A few years ago, there was a "help or not", and this year there was a "let not let go", now is the old man relying on the old and selling the old or the young man is ignorant?
Not long ago, young people were angrily criticized by the old people for hanging curtains under the sleeper berths of the train, and they thought that the lower berth of the train during the day was a public area, and everyone had the right to sit.
Young people, on the other hand, believe that they buy their own tickets and that all the decisions are up to them. With the public opinion making a big noise, netizens stood in line with the old man and caused heated discussions, and the customer service of the Railway Bureau turned things around!
Is the lower bunk a common area?
Everyone must have experienced giving up their seats on the bus, and they all say that young people give up their seats to older people to embody the traditional Chinese virtues, but with the promotion of this behavior, "giving up seats" has gradually changed its taste.
There are many old people who do not enjoy giving up their seats at the same time, they will insist that young people give up their seats, if they refuse, it may be the abuse of the old people, and more serious is to beat people.
This kind of thing is endlessly popping up on the Internet, some people think that this is the fault of the elderly, and think that the old man has become bad, and it is the love to give up the seat, and it is the duty not to let go, because everyone spends the same money, but there are also people who hold the opposite opinion, thinking that the young man should give up his seat.
Obviously this is a very controversial topic, no, this kind of thing gradually extends to the train, on April 14 on a train, because of the long distance, two young people specially bought a sleeper for the convenience of rest.
After finding a place, in order to create a private space for themselves and to avoid some noise, the two young men took out the bed curtain from their bags and hung it on the lower bunk.
It seems to be a very ordinary thing, but the accident happened that it was on the train at the time, which made an old lady who was sitting on the ground very annoyed, she picked up her mobile phone and made a video of a meal at them, arguing while recording.
I saw her shouting loudly, "Look at these young people, there are curtains on the car, so that the elderly in their 70s will not be allowed to sit", although there is no one in sight, but her tone can clearly feel that her anger is full, and she scoffs at this behavior.
Then she posted the recorded video on the Internet, asking everyone to condemn these young people, at first glance it seems that the old lady is very reasonable, after all, letting an old man in his seventies stand violates the virtue of "respecting the old and loving the young".
Unsurprisingly, when the public saw this video, they all felt that it was wrong with young people, and even came up with the sentence "The lower bunk during the day belongs to public seats", which is really shocking and endless, and there was a lot of heated discussions on the Internet for a while.
So who is right and who is wrong in this matter?
Netizens have their own opinions
Netizens said that the young people's practices are too extreme, and they feel that the young people have become bad now, and the train is not a once, but this kind of thing is the first time to see, these young people are too selfish, and they are the masters who will not give up their seats to the elderly on the bus.
There are also people who think that these young people should be allowed to sleep at night, and they should be allowed out in broad daylight, so it is difficult to let the people on the upper bunk nest on it for dozens of hours, it is really morally corrupt!
They said that they were not allowed to sit on the train, and when they saw older people, they would provide them with their sleepers and sleep on the ground, and they had to say that there was no one to do this kind of practice.
Some people even moved out of the so-called "international practice", which means that the seats in the lower berth of the train during the day are public areas, and passengers in the upper, middle and lower berths have the right to seating, and only sleeping at night can be divided into private areas.
This statement has also attracted some people to disagree, let's first say that this bunk is bought by people, natural people have the right to decide whether to let them sit, and the sleeper is more expensive than the ticket price of the hard seat, how much to spend more money to choose the lower berth is to provide convenience for themselves.
Therefore, some netizens on the Internet are also on the side of young people, they think that the old lady is purely moral kidnapping, and the entire sleeper is bought by others, why do you have to let others sit to be right, it is not who posts the video who is reasonable.
There are also people who say that young people pursue private space, and the tickets are also bought by themselves, and it is not wrong to hang a curtain, you see that Ma Yun is so rich, has he ever given a penny to a beggar, everyone has their own choice, why force it on others.
Some people also think that the 70-year-old lady taking random photos of others with her mobile phone without their consent is a sign of disrespect for others and feels that it violates people's privacy.
Some people even joked that I couldn't get used to seeing such behavior, I wouldn't hang curtains before, but I had to hang them in the future.
Seeing that public opinion is falling on both sides, each has its own reason, and the 12306 customer service did not sit idly by and responded publicly.
Customer service response
This video was spread very popular on the Internet, and the 12306 official also noticed it, so he quickly responded and replied, there is no explicit provision that the fence cannot be used, as long as it does not affect other passengers, it can be used.
Although it is not pointed out who is right and who is wrong, but people with a discerning eye understand that this means that it can be hung, so it seems that it is not that young people are ignorant, but that the old lady is a little unreasonable.
In fact, as early as 2023, there was a discussion about "whether the sleeper can sit", and the 12306 customer service said that the right to use the lower berth is limited to ticket-buying passengers, which means that if people let you sit, you can sit, if they don't agree, you have to respect people's wishes.
Perhaps in the eyes of most people, hanging curtains is hindering the rest of the elderly, but imagine if everyone sits casually, what is the point of buying a sleeper?
However, ushering in such a scene may be the escalation of the conflict caused by the old lady without friendly negotiation, and it is not the first time that such a thing has happened before, but things have a perfect ending.
There are no seats, there are seats
In 2013, a woman took an octogenarian to take a train from Chengdu to Zhengzhou, because the time was too urgent to buy a ticket in the carriage and was almost squeezed out, when two Henan guys saw this situation, they immediately gave up their sleepers, this way 24 hours, they were willing to stand all the way.
Seeing this, the flight attendant also gave out his lounge to these two Henan guys, and this scene of "serial shop" moved the people in the entire carriage and praised the Henan people.
In 2023, the K1178 train was forced to stall in the city along the river due to heavy rainfall during the operation, and the passengers on the middle train were trapped for 72 hours before they were rescued.
During this period, the tourists on the bus kept calling home for help, due to the heavy rain overnight caused the interruption of communication facilities in many places, it was impossible to keep in touch with the outside world for a short time, at this time, the power supply in the car has always been maintained, the air conditioning has been running, and the crew on the car has also been constantly reassuring the passengers.
During the break, considering that there were many passengers on the train who had bought standing tickets, all the men in the 2nd carriage stood up and took the initiative to give up their seats, and they lay down on the ground to rest.
When someone in the car caught a cold and was sick, the whole car was also actively helping each other, and did not compete with each other when they got the supplies, but enjoyed it first with the old and young women, which still touched countless people until now.
Looking at the fact that young people and old people are arguing endlessly for the sake of pulling the curtains on the train and not giving up their seats, I don't know why today's society has become like this, which is worth pondering.
The author thinks
It is right to carry forward the traditional virtues, but in the early stage, we must first respect people, you let me be a foot, I let you be a foot, only by helping each other can this society become better and better, let us work together to create a harmonious society.
Resources:
The surging news--The aunt complained about the young man's sleeper hanging curtains, and netizens fried the pot!12306 responded to →
http://baijiyahao.baidu.com/s?id=1796490709354605949&dfr=spider&for=pc
Guangming Net--The train sleeper hangs the curtain and others have no place to sit?12306 responded
hatps://baijiyahaao.baidu.com/s?id=1796486334050390262&dfr=spider&for=pc
China.com--Rights and Respect Cause Heated Discussions!Auntie complains that young people are not allowed to sit on the sleeper curtain (3)
Hatpas://news.china.com/sokialg/10000169/20240415/46373098_2.html
China.com -- Young people hung curtains in train sleepers, causing controversy, and the conductor said it was not a violation
Hatpas://news.china.com/sokialg/10000169/20240416/46379765.html
Volkswagen -- The octogenarian was given up his seat to the sleeper by train and finally slept in the crew lounge
http://kingdo.tj.com/sinwan/chinnas/201303/T20130313_8107973.html
Guangming.com--K1178 train witnesses recalled: The male passenger took the initiative to give up his seat and lay on the floor
hatps://baijiyahao.baidu.com/s?id=1773252809698961776&dfr=spider&for=pc