I. Preface
There is an old Chinese saying that once you make a mistake, you will be hated for eternity, which means that once you make some serious mistakes, you may become a lifelong regret.
This gave rise to a term for a certain group: "stumbling women", which refers to women who, because of the difficulties of life, have to go astray and use sexual relations in exchange for money as a means of earning a living.
The hero of today's story is a "lost woman", and the place where she usually trades is actually where her boyfriend works.
Unfortunately, she really "stumbled" because of an accident and died from a high fall.
This woman is really unlucky, what is going on?
Second, the "lost woman" accidentally lost her foot
Recently, a claim for the death of a woman who lost her foot occurred in Pengshui County, Chongqing City, which caused a stir on the Internet and aroused widespread concern in the society.
According to the verdict, the boss, Xiao, runs a hotel in Pengshui County, Chongqing City.
Shi, the protagonist of the story, was still unmarried at the time, and her boyfriend Xie worked in Xiao's hotel.
I don't know whose whim, the woman Shi actually took advantage of the convenience of this hotel to take the opportunity to engage in prostitution activities in the hotel.
The first time I saw this plot, I was very surprised, the woman actually prostituted herself where her boyfriend worked?
Can this man and woman still tolerate such a large-scale thing, is this still a normal couple relationship?
What kind of boyfriend would help his girlfriend in prostitution?
It can be said that such a boyfriend has no sense of responsibility, and such a girlfriend has no shame!
The hotel owner Xiao is of course unprofitable, he often introduces prostitutes to Shi, and also collects 50 yuan as a commission from Shi's illegal income of 150 yuan each time.
The boss of the 50 yuan also received peace of mind, on the one hand, he provided a trading place, on the other hand, he was also responsible for ventilating the message to ensure the safety of the transaction.
One day in February 2023, the boss Xiao informed Shi again that he would engage in prostitution activities in a hotel.
Unexpectedly, an accident happened in this transaction.
While Shi was serving, Xiao suddenly discovered an abnormal situation.
He had a hunch that his worst fears were about to happen, as the police arrived and were doing rounds in a nearby room.
Xiao was in a panic, but he didn't lose his mind, and he hurriedly called Shi to report the news.
After receiving the news, the client quickly went downstairs and left.
And Shi may think that the hotel is a safe place for her long-term transaction, or she is worried that she will have nowhere to go in the short term.
Instead of going downstairs to leave, she walked up to the roof of the hotel alone so that she could hide from the police for a while.
What everyone didn't expect happened, 5 days later, her boyfriend Xie was in the drainage ditch of the hotel and finally found Shi, who had been dead for a long time.
In the panic, her boyfriend finally woke up and had a big incident and had to choose to call the police.
Whether this boyfriend has a sense of responsibility or not, the reaction here is the most telling.
My girlfriend has been missing for five days, and my boyfriend and the hotel owner didn't choose to call the police.
Don't say that you are a thief with a weak heart, and you are afraid that you will report prostitution to the police.
What time is it? It's a big matter of human life.
The woman Shi relied on her own body to make money, but she met such a superb boyfriend and boss.
Shi is so pitiful.
Afterwards, Shi's parents and the boss Xiao reached an agreement after mediation, and Xiao paid 60,000 yuan for the funeral.
Xiao was sentenced to 6 months in prison and fined 2,000 yuan for the crime of procuring prostitution, and confiscated 100 yuan of illegal gains.
Shi's family believes that Xiao invited Shi to the hotel to engage in illegal activities, and suddenly notified Shi to escape at the time of the incident, which were the main reasons for the tragedy.
Moreover, Shi Mou's whereabouts were unknown for a few days after the incident, and Xiao, as the owner of the hotel, did not call the police in time to deal with it, and there were also potential safety hazards on the roof of the hotel.
These are indirect reasons for the tragedy.
Therefore, the family filed a lawsuit with the court, demanding that Xiao and the hotel involved be compensated for death compensation and spiritual solace totaling 1.51 million yuan.
The family's mood is completely understandable, a good daughter lost her life because she was introduced by Xiao to a lost girl, and because of Xiao's whistleblowing.
However, after trial, the court held that Shi went to the hotel to engage in illegal activities, which was Shi's subjective will, and this kind of behavior was essentially illegal and was not protected by law.
Moreover, the misstep and fall occurred in the process of evading law enforcement, because she was in a panic.
Going to the rooftop and the location of hiding are Shi's own subjective choices, and the direct cause of the fall also lies in Shi himself.
In addition, there is insufficient evidence to prove that the hotel was obviously negligent in its safety management.
In the end, the court rejected Shi's family's claim for compensation in the second instance.
3. The verdict has aroused strong controversy
Many people generally believe that the hotel owner Xiao provided a place for the crime, and the misstep incident also occurred in the hotel.
Regardless of whether the compensation of 1.51 million yuan proposed by the family is reasonable, Xiao should bear the responsibility for compensation, which is a sure thing.
Unexpectedly, after the second instance of the court, Xiao was able to retreat with his whole body, which was really unexpected.
Regarding whether the hotel is at fault and whether compensation should be made, the comment area has set off a strong debate:
First of all, the hotel is definitely responsible.
The place of the crime was provided by the hotel, and the accident occurred in the hotel.
150 yuan of illegal gains, the hotel will charge 50 yuan, if this is not responsible, the background of the hotel is too hard.
Drinking and dying together, the people involved still have debts, and they all work together to make money, isn't there a responsibility?
If you don't catch both parties, you will share the money, and if you catch the boss, you will push the responsibility, such a boss is too hateful, how can there be a good thing in the world that just collects money and does not take responsibility?
The hotel is so indifferent! It has not fulfilled its responsibilities at all, and people have been missing for five days, so why don't they call the police?
If you call the police early and look for it early, you may not miss the opportunity for emergency treatment, which is a serious inaction!
A weak woman who was found five days after she fell to her death for the sake of murder, had no power, no power, and no background, is really unjust and pitiful! This case should be investigated deeply!
Another voice, however, believes that the hotel is not at fault.
Is the family being crazy for money, and they still have the face to sue others? If their own responsibility leads to a misstep and a fall to their death, where can they blame others?
The unlawful partnership between the woman and the hotel is an illegal activity, and this kind of illegal interest is certainly not protected by law.
Xiao, the boss of the family, has reached an agreement with his family to compensate 60,000 yuan for funeral expenses, which is equivalent to saying that the civil part has been reconciled with Xiao.
The court can only make a separate judgment according to Xiao's illegal acts, and it is impossible to overturn the fact of civil mediation, and there is no problem with the court's judgment!
Appropriate humanitarian reparations are a balance between law and reason.
However, such a transaction is clearly unjust enrichment, which is certainly neither lawful nor reasonable, and the court judgment is very fair.
Fourth, the conclusion of the case
After analyzing this case, I believe that many people have mixed tastes and have very complicated feelings.
It is a fact that the woman who has lost her foot has violated the law and morality by committing illegal acts.
It is also a fact that the police have investigated and dealt with and severely cracked down on them in accordance with the law, which is a legitimate performance of their duties.
But thinking of Lai's personal experience, because of avoiding ward rounds, he accidentally fell high, so he lost his life and lost his youth, which is really pitiful and regrettable.
Disgraceful behavior not only disgraced oneself, but also lost one's life.
It also made the family endure grief, and even couldn't raise their heads in front of everyone.
In order to make some money, this lesson is too painful and profound.
The case teaches us,
Whether it's prostitution or prostitution,
As long as there is a violation of the law first, and the accident or even death caused by it,
All the consequences and responsibilities can only be resisted by oneself.
I believe that this is something that many people have never thought of, and we must take it as a warning and raise our awareness of the law.
The incident also reminds us that we must be kind-hearted and never go astray and do illegal and criminal things.
In life, when encountering danger, we must remain calm and do not act blindly, so as not to cause unnecessary disasters.
If Lai doesn't go astray to be a stumbling girl, there are rules to follow and laws to follow when everything happens during work.
If the hotel owner is not mercenary, he will not illegally allow a woman to engage in prostitution.
Then, the boss would not have been sentenced to a prison sentence, and the tragedy of poor Lai would have been spared.
It's a pity that there is no regret medicine in the world!
May the deceased rest in peace and be a law-abiding person in the next life!
#重庆头条#
#重庆一卖淫女坠亡家属起诉宾馆索赔被驳回#