Mizuki Nianhua is a very famous music group in China, the first five members of their group are all high-achieving students from Tsinghua University, and they have also left a lot of popular works.
In April 2001, Lu Gengzhi and Li Jian founded Mizuki Nianhua, and this year, it is the 20th anniversary. For most of these 20 years, they have existed in the form of Lu Gengshu + Miao Jie, and this year, they have added a young member, Chen Qiuhua from the Tsinghua Academy of Fine Arts.
Recently, Mizuki Nianhua participated in a program called "Singing While Walking", which belongs to the documentary program of music tourism. In the 5th issue that was recently broadcast, the protagonist is Mizuki Nianhua. The two of them traveled to the ancient city of Anyang in Henan and spent a wonderful time in this old romantic tour.
Somehow, every time Mizuki Nianhua or Lu Gengshu has attracted attention on the Internet over the years, it is often inseparable from a topic, that is, the breakup of Lu Gengshu and Li Jian in the first place. Therefore, in this episode, Lu Gengzhi once again mentioned the old things, talking about Li Jian's departure at the beginning, and his words still revealed his complaints and blame for Li Jian.
In the show, the three of them sat together to eat and chat, and Lu Gengzhi took the initiative to mention that the group was just in the stage of improvement and rising, but Li Jian wanted to leave, almost forcing him into a desperate situation. As for the reason for Li Jian's departure, Mr. Lu said he had privately contacted a Record Label in Taiwan, saying that the incident was "a very big injury to me."
Lu Gengji's meaning is obvious, the combination has just improved, you betray me and plot to jump ship, too unkind. He also said that he and Li Jian had been very good friends since they met in Tsinghua, and he had always treated each other like younger brothers and watched him grow. At the critical time, he ignored himself and said that he would leave, so sorry for himself.
Regarding Li Jian's contact with the Taiwan Record Company, it seems that this is the first time I have heard Lu Gengzhi talk about it. But after Li Jian left Mizuki, it seems that he did not sign any Taiwan record companies, but a person buried his head in music, and signed some small companies in the mainland with a relatively relaxed creative environment, such as the first and second albums are Tianjin TEDA Records. Therefore, whether Li Jian has contacted a Taiwan record company or not should not be evidence of his betrayal of Mizuki Nianhua.
Next, Lu Gengji also disclosed the details of Li Jian's departure. Saying that on a plane back to Beijing from Chengdu, he asked Li Jian, "Do you think it is better to do concerts", Li Jian was stunned for a moment, and after thinking about it, he gave a positive answer. Lu Gengzhi recalled, "At that time, after hearing this answer, my heart was very uncomfortable..."
After getting off the plane, Lu Gengzhi asked again, "Can you make your own music?" Li Jian nodded again, then waved his hand and left...
In fact, many people have heard this plot, but what Lu Gengzhi said this time seems to have some small differences from the version we have heard before - he omitted the most crucial sentence, that is, he said the 4 words "Then you go".
Of course, we can't be 100% sure that Lu Gengshu said "then you go" 4 words, but combined with this situation and results to analyze, I think he said the possibility is very large, without these 4 words, Li Jian would not have waved his hand like this and left. If he really said that Li Jian would not be able to leave, any other person might have left.
Over the years, when Li Jian was asked why he broke up with Lu Gengji, he said that there were differences in musical philosophy, one favoring strong rock and the other favoring quiet folk songs, and there would be conflicts in creation. In fact, this is indeed the deep reason for their breakup, but at the time it was only a hidden danger of their relationship breakdown, and it was Lu Gengzhi's words that personally pushed their cooperative relationship to the end.
If you think about it, for Li Jian, whose creation is bound, when faced with Lu Gengji's sharp question "Do you think it is better to do concerts", he does not answer in certainty. If he said no, wouldn't he be right in Lu Geng's heart - since you don't have confidence in your own music, then why are you still wronged here, just listen to me?
Li Jian's answer was only the most normal answer of a dignified and confident musician, and when Lu Gengzhi heard it, he actually felt that such an answer made him particularly uncomfortable! This is outrageous, and it also fully reflects his inner arrogance and dictatorship. Why didn't he think that his torture was more uncomfortable?
As the captain and my friend and brother for many years, I don't think Lu Gengzhi should ask such a question at all! If you perceive that Li Jian has an idea in his heart, for the sake of the harmony of the combination, you should communicate euphemistically and resolve each other's knots, rather than forcefully forcing the other party to admit that he can't do it, and then obediently obey him.
What was even more excessive was that he asked again and did not die, and solemnly tortured again. After Li Jian replied affirmatively again, he casually said, "Then you go," which I don't think is surprising at all. As long as he doesn't "force" Li Jian to go like this, everything still has room for easing communication, but the words spilled out, you have spoken like this, do you still let Li Jian admit on the spot, "Brother, I am wrong, I will definitely not be able to do it alone, please don't drive me away!" ”
Of course, I believe that Lu Gengzhi really did not want Li Jian to leave in his heart. As soon as Li Jian left, he insisted on music for six or seven years before he could make such a combination that might be doomed. It's like a couple, a man stumbles for years and finally finds a girlfriend and gets married. But after marriage, there are often contradictions between the two, macho he in order to make the other party submit to himself, asked "do you think you will have a better life without me", the other party did not expect him to ask so, but thought about answering yes; he was very hurt in his heart, she actually said that it was better to leave me! This can't stand it! Then he asked again, and the other party still replied in the affirmative. He said angrily, "Then go live your good life."
In such a situation, the other party does not leave, how long to stay? After the other party left, he was alone at home chagrin and sad, who can blame?
After Li Jian left, Lu Gengshu found Yao Yong and Miao Jie to reorganize. Not long after, Yao Yong left again, leaving only Miao Jie to accompany him until today. Why was it that only Miao Jie could accompany him all the time and not leave? In fact, this time in the show they also talked about.
This time it was Chen Qiuhua who spoke about it, and he said his thoughts from the position of a bystander who joined Mizuki: "Brother Miao has been in the group for more than ten years, just like a silent guardian..."
This sounds like praising Miao Jie, but in fact it hits the nail on the head, puncturing the special relationship between the two members of Mizuki Nianhua, that is, Miao Jie is too non-existent in the combination, Mizuki Nianhua has always been a combination of Lu Gengjie, and Miao Jie is only an auxiliary role.
It could be seen that Miao Jie and Lu Gengshu were a little embarrassed to hear their little brother issue such doubts. Miao Jie simply faced this problem and said, "I think the biggest support I can give is 'not leaving'."
Lo and behold, it could be heard from these words that Miao Jie should have had the idea of running away more than once, but each time he stayed. As one of the members of the duo, he actually said that his biggest support for the group is "not leaving", which sounds a bit ironic, and the words are directed at the "great dictator" Lu Gengjiao.
Lu Gengjiao smiled and responded, "This kind of brotherhood between me and Lao Miao is really ups and downs, although it is stumbling, but in the end it is still not abandoned..."
Looking at the music scene, we can hardly see this kind of duo with one strong and one weak, and such a disparity in the status of the group, because even if there is, it will soon break up. Perhaps Miao Jie has been accustomed to this kind of forbearance for many years, but Li Jian could not get used to it, so Li Jian's departure was inevitable.
Since the formation of Mizuki Nianhua 20 years ago, Lu Gengzhi is not looking for a partner who cooperates with equals, but a singing assistant. He looked for Miao Jie because he liked Miao Jie to sing an excellent high note. In addition, he also said that when he first looked for Li Jian, he was also because of the other party's singing talent.
Lu Gengzhi must not only firmly control the creative direction of the group, but also dominate in singing, and the partner can only set him off in sound. With a dictatorial role like him, and with a particularly tough communication, how many musicians like Miao Jie are willing to go along with it and accompany him through so many years? At least Li Jian couldn't do it.
Although Lu Gengji's talent cannot be denied, but to be honest, his pattern is a bit small, and he is not suitable for the establishment of a group. It's been 20 years, and he still keeps paying attention to the matter of breaking up with Li Jian, and he still has a grudge against Li Jian. This time in the show, it is not who to interview, but he took the initiative to say that the audience he faced was only Miao Jie and Chen Qiuhua, did the two teammates not hear enough about you and Li Jian? Obviously, it is the needs of the show, and experience tells him that Touching porcelain Li Jian can often attract more popularity.
I remember that at the beginning of last year, Lu Gengzhi quarreled with netizens on the Internet because of this matter, he said that "Li Jian's original departure from Mizuki was an irresponsible performance", and at the same time, Li Jian had bought a draft to blackmail him for many years.
At that time, the matter attracted a lot of attention on the Internet, and Li Jian did not respond positively from beginning to end.
In fact, over the years, he and Li Jian are not old and dead, and occasionally there has been cooperation on the scene, why bother, whether it is because of the relationship between alumni, former teammates or ordinary friends, whether it is because you were wrong or Li Jian was wrong, they are all middle-aged, they should have been relieved; he has repeatedly taken it out and stirred up, unilaterally provoking contradictions, which is undoubtedly a manifestation of narrow-mindedness. What do you think?