#精品长文创作季#
Sentence | An-ching-hsien
Edit | 9527 Meow Goo-kun
The existence of classic IP has fed most of the entertainment industry, to say the least.
Almost every year, there is news of various adaptations and remakes.
Last year's "Happy Affair in a Sedan Chair" was a remake of the classic costume drama "The Wrong Sedan Chair to Marry the Right Lang", and the Douban score was only 4 points.
At the beginning of this year, "Sword and Fairy IV" and "Sword and Fairy VI", which continued the IP of "Sword and Fairy", were launched, but the combined scores of the two dramas barely caught up with a "Legend of Sword and Fairy III".
It's not that the audience is biased against classic remakes or IP sequels.
It is the creators of domestic dramas who erase the audience's trust in IP works with their strength.
When I learned that the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions" was coming, a bad premonition gradually sprouted.
As soon as I saw the casting and styling of the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions", my eyes went black.
Some netizens complained:
"When I saw Jia Baoyu's face, the face of the old man in the subway throughout the whole process"
Some netizens commented:
"Is it to make Cao Xueqin angry with Cao Xueqin when the movie version of Dream of Red Mansions makes Qin Keqing like this?"
The fact is that just by looking at the trailer of the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions", you can taste the taste of "aesthetic collapse".
Jia Baoyu's casting is crooked melons and cracked dates, and his temperament is not enough
Ouyang Fenqiang's version of Jia Baoyu must be the most recognized classic version in the hearts of the audience.
Jia Baoyu is described in the original book
And Ouyang Fenqiang is not a stunning handsome look.
But the baby fat is obvious, and the eyes are as clear as water.
not only performed Jia Baoyu's innocence, but also performed a kind of pampered and squeamish since childhood.
After that, Ma Tianyu and Yang Yang, although they did not reach the recognition of Ouyang Fenqiang.
But the acting skills, appearance, and temperament of the two are very outstanding.
can take a look at the casting of Jia Baoyu in the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions", there is no extravagance, full of village feeling, long face, strong sense of flesh, and at the same time, the facial features look mediocre.
In the filter of the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions", you can even see the problem of black around his lips.
It's not so much Jia Baoyu as a village boy.
Looking at this version of Jia Baoyu, it's really no wonder that netizens see the face of the subway uncle.
Daiyu's face is full and she looks like a maid
The description of Lin Daiyu in the original book is "two bends that seem to be frowning and not frowning, and a pair of eyes that seem to be happy but not happy."
The state is full of sorrows, and the disease of the whole body. Tears are dotted, and the pant is slight. ”。
Daiyu's image is actually delicate and charming.
Arrogant and cold, it is difficult to hide the sentimentality, delicate and sensitive temperament.
In the classic version, Lin Daiyu portrayed by Chen Xiaoxu has this feeling, she has a standard goose egg face, with a soft outline but a thin face, and her overall temperament is very ancient.
But in the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions", Zhang Miaoyi, who plays Lin Daiyu, has a maid face, with a strong sense of flesh on her face, and the obvious baby fat shows that her face is round and rich.
Every shot she appears in is more like a lively girl, without the pain of life experience and the worries of the situation.
The mediocre appearance of the maid is full of feeling, and she is also a maid who sneaks away to the kitchen to cook at any time.
Qin Keqing exploded and changed the side girl, and she didn't see it
The description of the character of Qin Keqing in the original book is "born delicate, gentle and peaceful", and the character's characteristics are sleek, shrewd, and peaceful.
But being romantic is not the same as coquettishness, and the 87 version of "A Dream of Red Mansions" plays Qin Keqing's picturesque eyebrows and autumn water, which can be called the first beauty in "A Dream of Red Mansions".
But Qin Keqing in the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions" can be described as a woman who has changed her edges, with no clothes, scratching her head and posing, and looking down at the actress in the camera.
From head to toe, it has a foxy temperament, and a face full of science and technology has no costume charm.
Those who know can see that this is Qin Keqing in "Dream of Red Mansions".
I don't know which Oiran in the Qinglou I thought it was, and the moment I appeared, there was a taste of cheap Internet University.
Many netizens complained about this:
"Qin Keqing's appearance, I thought it wasn't the Dream of Red Mansions, it was the Dream of Green Mansions"
More netizens were indignant:
"Don't take such an insult to Keqing...... Such garbage should be nailed to the pillar of shame in film and television history."
Looking at it this way, in the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions", the only actor who can handle it is probably Guan Xiaotong, but in fact, Guan Xiaotong's image is also very different from the image of Jia Yuanchun in "Dream of Red Mansions".
Jia Yuanchun is like a malnourished child
Jia Yuanchun in the original work of "Dream of Red Mansions" is the daughter of Jia Zheng of Rongguo Mansion, she is virtuous, filial, and although she is not very old, she is calm and talented.
In the previous versions of "Dream of Red Mansions", the actress who played Jia Yuanchun was rich.
At first glance, it is full of luxury, accustomed to glory and wealth, and has taste and style.
can participate in the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions", Guan Xiaotong's childishness is difficult to hide.
There is a feeling of timidity in front of the camera, and his face is so thin that he looks like a malnourished minor.
Even if you are wearing a luxurious dress, you have a sense of crampedness that you can't hold up.
In terms of casting, Guan Xiaotong can be said to be the only highlight of the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions".
But Guan Xiaotong and Jia Yuanchun's temperament and personality are incompatible, and they don't have the slightest bit of Jia Yuanchun's spirit.
In terms of casting, the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is already a fragment.
At present, the filmmaker has also changed the direction of the film's promotion to the track for plot content.
Jiafu seems to be prosperous, but in fact, it is outside of gold and jade, and it is ruined.
Jia Tun Lincai's plot, which was deliberately diluted and ambiguous in the original book and previous versions, was all brought to the surface by the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions".
But objectively speaking, the plot that anyone with a discerning eye can taste does not appear in the original book and various classic versions.
It is precisely because of the Spring and Autumn brushwork that on the surface it is the long-term affection of children, but in fact it is the rise and fall of the times, the sophistication of human feelings, politics and economy, and the social form of undercurrents.
Now that the film version has pierced everything, the beauty of "Dream of Red Mansions" has disappeared, and Lin Daiyu's tragedy has instantly become the three words "brokenness" summarized in the traffic era.
In short, from the plot style to the casting of actors, the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions" is obvious.
It is almost impossible for this film to be recognized by the audience.
One is because the movie itself has been backlogged for a long time, and the texture is completely incomparable, and the other is that the pearl and jade are in front, and the 87 version of "Dream of Red Mansions" can no longer be surpassed.
Finally, what do you think of the current signal released by the film version of "Dream of Red Mansions"?
Are you optimistic about the launch of this movie?
Participate in the discussion in the comment section and talk about your views on the latest trailer of the film version, the status of the actors and the direction of the plot.