"Langya Relief Grocery Store" scored 5.0 points
1. Kazema Falcon: 6 points
Film critic.
The old tradition of Shochiku civic dramas is very stuffy, there is no golden age at all, only the poster of "Humpback City Noisy Taiko" in the first shot made me "wow". Compared with the Chinese version, it is very realistic, and the plot of the old man eloping with the orphanage sister is more reasonable and touching. After looking at the rich significance of grocery stores in the lives of people," I found that the Chinese version should actually be called "Relief Supply and Marketing Cooperative".
2. Lu Zhiyu: 6 points
The operator of the WeChat public account "Watching Movies and Seeing Death", co-founder of "Whale Screening Room", author of the film essay collection "Joker, Circus Tears".
1. See Lin Yundu again, inexplicably good! 2. Perhaps, only Keigo Higashino's work is too difficult to adapt; now, it is a little understanding of the incompetence of Han Jie's version. 2. Of course, the taste of Japan is more in line with Keigo Higashino, and it can be seen that Ryuichi Hiroki has made every effort to get close to the original work, even if the narrative is weak, the street scene is still beautiful and comfortable to watch.
3. Peach Forest: 5 points
Film and television self-media person, Operator of WeChat public account and Weibo "Tao Tao Movie", initiator of offline activity "Tao Tao Movie Group".
Better than the mainland version, but not particularly good. More and more, I feel that this is a story that is difficult to visualize, and it is still very boring to just take a few fragments.
4. Lucifer: 4 points
Doctor of Arts.
"Healing" is the total acceptance of the life of a lost dog who has nothing and has nothing to rely on. Compared with the Chinese version that hopes for future adaptations, the Japanese version is more considerate of the pain of the losers. However, the situation design of several life dogs is too thin, and they only have occasional connections with each other, and it is difficult to find further situations.
5. Big Odd: 4 points
Veteran film researcher and freelance writer.
The film is overwhelmed by the flirtatious dialogue and sensational scenes that are as tall as the Empire State Building, so aspirants please continue to adapt it.