The relationship between the two parties broke down before receiving the certificate
Can the bride price given by the man be refunded?
Yesterday (30 April)
Related topic #Before the woman receives the certificate
found out that her boyfriend was cheating and broke up, and refused to return the bride price#
rushed to the hot search and attracted attention
Before receiving the certificate, the woman refused to return the bride price due to the man's fault and the marriage
"Why did you freeze my daughter's bank card? It was the man's fault that he wanted us to return the bride price? On April 18, at the Executive Bureau of the People's Court of Xinyuan County, Xinjiang, Zhang Liang (pseudonym), the father of the bride-to-be, said emotionally. The next day, the judge successfully concluded the marriage property dispute case.
In 2016, Yanzi (pseudonym) and Da Fei (pseudonym) met and fell in love while working outside, and then lived together.
On February 8, 2022, the two parties returned to Yanzi's house to hold an engagement ceremony, and Dafei's father Wang Gang (pseudonym) gave Yanzi a bride price of 48,000 yuan and gold and silver jewelry worth 7,033.5 yuan, totaling about 55,000 yuan.
At the engagement ceremony, Yanzi promised to get married with Da Fei on February 22. Later, due to the breakdown of the relationship between the two parties, the marriage fell apart.
On October 31, 2023, Da Fei and his father Wang Gang sued Yanzi and his father Zhang Liang to the Xinyuan County People's Court, requesting the return of the bride price and gold and silver jewelry.
On January 29, 2024, considering the impact of the common life experience on the woman, the Xinyuan County Court determined that Yanzi and her father Zhang Liang should return the majority of the bride price of 38,523.45 yuan (i.e. 70% of the amount of the bride price and jewelry) within 10 days from the effective date of the judgment.
After the judgment took effect, because Yanzi and his father did not return the bride price, on April 8, Da Fei and his father Wang Gang applied to the court for compulsory enforcement.
After entering the enforcement procedure, the enforcement cadres and police took into account the particularity of the property dispute in the marriage contract, and decided to adopt the pre-enforcement mediation model to resolve the dispute in line with the principle of mediation giving priority and the case being concluded. The mediation team patiently did ideological work for Yanzi and her father Zhang Liang, combining the rigidity of legal authority with the flexibility of humanistic feelings, informing them of the legal consequences of refusing to perform effective judgments and rulings, and at the same time explaining the adverse effects of being included in the list of dishonest judgment defaulters, restricting high consumption, and judicial detention.
In the end, after the judge handling the case repeatedly explained the law and reasoned, Yanzi and his father Zhang Liang returned more than 38,000 yuan in dowry.
Netizens are hotly discussed
Netizens in the comment area were indignant
Some think
Fortunately, the problem was found before the certificate was obtained
Timely stop-loss is a good thing
Others think
The Court's decision was reasonable
Combine the facts of the case
Only 70% of the bride price is required to be refunded by the woman
There are also people who ask for a bride price of 48,000
Discussion: "Too little"
"The amount of the bride price must be seen in combination with local customs"
……
What do you think about this?
Welcome to the comment area to express your views~
END
Source: 19th Floor, Weibo Hot Search, Rule of Law Daily, People's Daily Online, News Network, China Law Popularization, Jiemian News, Southern Metropolis Daily, Netizen Comments, etc
Editor: Lady W
Dots to share