In the plot of the first twelve episodes of "Who is the Murderer", judging from the age and some details, the murderer has initially had three candidates: He Weiguang, Shen Haiyang and Hu Shanquan.
Through Xia Jinlan's case, He Weiguang can almost be ruled out, he was already admitted to the hospital before Xia Jinlan was killed, he did not have the time to commit the crime, but in the last case and the first four cases, He Weiguang still has the possibility of committing a crime, and this character is still in the midst of innocence and sin.
The plot will be reversed: Shen Haiyang is Shen Yu's adoptive father, and Hu Shanquan is not the murderer
Through the cast list, it is not difficult to find that the whole drama appears in the juvenile Hu Shanquan, juvenile Shen Haiyang, adult Shen Haiyang, but there is no adult Hu Shanquan, if it is deliberately in the adult Hu Shanquan did not appear in the cast list, then why did the juvenile Hu Shanquan appear?
Such small details will clearly have an explanation: releasing the teenager Hu Shanquan is deliberately leading the audience to guess that Hu Shanquan is the murderer, but there is no adult Hu Shanquan actor, the fact shows that this person has long died, he did not even leave a photo, then Hu Shanquan is so important that the character is left with only one way to appear.
Through DNA matching, it is proved that the "pile of white bones" that is father and daughter with Shen Yu may be Hu Shanquan! Only in this way of appearance, there is no need for actors, and there is no need to appear in the cast list.
Then it can be boldly speculated that Hu Shanquan is Shen Yu's biological father, and whether Shen Haiyang is the adopted Shen Yu or whether he likes to be a father is also possible.
If Shen Yu was adopted, Hu Shanquan witnessed Shen Yu's mother dying of dystocia and hemorrhage, thus having a psychological shadow, and later met Shen Haiyang when he was seeing a doctor, Shen Haiyang adopted Shen Yu out of kindness and tried to treat Hu Shanquan, which can also explain the murderer's modus operandi, in order to give birth to Shen Yu, Shen Yu's mother and father decided to protect the child first, anesthetics and muscle relaxants, tables, bleeding and final smile expression, this is the last scene of Shen Yu's mother when she gave birth, and the last smile has the effect of drugs. There is also the joy of facing the newborn, Hu Shanquan's repeated crimes are to find the thoughts of Shen Yu's mother, as if this scene can evoke Hu Shanquan's memory of Shen Yu's mother.
If the whole story is Shen Haiyang's happy father, all these behaviors are caused by Shen Haiyang's mental disorder, and sometimes sober and sometimes crazy, which is why he disappeared since the Xia Jinlan case, all the serial cases are to carry out some kind of psychological level of rituals, Shen Haiyang just wants to ask Shen Yu's mother why this child is not his own, when Shen Haiyang accidentally killed Li Lan, he also understood that he was more and more out of control, only by avoiding Shen Yu, he could not hurt this daughter.
If Hu Shanquan is the murderer of the serial case, and the "pile of white bones" is Shen Yu's biological father Hu Shanquan, then in the last case, Hu Shanquan is not the murderer.
The murderer chooses one of the two: Shen Haiyang is insane, and Hu Shanquan misses Shen Yu's mother
The key to this is still shen yu's mother, if Hu Shanquan is the murderer, these serial cases are a kind of thought, shen Haiyang is a murderer, these serial cases are the manifestation of his mental disorder.
No matter who these two people are, it seems that they can't explain why Leng Xiaobing didn't shoot when he faced the murderer, was Leng Xiaobing just frightened, if it was really instigated, he had been pursuing the Haizhou case for so many years because he wanted to face the murderer again.
From the Xia Jinlan case to the dancing girl case, which is more than ten years apart, the real murderer is separated from how many years to commit the crime, He Weiguang occupies a lot of important scenes compared to the other two people, Hu Shanquan and Shen Haiyang are almost only heard of their names and do not see their people, the two people are more mysterious than one, whether it is missing or insane, this is a psychological problem.
They were able to hide this psychology for more than ten years, and finally told Shen Yu to commit a crime, which was clearly not something that a problematic person could do, and they were very afraid that the final murderer would be identified in He Weiguang's body, because He Weiguang was too normal, at first he thought he had taken a funny script, but it was very painful to see him being tortured, and later thought that he was taking a tragedy, being brainwashed by Shen Yu, and being framed or eventually becoming a vegetative person.
If He Weiguang is a murderer, then we have to admire the logic of this drama, He Weiguang is also almost a kind of person who is put to death and born later, sooner or later will be caught, committing so many crimes, caught is death, after becoming a vegetative person, he can wake up and have hope of life.
Who do you think is shen haiyang, Hu Shanquan, and He Weiguang? Which of the three of them had more reasons to torture and take advantage of Shen Yu?