A novel is a novel and cannot become a real historical story, and providence is so, and Song Jiang and Fang La cannot overthrow the Northern Song Dynasty together.
Song Jiang himself was short in stature, his skin was hey, his chest had no ink, Wen could not mention the pen to settle the world, and Wu could not immediately settle Qiankun, but he sat on the first chair in Liangshan with his superior ability to control people. Since the Song River went to Liangshan, it slowly emptied Chao Gai, and every time he went out on a expedition, he rushed to go first, leading a group of brothers to make meritorious achievements outside, ostensibly to relieve external troubles for his brother, but in fact, it was to win people's hearts, and over time, the real boss of Liangshan became Song Jiang, and finally the door plaque of Liangshan was changed from "Juyi Hall" to "Zhongyi Hall", marked with the label of "For The Way of Heaven".
Strength did not allow Liangshan to compete with the Northern Song Dynasty
In the final analysis, the good men of Liangshan are still a group of good men in the green forest who gather in the mountains and forests, and according to one side, the king is still hegemonic, but if he wants to compete with the whole country, he does not have enough strength. Liangshan's main economic source is still to rob the family and rob the surrounding corrupt officials and local tycoons, but this is not a long-term solution, liangshan good people only know how to drink from large bowls, eat and drink, but do not know how to develop the economy and strengthen strength, such a group can not defeat the entire Northern Song Dynasty. A careful reading of the "Water Margin" can be found that every time Song Jiang and Wu Yong encountered a good man with strong martial arts, they knew that they were not opponents, so they disregarded the morality of the rivers and lakes, and used various tricks to deceive and deceive each other, and tricked each other into joining Liangshan. Therefore, liangshan's way of developing strength is not stable. Although Liangshan is playing the banner of "For the Heavenly Path", in the eyes of the people, they are still a group of rogue grass. Therefore, no matter when the time and place are favorable, Liangshan does not have enough strength to confront the Northern Song Dynasty.
Not everyone is willing to bear the name of rebellion
When Song Jiang first went to Liangshan, Chao Gai put wine to wash the dust for his brothers, and Li Kui said: "Simply kill tokyo, take the bird throne, the brother became the emperor, anyway, the brother is also surnamed Song." At this time, the whole Liangshan was silent, and Chao Gai, Wu Yong, Gongsun Sheng, and others were speechless. Because from the perspective of the brothers in Liangshan, all they wanted was to "drink in a big bowl and eat meat in a big mouth" every day, to live a happy and happy life, and they did not think about the left rebellion, nor did they want to bear the name of a lifetime. Because most people on Liangshan are also forced to go to Liangshan, the ancient heroes and good men pay attention to "loyalty, righteousness, and faithfulness", no one wants to bear the stigma of grass and rebellion, and the brothers of Liangshan are only gathered in Liangshan because of a "righteousness" word, so everyone is very happy about this life. Therefore, if Song Jiang wanted to rebel and overthrow the Northern Song Dynasty, not all the good men of Liangshan were willing to follow, and Lu Junyi, Gongsun Sheng, Wu Yong and other people who knew everything would not agree.
Lack of strategic coherence
Although the good men of Liangshan are all strong in martial arts, with a hundred heroes, on the other hand, it is actually a group of reckless men gathered together, just fighting, the only "Zhi Duo Xing Wu Yong" is just a failed candidate who has read more than a few years, which will only make the point pit treacherous means of abduction. If Liangshan rebelled and wanted to overthrow the Northern Song Dynasty, what was missing with the Liangshan military camp was not soldiers, but strategists, a "Zhuge Liang" who could help Liangshan come up with plans and make overall strategic plans.
Joining forces with Fang La is not necessarily sincere
Song Jiang and Fang La joined forces to overthrow the Northern Song Dynasty, so who was in charge? Who is next? For the Liangshan brothers, especially Li Kui's temperament, he definitely wanted his brother Song Jiang to be the boss, but the Fang La group was also full of talents, and Fang La had also established himself as emperor, so he was willing to easily submit to Liangshan as a supplement, so even if Song Jiang and Fang La joined forces to rebel, they would never be sincerely united internally.
Therefore, Providence predestined the end of Liangshan, and even if it rebelled, it would not succeed.