Liuyi brother hot comment2023-03-05 20:39
Detail one
From "suspected sexual assault", "suspected assault" to "suspected obscenity"
The Li Qiuping incident was first disclosed by the well-known media "Economic Observation Network" and "Cover News", using the words "suspected sexual assault" and "suspected assault", and the joint investigation team of the Jiangxi Ganzhou Municipal Party Committee used "suspected obscenity", these three different words have their own definitions at the legal level, and professional matters are left to professionals to discuss, but one thing is certain, "sexual assault", especially "assault" includes a broader connotation, and "obscene" is more specific.
Then, people naturally have to ask, why did the determination of "suspected indecency" before the investigation reached a conclusion, is it local protectionism, protection of calves, or is the local government planning to make big things small and trivial? It is really not, "suspected of indecency" can advance or retreat, defend and attack. If you sit down like the hugging and forcible kiss spread on the Internet, the characterization of the incident as obscene is still objective; If the results of the investigation are more serious than the Internet, it is simple, remove the word "suspected" and recharacterize. The Ganzhou Joint Investigation Group still has people who understand.
Standing on the side of the "Economic Observation Network" and looking at it again, it is different. As a national media, in the face of such a bad incident, I have interviewed victims with legal literacy. I believe that the description of the victim is objective and factual, and if there are untrue words, it will inevitably lead to a very passive future work, and we cannot ignore this consequence. Second, if you have already received one mental injury, you cannot be hurt again because of false claims. From these aspects, the use of "suspected sexual assault" and "suspected assault" by the Economic Observation Network is rigorous, grounded, and will not be rash. As mentioned above, from a legal point of view, the connotation and extension of "sexual assault" or "assault" exceed "indecency".
It can be seen that there is a disagreement between the media and the local government.
Detail two
Twenty days between the time of the incident and the time of disclosure
There are two versions of Li Qiuping's suspected molestation of female cadres on duty to train female cadres, February 2 and February 8.
According to local media reports in Anyuan County:
On the morning of February 8, 2023, the third meeting of the 16th Anyuan County Committee of the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference was held, and Li Qiuping attended the meeting and took a seat in the front row of the rostrum.
However, on the morning of February 9, when the third session of the 18th Anyuan County People's Congress was held, Li Qiuping did not attend the meeting. The government work report, which should have been made by the county head, became "entrusted by Li Qiuping, deputy secretary of the county party committee and county magistrate, Yang Beilin, member of the standing committee of the county party committee and deputy county magistrate, reported to the conference on behalf of the Anyuan County People's Government."
Based on this, some people infer that the incident occurred on February 8. A little scrutiny is not true, Li Qiuping will not be like the hairy young man who has just entered the career path, and he will push off the important activities of the day because of the drunken gaffe the night before, but something important must have happened this afternoon.
What's important?
Police summons can first be ruled out. Even if Li Qiuping is arrested as rumored to be, the police will verify the experience in an appropriate way without affecting the work of the county elders and give enough face.
Second, official business trips can be excluded. At the county-level people's congress, the head of a county is to make a government work report on behalf of the county government, and official activities will be coordinated in advance to avoid time conflicts with major political activities.
Excluding official business trips and police summonses, the only thing that can be said is that the relevant departments of the Ganzhou Municipal Party Committee gave Li Qiuping a formal notice of suspension or greetings first.
Then, in the more than 20 days from the beginning of February to February 24, although there is not much public information, the victim, the suspect, and the central state organs of Ganzhou City, including the central state organs where the victim is located, reacted to the molestation incident, although there is not much public information, a reasonable analysis can be made.
First, the victim reported Li Qiuping's molestation to the relevant authorities in Ganzhou, reported to his unit, and after obtaining consent, left Anyuan County and returned to the capital.
Second, after the suspect sobered up, he knew that he had broken into a big disaster, and immediately went around public relations in an attempt to turn big things into small things.
For example, the Whampoa Military Academy in those years was a special department for training senior cadres at the provincial and municipal levels. After learning the details, the top management of the organ personally came forward and communicated with the Jiangxi senior management through normal channels, strongly demanding that the suspect be severely punished.
Fourth, in the face of the political impact caused by Li Qiuping's strong kiss, Jiangxi is undoubtedly a test of political wisdom, and it feels pressure. Although Li Qiuping's indecent assault on female cadres on duty and training was a personal act, this move undoubtedly smeared Anyuan, Ganzhou, and the whole of Jiangxi, disgraced the people of the whole country, and had an extremely bad political impact. Improper handling will affect the relationship between local and national organs, and the negative image will be difficult to reverse. As a result, a suspension notice was issued on the 24th.
The public can't help but ask whether Li Qiuping, who was suspended from office because of the fact that no one in Ganzhou had moved on the Internet, or that there were other reasons, such as interceding for him and clearing his name.
Detail three
The victim was interviewed by the media
The Economic Observer first reported the news of Li Qiuping's suspension, and after that, a number of well-known media followed. "Cover News" has a detail worth playing with in the not-so-long news. The introduction of the news said that "February 2023, multiple sources confirmed", there is a year, month, no date, is it an oversight, or does it imply that the incident has occurred for many days by February 24, which coincides with the rumored incident on February 2, and there are "multiple sources", the matter involves the deputy secretary of the county party committee and the county magistrate of Anyuan County, and the media is very cautious.
According to the "Cover News", the victim was interviewed by the media and told the reporter, "He has left Anyuan County, and the matter is now handled by the organization." ”
Obviously, the statement here seems to contradict the rumors. Rumor has it that on the night of the incident, the victim called the police and 110 went out of the scene. Under the jurisdiction of Li Qiuping, the Anyuan County police can imagine local protectionism, and the victims have concerns about whether the police can be fair and impartial, or whether they really encountered unfair treatment in the process of recording that night, so they said that they were "handed over to the organization".
From another perspective, it seems to understand that as a well-educated legal professional, calling the police is the proper meaning of the question; As cadres on temporary duty, believing that the organization depends on the organization is also a basic political quality. Therefore, whether it is called to the police or handed over to the organization, it is reasonable.
Detail four
"Filing a case" and "breaking the law"
Carefully reading the report of the Ganzhou Joint Investigation Group, the public found that the wording of the circular was different from the common expression of the discipline supervision commission, and we compared the report of the Ganzhou side with the report of Duan Ying and Wang Shengzhan.
The comparison found that the discipline supervision commission generally has a fixed expression, "suspected of serious violations of discipline and law subject to disciplinary review and supervision and investigation", Duan Ying used "case filing for review and investigation" on this basis, Wang Shengzhan used the standard format "disciplinary review and supervision and investigation", and Li Qiuping and Duan Ying were exactly the same, that is, "case filing for review and investigation".
The biggest difference between Li Qiuping and the above two is that the first two discipline supervision commissions are responsible, while Li Qiuping has the participation of public security organs in addition to the discipline supervision commission. One of them. Second, the expression of the Ganzhou side is not a pretense and perfunctory to the public, let alone the so-called hugging and forcible kissing of the professor who defended Li Qiuping, which is commonplace and commonplace, but "suspected of obscene illegal acts", with clear terms. The extent of the violation needs to be investigated.
Final words
To sum up, around the incident of Li Qiuping's suspected molestation of cadres who were on duty for training, the media and localities, nongovernmental and official, those who advocate severe punishment and those who whitewash them, and so on, all have different voices, which can also be understood as a multi-party game. What will be the end, to paraphrase the words of the People's Daily, no one can cover up, no one dares to cover up, we will wait and see!