the play, Lu Bohao's servant killed a pig and ran to Cao Cao's door to sharpen his knife, and said "Jian goods, this will kill you". Who killed pigs and said that......
In the end, there are several princes who cut down Dong
In the first episode, Cao Cao was still on Dong Zhuo's side, Yuan Shao had already gathered the princes of the Eighteenth Road, and Cao Cao also gave Dong Zhuo advice, saying that the princes of the Eighteenth Road were a rabble.
Later, after Guan Yu beheaded Huaxiong, Yuan Shao named Liu Bei as the prince of the Nineteenth Road, and after the Battle of Chibi, Cao Cao said that the princes of the Eighteenth Road were left with Ma Teng and Liu Bei. So Cao Cao is not among the princes of the Eighteen Roads?
The princes of the Eighteenth Road asked for Dong, and the princes defended the city and Dong Zhuo attacked the city
This is also the most outrageous place of the new three, it is clear that the princes of the Eighteenth Road are the party attacking the city, attacking the Tiger Prison Pass, and the station of the princes of the Eighteenth Road is called the camp, which is stronger at most, and it is far from being a city. And the princes of the New Three Kingdoms and the Eighteen Roads, they live directly in the city, but it's okay, after Dong Zhuo led the troops out of Luoyang, he became the party attacking the city, Dong Zhuo even said to Lu Bu that his Xiliang army is good at field warfare, not good at attacking fortifications, so if you want Lu Bu to lure the princes out of the city, it's a real siege war.
And the new third version of Liu Guan Zhang Geyan, after Liu Bei was given to the princes of the 19th Road, lived in a relatively simple house, and the screenwriter of the new third was most likely to show that although Liu Bei was given to the princes of the 19th Road, he was still not taken seriously. But the problem is that the screenwriter has no common sense at all, and when marching and fighting, he normally lives in tents, and Liu Bei has a private house to live in, is this called being despised? Of course, in the screenwriter's brain circuit, the princes of the 18th Road are the defenders of the city, and they must all have good houses to live in.
Liu Bei, who immediately came to participate in the allied war against Dong after the rebellion
Xinsan completely deleted the plot of Liu Bei's fight for the Yellow Turban, and after they formed a rebellion in Taoyuan, they directly chose to participate in the allied fight against Dong. Originally, it was not impossible for you to set it up like this, but the follow-up plot was still based on Liu Bei is county order, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were horse archers, and step archers were interpreted, which is not right.
For example, Liu Bei claimed that the three of them came from the plains, and Liu Bei was the plain order, of course he took Guan Zhang from Pingyuan, but the new three Liu Bei came immediately after the rebellion, and the three of them were purely civilians before, why did they still come from Pingyuan? The three of them were changed their household registrations? And the new three Zhang Fei was furious when he heard that Yuan Shu's subordinates said that the three of them were weaving mats and selling shoes, and they were slaughtering pigs and selling wine, which is not right, the new three Liu Bei introduced himself like this when he came, and others just stated the facts, what are you angry about?
If your brother is like history, or romance, he already has an official position, of course others say this deliberately humiliating, but you don't, it's just according to your self-introduction, what are you angry about?
In addition, the New Three Kingdoms did not confess that Liu Bei and Gongsun Chan were classmates, and when Liu Bei participated in the alliance of princes, unlike the original Romance Gongsun Chan took Liu Bei, Liu Bei went by himself, and he relied on Cao Cao's help to enter the door. After entering the door, Gongsun Chan obviously didn't seem to know Liu Bei, and didn't help him introduce him, when a bunch of people didn't believe that Liu Bei was a relative of the Han family, Gongsun Chan didn't speak, so obviously the two sides didn't know each other.
As a result, when the princes' army broke up unhappily, Liu Bei faced Cao Cao, who had helped him many times and took the initiative to recruit him, chose to refuse, saying that he had promised to go to Gongsun Zhan, this plot was very confusing, Liu Bei of the New Three Kingdoms had no intersection with Gongsun Chan before, why did you want to take refuge in him? And when Liu Bei learned that Gongsun Chan died, he also said that he had a good relationship with Gongsun Zhan, when did you two climb the friendship?
Lu Bu is a family slave in the end
In the early plot, in order to whitewash Lu Bu, there was no scene of killing Ding Yuan, and he came back directly from Xiliang with troops, but during the battle of Tiger Prison Pass, Zhang Fei scolded him for being a slave with three surnames, and Lu Bu also asked curiously, "I am dignified Lu Bu, why did I become a slave with three surnames."
I don't know if it was to get together the three surnames, and let him worship Wang Yun as his father-in-law (or when he didn't kill Dong Zhuo), when Lu Bu defected to Liu Bei, Zhang Fei said that Lu Bu had four fathers, all of whom died because of Lu Bu, that Ding Yuan and Dong Zhuo were indeed killed by Lu Bu, what did the death of Lu Bu's father and Wang Yun have to do with Lu Bu? Especially Wang Yun, Lu Bu was benevolent enough to him, because he didn't win Li Dao and Guo Yan caused Wang Yun to be killed, so he has to blame?
Who ambushed Dong Zhuo?
On the way to burn Luoyang and move the capital to Chang'an, Dong Zhuo suddenly encountered an ambush of soldiers and horses, who sent this army of soldiers and horses? First of all, it was definitely not Cao Cao, because Cao Cao pursued Dong Zhuo's cavalry in the play, and it was impossible to prepare so many rolling wood and stones; secondly, Cao Cao repeatedly said that he was fighting alone, and Yuan Shao and other princes did not want to go in, so this ambush that appeared out of thin air was pretended to be a Zenith?
When was the last time Cao Cao and Lu Bu met?
In the plot of Baimenlou, Cao Cao made an appointment to meet Lu Bu, and the two reminisced, saying that the last time they met was in Dong Zhuo's mansion, no, you two have been fighting in Yanzhou for a year, and they haven't met? When Lu Bu defected to Liu Bei, he bragged to everyone, saying that he had met Cao Cao in the Battle of Puyang, but it was too dark for him to run away, which is not considered a meeting?
Zhang Fei Yongwu is not under Lu Bu?
Before the Battle of Bailoumen, Lu Bu boasted that he had a red rabbit horse and Fang Tian's painted halberd, and he was invincible in the world, but Chen Gong said that "Guan Yu, Zhang Fei, and Zhao Yun are not under you in all their bravery."
What's the matter, Guan Yu and Zhang Fei are forgotten, Zhang Fei in this play was defeated by Lu Bu twice, in the battle of Tiger Prison Pass, Lu Bu flew Zhang Fei's weapon and picked it off the horse, if it wasn't for Guan Yu to help in the battle, Zhang Fei would have died under Lu Bu's Fang Tian painting halberd.
In the second battle of Xiaopei, Zhang Fei was picked off by Lu Bu again, but this time it was Xiaobing's oral statement and did not perform.
Zhang Fei is also far inferior in archery, Zhang Fei can only shoot eighty steps, but Lu Bu can shoot a hundred steps away.
Xun Yu with a split personality
Xun Yu of the New Three Kingdoms secretly discussed with Cao Cao to hold the Son of Heaven hostage in private, and used the Son of Heaven to use it, and he couldn't see what kind of loyal minister he was.
Then when Xu Tian was hunting, Cao Cao shot the deer, Xun Yu smiled and shouted "Okay", but everyone cheered and had a face on his hips.
Afterwards, Cao Cao also complained to Cheng Yu that "Xun Yu sighed for a long time", and in the later plot of Baimamen, Xun Yu turned into a loyal minister of the Han Dynasty, and he became a split personality.
Where did Cao Cao's captured baggage go in the Battle of Guandu?
Regardless of the official history or romance, the first confrontation between Yuan and Cao's armies in Guandu was Cao Cao's defeat:
In August, the Shaolian camp was a little ahead, and it was dozens of miles from east to west. The public is also divided into battalions and equal, and the battle is unfavorable.
When the judge saw Cao Jun coming to charge the battle, he ordered the cannon to be fired: two 10,000 crossbows were fired simultaneously, and the archers in the Chinese army rushed out of the formation to shoot indiscriminately. How did Cao's army resist the enemy, looking south and hurrying away. Yuan Shao drove his troops to cover up, and Cao's army was defeated and retreated to Guandu.
The new three was changed to the first battle of Guandu, Cao Cao broke Yuan Shao head-on, and beat Yuan Shao's 700,000 army to only 400,000, and lost 300,000 troops.
On the other hand, Cao Ren reported to Cao Cao that he had seized ordnance and carried countless baggage, and then Cao Cao wrote to the rear that the grain and grass were exhausted. Is this Cao Cao himself embezzling all the seized grain into rice bowls?
Who contributed the serial plan?
In the New Three Kingdoms, it was Yu Ban and Mao Ji who gave Cao Cao advice in the Battle of Chibi to connect the chain warships together, and Pang Tong did not appear in the Battle of Chibi at all.
Later, Pang Tong appeared, and he actually said: "If it weren't for the serial plan I offered, would Zhou Yu have won?"
Huarong Dao Fang Cao was afraid of the northern revenge army and Cao Cao's battle of Chibi, how many states were left?
Huarong Daoyi interprets Cao Cao, the tension of this scene lies in the fact that Cao Cao experienced life and death in an instant, Guan Yu made a military order but released him out of kindness, Zhang Liao and others also brushed their faces, both sides are real contests and balances between life and death. In this plot, Luo Guanzhong's evaluation is "Fight to the death to reward your confidant, so that Qianqiu will look up to his name". The reason why this scene has been recited through the ages also lies in the dramatic tension of the plot. And after the New Three Kingdoms joined the theory of seeing through, Cao Cao saw through Zhuge Liang's deliberate release of water, so he was not nervous at all, but Zhuge Liang was worried that he didn't understand what he said, so don't let Guan Yuzhen cut Cao Cao with a knife.
Another inexplicable part of this plot is that the Sun and Liu families are worried about who killed Cao Cao, and the rest of Cao Cao will crusade against who will take revenge, why is this place inexplicable? Because of the Battle of Chibi, if the Cao army was wiped out in Huarong Dao, there would be more than one Cao Cao who died, but the martial arts elite was served in a pot, and at this time Cao Cao's heir has not yet been established, there is Huang Kui inside and Ma Teng outside, if you can protect yourself, burn high incense, plus Zhu Da's screenwriter mathematics and history are not passable, after the Battle of Chibi, Cao Cao instantly became Yuan Shao, and there are only four states left, just such a tragic situation, where is the power to take revenge, even if revenge, if there is no general, what combat effectiveness can it have?
Guan Yu was not convinced by Huang Zhong in the end
After Liu Bei proclaimed himself the king of Hanzhong, he sealed Guan Zhang Ma Huang as the four generals before and after the left and right in history, and in the romance, he sealed Zhang Zhang Zhao Ma Huang as the five tiger generals.
The ancestor was the king of Hanzhong, and he sent poems to worship Guan Yu as a former general. Yu Wen Huang Zhong was the rear general, and Yu said angrily: "The eldest husband will not be in the same column as the veteran!"
Yun Chang asked: "What title does the king of Hanzhong give me?" The poem said: "The head of the five tiger generals." Yun Chang asked: "What about the five tiger generals?" The poem said: "Guan, Zhang, Zhao, Ma, and Huang are also." Yun Chang said angrily: "Yide is my brother, Meng Qi is a famous family for generations, Zilong has been with my brother for a long time, that is, my brother is also: the position is with me, but also." What kind of person does Huang Zhong dare to be in the same column as me?
The plot in the New Three Kingdoms was changed to Guan Yu's disobedience to Ma Chao and his own juxtaposition, and praised Huang Zhong as an old hero.
As a result, Huang Zhong was hit by an arrow in the Battle of Yiling, and Huang Zhong said before he died that he would go down and ask Guan Yu if he was convinced, isn't this version of Guan Yu quite convinced by you.
Are Cao Pi and Cao Jie brother and sister or sister and brother?
In the episode Cao Pi usurped the Han Dynasty, in the face of the coercion of hundreds of officials, Emperor Han Xian beat Cao Jie out of anger, Cao Jie not only did not blame Emperor Han Xian, but comforted him that "it is not good to be a brother".
After seeing Cao Pi in a blink of an eye, he called him younger brother instead, what, who is the two of you?
Cao Shuang's character design
Cao Shuang was beaten by a felling Shu, Gao Pingling had a big advantage, and he was guilty of instigating surrender, and was directly scolded by Huan Fan as stupid as a pig and dog, and the role of having no bright spots in history and romance has become both wise and brave in the New Three Kingdoms, wise enough to see through Zhuge Liang's strategy, martial enough to kill Wei Yan and rescue Cao Zhen, Sima Yi said that Cao Shuang's talent is far above his father Cao Zhen, and he is also far better than his son Sima Zhao. As a result, Gao Pinglingzhi couldn't go on, and he became that stupid image again, so it can only be said that this version of Cao Shuang may have hit his head when he was in power.