preface
In spell returns, "body" and "soul" are important settings in the worldview
It is often interspersed with various character dialogues
But Wasabi was very troublesome and did not explain clearly
So I sorted out a little bit of the information about the body and soul in the manga
Discussions are also welcome at the bottom
Known settings
Set zero: Man = Body + Soul
The main evidence is the 98-episode séance and the 22-episode dialogue between a real person and Nanamin
Setting 1: The magic form exists in the flesh
The most widely known setting is also the basis of the later argument, but there are still some explanations that do not make sense
The main evidence is 11 episodes of Tiger Zi and Five Articles of Dialogue, Brain Flower.
There are two main problems, see questions A and B below
Setting Two: Bondage acts on the soul
It is not difficult to deduce the setting. According to the tiger and the great master in the realm of birth, and the tiger's body was in a state of death at that time, it must be the soul itself that is bound.
There is also evidence that the bondage between the rope and the ancient spellcaster is still valid after the rope has transferred the body
Setting Three: Heaven and mantra act on the flesh
That's a bit tricky
Although this setting seems to be very normal, there is also a lot of evidence (Even ersei)
However, for the time being, it is impossible to explain the difference between Makoto and Mechanical Pill
See Question C for details
Set the hypothesis
Hypothesis 1: The soul precedes the body
The real person said
Hypothesis two: soul = body
The false oil put forward the conjecture, the real person said
（???? ）
There are too few clues to discuss for the time being
issue
Question A: The fingers of the celebrant
It is known that there is a part of the soul of the celebrant on the finger of the celebrant
After The Knotweed Yuren takes over the body, the Knotweed Yuren at this time should be the body of the Tiger + the soul of the Suzun
If the setting is true, sushi should not be able to perform the spell at this time
But you know that I know that the one-eyed dragon also knows that at this time, the sushi is not only a magic style, but also a field
This violates the assumption that the form exists in the flesh
The grudging explanation I can think of is
Tiger Has Become "Fleshly" Like Him anaki
And we don't know what kind of existence the flesh is
But what is certain is that the body can be used in the form of magic (three brothers)
Question B: Tian Yuan
Holder of the Immortal Technique
(This is a bit strange in itself, so far I have not seen this passive type of magic except for Tianyuan.)
I suspect that this is not his own technique, but a very costly bondage)
If the body withers away, what happens to the technique itself?
And the act of assimilation itself is less clear
Is it the new celestial element = (star slurry + old celestial element) / 2
So if the Star Pulp itself has a magic style, will Tianyuan inherit it?
Question C: Heaven and mantra
Bondage is also one of the most important settings in this manga
Sacrifice something in exchange for an unusual ability
Shinki and Mechanical Pill are two examples
But there are some problems with the heavens and the curse
Shinki lost what little spell power he had left and gained the same physical abilities as Shir
The mechanical pill healed the body, theoretically losing the huge spell power it possessed
And the night before the festival looked down, he did not lose its spell power
(One possibility is that he has formed a new bondage with himself, exchanging his life for the same spell output as before))
postscript
None of the above is about the soul and body
The purpose of this article is to help those who are poisoned by the complicated settings of the mustard to sort out a little bit
And the above is only the part that comes to mind at the moment of writing
I'll make up for it later if I have a new idea
If there is any error, please correct it