In the battle of Ye Mengguan, Zhang Fei drove the firepower to the maximum, and fought with Ma Chao for a day and a night, but he still could not take advantage of it.
In this battle, which of the two sides is better?
When Zhang Fei was desperate, Guan Yu was sitting in Jingzhou, busy patrolling the city defenses during the day, idle at night reading with candles, although he had always been in a state of combat readiness and never slackened off, but after all, the swords and guns were in storage, and he had not fought for more than ten years!
Before Zhang Fei fought Ma Chao, Zhuge Liang once said, "Ma Chao is invincible, unless he goes to Jingzhou to take Guan Yunchang"! If Guan Yu really rushed to Ye MengGuan and replaced Zhang Fei in fighting Ma Chao, what would be the outcome?
Speaking without blowing or black, Guan Yu at this time has a high probability of being unable to defeat Ma Chao!
<h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" data-track="57" > Zhang Fei vs Ma Chao, who is better in the end? </h1>
If you want to discuss the strength and weakness of Guan Yu and Ma Chao, you must first analyze the height of Zhang Fei and Ma Chao. The Battle of Ye Meng Guan can be divided into multiple details of the process, and we will look at it separately.
Let's look at Zhang Fei first. Zhuge Liang claimed that he wanted to transfer Guan Yu to come, which was a well-known method of agitation, and he put up a contrasting relationship: Zhang Fei was at Yangqiao, only because Cao Cao did not know the virtual reality, while Ma Chao killed Cao Cao to the point of almost killing himself in the six battles of Weiqiao. For example, when Zhang Gao violated Ye Mengguan, Zhuge Liang once provoked Huang Zhong in person, saying that unless Zhang Fei was transferred, he could only meet the enemy, and huang Zhong was angry to the point of turning his beard upside down, and he folded two iron bows in succession! Therefore, Zhuge Liang's sharp-tongued method of agitation can indeed poke Zhang Fei's nerves and greatly stimulate Zhang Fei's fighting spirit, so Zhang Fei angrily erected a military order!
If he made a military order, it was equivalent to no way back, try to see Zhang Gao, in front of Zhao Yun and Ma Chao are more fragile and afraid, but when he made a military order in front of Cao Hong, the immediate combat effectiveness was bursting, and he was able to fight with Zhang Fei for thirty or fifty years, if it were not for the disadvantage of the rear army, he could still open up and continue to fight!
Before the war began, Liu Bei gave Zhang Fei more strength, or used a tired enemy strategy for Ma Chao. When Ma Chao fought, Liu Bei did not let Zhang Fei go to war, and asked to "avoid his sharpness first", which made Zhang Fei anxious, hating not being able to swallow Ma Chao flatly, but Liu Bei refused, "three or five times were taken in"!
Zhang Fei's anger, like an inflated balloon that had been forcibly pressed, was about to explode; Zhang Fei's fighting spirit, like a powerful spring that had been forcibly squeezed, was about to bounce off; and Zhang Fei himself was like a tight clockwork, about to turn with full force!
What about Ma Chao? Ma Chao came from afar, shouting and scolding from early in the morning, his throat was smoking, he tossed and turned all morning, and he failed to fight, originally wanted to fight with "one drum", and the result was that he was "weakened again". Until the afternoon, when "everyone and horses on the Horse Super Formation were tired", Zhang Fei rushed down the pass like the wind!
Through the above comparative analysis, it can be seen that Zhang Fei, under the premise of Zhuge Liang's agitation and Liu Bei's tired enemy strategy, has fully condensed his fighting spirit, accumulated thick and thin hair, and in the case of waiting for work, he has adjusted the pre-war state to the best; while Ma Chao has instead hit the air with force, and the sharpness and momentum are three points weaker.
The first time he singled out, after fighting for more than a hundred, Liu Bei praised a sentence of "Ma Chaozhen Tiger Will Also", and then "feared that Zhang Fei would lose, and rushed to collect the army"; the second single challenge, Zhang Fei stopped the horse for a moment, directly took off his helmet, "only wrapped a scarf on the horse", Liu Bei's reaction was "afraid that Zhang Fei would lose, and he hung up on the next pass", and after the two sides once again singled out more than a hundred, Liu Bei once again 'Ming Jin collected the troops".
Zhang Fei took off his helmet, which is quite similar to Xu Chu's armor removal, which is a way to reduce the weight, which can reduce the rate of physical loss and improve physical flexibility, which shows that Zhang Fei is not easy to fight. In addition, Liu Bei's two mingjin also fully illustrates one point, that is, Zhang Fei's battle situation is not optimistic!
In the rendition, the single-handedness between the military generals, the side of the Mingjin, is usually considered to be slightly inferior, such as Ling Tongqiang topped Zhang Liao 50 he, Sun Quan quickly mingjin, and then for example, Guan Yu strongly topped Xu Huang 80 he, Guan Pinghuo Mingjin (Guan Yu's right arm is less powerful, Guan Ping is afraid of his father's old age), of course, except for special circumstances, such as Yu Mingjin recalled Pound. In short, Liu Bei recalled Zhang Fei twice, which shows that Zhang Fei did not take any advantage, and even did not blow or black, in this case, Zhang Fei's staying power is likely to be inferior to Ma Chao, Liu Bei is also a fierce general who has been in the battlefield for a long time (at least strong and second-rate), which should be able to be seen clearly.
Some people say that Liu Beimingjin is only out of concern for Zhang Fei, but thinking in reverse, why doesn't Ma Dai care about Ma Chao's safety? Why didn't Ma Dai have Mingjin?
After the two sides fought for another twenty or thirty times, "Ma Chao saw that he could not win Zhang Fei, cheated and lost, and secretly held the copper hammer in his hand", but the copper hammer was dodged by Zhang Fei, and then Zhang Fei immediately cheated and shot an arrow, which was also dodged by Ma Chao!
Some people say that Ma Chao was anxious and took the lead in cheating defeat, indicating that Ma Chao lost, which is obviously taken for granted. Fraud is a strategy when the military generals are single-handed, and the military generals of the same grade can be defrauded, such as Guan Yu's deception of Huang Zhong (dragging knife meter), Pound De's deception of Guan Yu (dragging knife meter + dark arrow), and different grades of military generals can also be deceived, such as Xiahou Yuan's deception of Yang Ren (dragging knife plan to kill), Cao Hong's deception of He Man (dragging knife plan to kill), Zhang Gao's deception against Lei Tong (back to the horse gun stabbing to death), are high-end to low-grade fraud, and Ma Dai has cheated Wei Yan, Zhang Fei (cold arrow shooting), is a low-grade to high-end fraud. In short, cheating is a head-to-head strategy, but it is not a failure at all!
Secondly, the reason why Ma Chao cheated and lost was indeed because he was anxious in his heart, it was because he had to win, if he couldn't take it down, he wouldn't be able to account to Zhang Lu and Yang Song, and he would be in a dilemma, and there would be almost no place for him!
In fact, Ma Chao is an archery master, once shot down dozens of people on the boat with a series of arrows in the Battle of the Wei River, if he did not throw a copper hammer, but shot a cold arrow, Zhang Fei in the case of poor visibility at night, may not be able to dodge, you know, not long before the Battle of Berkshire, Zhang Fei was shot in the helmet by Yan Yan in the daytime, almost lost his life. As for Zhang Fei's arrow, there was no threat to Ma Chao, because Ma Chao could not only listen to the wind detector (dodge the sneak attack from behind the forbidden one), but also use the gun to pull out the arrow rain and the dark crossbow, which was the ceiling level of the anti-arrow ability!
Some people also said that the purpose of Zhang Fei's battle was to capture Ma Chao alive, so there was no killing move, which may have been misled by the CCTV TV series, in fact, in the original work, after the night battle between the two sides, Liu Bei showed Zhuge Liang his intention to surrender Ma Chao, so in the battle between Zhang Fei and Ma Chao, both sides were full of strength and desperate!
Guan Yusheng captured Wang Zhong, Zhang Feisheng captured Liu Xian, Zhao Yunsheng captured Wu Yi, Ma Chaosheng captured Li Meng, huang Zhongsheng captured Xiahou Shang, all of which were super-first-class to third-rate, which was several grades behind, so would Zhang Fei have the luxury of capturing Ma Chao in the case of desperately fighting and unable to win? Isn't that whimsical!
In summary, we can roughly conclude that as far as the pre-war state is concerned, Zhang Fei is in an all-round advantage, with the fighting spirit and strength accumulated to the bloodline, while Ma Chao is tired and frustrated; as far as the single-handed situation is concerned, Zhang Fei takes off his helmet and fights, and Liu Bei twice tweets; as far as the night battle situation is concerned, both sides have dodged the dark weapon, but Ma Chao did not use a more lethal bow and arrow.
If the two sides are objectively and fairly scored, as far as the overall battle situation is concerned, if Ma Chao has 99 points, then Zhang Fei may only have 95-98 points.
<h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" data-track="84" > What is the development of force between Zhang Fei, Guan Yu, and Ma Chao? </h1>
Any fierce general, his strength value must go through multiple stages, roughly including the debut period, the rising period, the peak period, the decline period, the recession period, Zhang Fei, Guan Yu, and Ma Chao.
Let's look at Zhang Fei first. In the Battle of the Yellow Turban, Zhang Fei debuted, and then slowly escalated the fight against the monsters, during the Battle of Tiger Prison Pass and the Xuzhou Storm, Zhang Fei through many encounters with Lü Bu and many battles with the generals of Cao Ying, the force value showed a rapid increase, and even in the Battle of Xiaopei City, you can hard fight Lü Bu for more than 100 times without winning or losing, and then stab Ji Ling, and also be able to break through the encirclement of the Eight Tiger Generals of Cao Ying, during this period, Zhang Fei's force value reached its peak, and Zhang Fei at this time was roughly 33 years old.
However, after the Battle of Chibi, Zhang Fei was more than 40 years old, and his state declined, such as being unable to get out after being besieged by Zhang Ren and Wu Yi, and relying on Zhao Yun's assistance to reverse the war situation. At the time of the Battle of Ye Mengguan, Zhang Fei was already 48 years old, the peak period had long passed, and the decline in strength value was serious, so he was slightly powerless in front of Ma Chao; in another 4 years, Zhang Fei's martial arts began to decline, and even within 50 he could not take Zhang Gao.
Let's look at Guan Yu again. Guan Yu also made his debut in the Battle of the Yellow Turban, and gradually rose in many major battles such as the Battle of Dongdong, the Battle of Beihai, and xuzhou fengyun, and after Lü Bu's death, Guan Yu's self-confidence began to explode, and his strength value also reached its peak, such as when the siege of Xia Pi, he could fight to kill Xu Chu and Xu Huang' second generals. After getting the Red Rabbit Horse, Guan Yu's strength value increased by two to three percent again, reaching a super peak, the speed of the Red Rabbit Horse, the strength of the Green Dragon Sword, and his own martial arts, the perfect combination of the three, can suddenly slash Yan Liang, explode and slash three knives to curse Wen Ugly, and faintly have the divine power of Lü Bu's year. At this time, Guan Yu was 38 years old and in his prime.
However, after the Battle of Chibi, Guan Yu was already close to 50, and his strength had also declined significantly, such as fighting with Huang Zhong for 150, under the dual advantage of age (Guan Yu was 49 years old against Huang Zhong 64) and mounts, he did not have the upper hand at all, and he also relied on the deceitful dragging knife to seek fighters, and by the time of the Battle of Xiangfan, the 58-year-old Guan Yu had declined to a low point, so he was slightly overwhelmed in front of the prime-aged Pound, and finally he was shot by a dark arrow, almost falling to the altar.
Let's take another look at Ma Chao. Ma Chao debuted at the age of 17, double killed Wang Fang, Li Meng, but also a small gain, in the following ten years, Ma Chao's physical fitness, endurance, experience, marksmanship have gradually increased, in the Tongguan, Weishui six battles have been strengthened and improved, so in the Battle of Ye Mengguan reached the peak of force, at this time Ma Chao was 38 years old, is in the year of the fight.
From the peak of Zhang Fei, Guan Yu, and Ma Chao, the golden age of super martial artists is between 30-40 years old, during this period, whether it is physical strength, endurance, or skill, experience, they are in the peak state, but once they pass the hurdle of 40 years old, physical strength and endurance are a bit unable to keep up.
In addition, compared with Zhang Fei, Guan Yu's decline in force was more serious. After the Battle of Chibi, Zhang Fei also experienced a series of battles, such as the battle of Xu Chu, Zhang Liao, and Xu Huang, such as capturing Yan Yan and killing Zhang Ren in the Battle of Jinchuan, such as defeating Zhang Hao and severely injuring Xu Chu in the Battle of Hanzhong.
But Guan Yu has been sitting on the "cold bench", from the ancient city meeting, in 15 years, Guan Yu in addition to single out Huang Zhong, there was no performance of fighting, he settled in Jingzhou, not only busy with military affairs, but also married a wife and daughter, so the martial arts are even more unfamiliar!
Remarks: The age of the three people can be calculated at all stages, and this article will not be expanded into details.
Summary: During the Ye Mengguan period, Ma Chao was 38 years old, such as the peak of his prime, while Zhang Fei was already 48 years old, his strength had dropped significantly, and his endurance could not keep up, so he seemed inadequate. At this time, Guan Yu was already 53 years old, and his martial arts were seriously unfamiliar, and he had already reached a period of decline.
<h1 class="pgc-h-arrow-right" data-track="96" > Guan Yu vs Ma Chao, who is stronger in the end? </h1>
Guan Yu and Zhang Fei at the peak of their peak belonged to the "two males" after Lü Bu, basically between Bo Zhong, and should be slightly stronger than the peak Ma Chao. But during the 53-year-old recession period, Guan Yu, who met the 38-year-old peak Period Ma Chao, will definitely be overwhelmed!
1. Guan Yu's combat style will not pose a threat to Ma Chao.
As we all know, Guan Yu is arrogant, before the single challenge, never polite, do not answer, basically rush up to cut, this sudden attack of the combat style, so that many fierce generals are difficult to adapt (such as Hua Xiong, Yan Liang, Wen Ugly), especially after equipped with red rabbit horses, impact, lethality is stronger! For example, Wen Ugly, when chasing Xu Huang, was slashed three times by Guan Yu, who was randomly stabbed in the slash, and fled timidly, and then Yan Liang, when he wanted to ask questions, he was killed by a knife before he opened his mouth!
But Guan Yu's routine is definitely useless to Ma Chao. Ma Chao will not be short-circuited like Yan Liang, nor will he be as timid as Wen Ugly, but he is also prepared, and his force is superb, and it is absolutely easy to resist Guan Yu's rushing impact. In addition, the red rabbit horse is also close to the twilight age, and the old arms and legs have long since not had the impact of that year!
2. Large knife to long gun, there is a certain short board.
Guan Yu's biggest advantage lies in speed and strength. First of all, the speed advantage of the red rabbit horse no longer exists, and secondly, the strength advantage cannot be taken advantage of in front of Ma Chao, because Ma Chao's "tiger body wolf waist", the strength is not bad at all, and he can fight with Xu Chu's strength-type fierce general for more than 230 times, and finally he is not timid.
Since the strength can not occupy the advantage, then the weight of the Green Dragon Sword has become a disadvantage, because as the number of rounds of the single challenge increases, Guan Yu will inevitably consume more physical energy, and the follow-up endurance will definitely not be able to keep up, and the maximum number of rounds he can withstand is more than 100 rounds (refer to Zhan Huangzhong and Zhan Panda); and Ma Chao's marksmanship is no less than Zhao Yun and Zhang Fei, and does not rely too much on strength, but focuses more on skill and flexibility, so after a long time of single challenge, he can still calmly cope, such as in the Battle of Tongguan, Ma Chao has been at ease from beginning to end Xu Chu also had to unload his armor and fight, and later even abandoned the sword to the ground, and the knife technique was obviously chaotic.
3. The identity and mentality of the two are different.
At this time, Guan Yu belonged to the deputy general manager of the group (equivalent to the princes of one side) who was guarding Dazhou, and at this time, Ma Chao's wife and children had long been killed, and the former Xiliang troops had long been crushed, and they were already alone and had no worries. That is to say, if the two are desperate, the mentality is completely different.
Zhang Fei's bloody fight for Lü Bu and Xu Chu's blood fight for Ma Chao are all similar situations. Zhang Fei was a single stick and Liu Bei's younger brother, but Lü Bu was a prince who held Xuzhou in his hands, and there were beautiful wives and concubines at home; Xu Chu was a bodyguard of Tie Xian and Cao Cao, but Ma Chao was a prince with tens of thousands of troops, and he was carrying a deep vengeance in the sea of blood, so Lü Bu lacked the courage to exchange his life for his life in front of Zhang Fei and Ma Chao in front of Xu Chu, and even the risk of injury could not bear, so they were fighting cautiously and cautiously to ensure their own safety.
And Guan Yu was entangled by Pound and desperately, which is also the truth, Guan Ping once gave a pertinent evaluation, "You can't be heavy with Taishan, and compete with the stubborn stone"!
In short, Ma Chao can offset the other party's life, but Guan Yu has some scruples and even is overstretched.
Conclusion 1: In terms of prerequisites, Guan Yu's age is at a significant disadvantage, and it is the peak period of dealing with Ma Chao in the recession period; in terms of combat skills, Guan Yu's running routine will not pose a threat to Ma Chao, but the physical exertion is relatively greater, and the durability is obviously not as good as Ma Chao; in terms of identity and mentality, Guan Yu does not have the courage to fight desperately.
Conclusion 2: If Guan Yu rushes to Ye MengGuan to challenge Ma Chao, it is likely that he will be weak after more than 100 combinations; if Ma Chao fights with might, Guan Yu may not be able to survive the 200 rounds and will be obviously defeated; if Ma Chao uses deception and supplemented by archery, then Guan Yu, who has the worst arrow defense ability, will be difficult to bear, and the consequences are unimaginable!