The hottest variety show during this time is "Brother With Thorns".
From the beginning when the audience did not believe in the guest lineup that could be invited to the Internet, to the fact that these senior celebrities full of childhood memories really came, and then to the various "memories killing songs" sung again, the audience completely fell, which is the variety show we want to watch.
The "first stage" of the brothers makes people see the blood boiling, so that everyone is a little too much looking forward to the brothers' "one public stage".
However, from an objective point of view, the "one public stage" is destined not to surpass the "first stage".
After all, the brothers can't continue to sing their famous songs in "Yigong", but the audience wants to hear those.
To be honest, if you can choose some familiar old songs when you choose songs every time you perform.
Maybe it can also meet the expectations of the audience.
Once the audience has not heard the selected song, the audience is bound to be disappointed.
"The Brother Who Cuts Through the Thorns" and "Sister Lang" are still different.
Many of the brothers of this show have been extremely popular, and they all have their own popular masterpieces.
In contrast, the sisters' backgrounds and glory are obviously very different.
Whether it is beyond band, Black Panther band, or Chen Xiaochun, Lin Zhixuan, Hu Haiquan, many of their songs are now often taken out and sung.
And as long as everyone goes to KTV, they basically sing the songs of these people.
There is already a stereotype in the minds of the audience.
These brothers seem to be able to sing their own songs, and they can only perform their own famous works.
If they were to cover the current Internet celebrity songs, the audience would feel very low.
Of course, the brothers are not unable to sing other people's songs.
It's just that they need to sing the same classic or more classic songs for the audience to buy in.
Simply put, the audience will always like to "compare upwards".
For the two seasons of "Sister Lang", most of the sisters have no representative works in the eyes of the audience.
It can even be said that the audience has no idea that the sisters can sing and dance.
Then, the sisters only need to sing and dance casually, even if it is "upward comparison", the audience can have surprises.
"Brother With Thorns" and "Sister Riding the Wind and Waves" seem to be the same type of variety show.
But there is a big difference between the two, and the sisters need to choose "classic songs" to add points to themselves.
The brothers belong to the kind of "classics" that the sisters are looking for, and their works are taken out and sung by others.
Given that the audience has different mentalities towards "brother" and "sister".
The songs sung by the brothers "Yigong" were obviously not enough to impress the audience.
Unless the brothers cover the classic songs of the level of the four kings on the stage, the audience's hearts will always have a gap.
From the above analysis, it can be concluded that "Brother with Thorns" is destined to go high and low.
In addition, the script of this show is obvious, and the ticket control of the program group is even more embarrassing.
After the brothers' "one public performance" was all over, the brothers received the following audience votes.
Of course, this is not the final vote, because the program team wants to create suspense, and the votes of several brothers will not be announced until the next issue.
Let's briefly analyze it, according to the audience's vote, Lin Zhixuan's tribe is quite backward.
However, the final result of the competition was that the Lin Zhixuan tribe won the third place.
Because they gained a 250 firepower bonus for the Scalding Force Regiment.
Let's talk about this hot force group first.
After the eight tribes show, the Hot Force group will each choose three tribes.
The top five tribes will receive firepower bonuses of 300, 250, 200, 150, and 100, respectively.
I believe that everyone can also see that the vote of the hot force group is actually the most critical.
In contrast, the vote of 1,000 spectators on the spot was simply a cutscene.
Because 1,000 spectators each had 3 votes, divided into eight tribes, the average was less than 400 votes.
If you are voted first by the Hot Force Group, you can directly get 300 votes.
To put it bluntly, it seems that the brothers' final vote is composed of two parts, but it is actually quite easy to control.
The program group only needs to control the vote of the hot force group, and the ranking of the eight tribes can basically be completely controlled.
So, is this hot force group easy to control?
Just take a look at this lineup.
There were only ten people in the Boiling Force Regiment.
Compared with the 1,000 spectators on the scene, do you think it is good to control?
The program team designed such a team of ten people, their power is much greater than 1,000 viewers, is this really not a script arrangement?
The program team designed this "hot force group", and their explanation to the audience was to make voting more professional.
Because the program team introduced the team and said that they were all professionals.
So, can these people really be called professionals? Let's analyze it briefly.
The first professional to cut to the camera is Shen Yifei.
This expert is positioned as an "expert in sociology".
In Mango's recently launched divorce reality show, "Goodbye Lover".
Shen Yifei, a sociology expert, is also a guest of observation.
In each episode of the show, Shen Yifei's comments on the three couples can be pointed every time, which can be said to be quite accurate.
Shen Yifei's performance in "Goodbye Lover" is definitely quite a fan.
After each of her explanations, the audience can suddenly open up, and everyone's hearts have also opened up a lot.
However, does a "sociological expert" like Shen Yifei really know how to sing and dance?
Next is Li Xiaomeng, an "education expert".
Isn't it a joke that the program team asked an "education expert" to comment on the brothers who sang better?
"Guangming Daily client" Zhang Jinjin.
In addition to the three close-ups given by the camera, let's talk about the titles of the other seven.
Zhan Zhiyan of "New Weekly", Zhang Yuehan of "Sanlian Life Weekly", Liu Huan of "China News Weekly", Cui Guannan of "Xinhua Net", Zhang Yue of "Photographer", You Xiaogang of "National First-class Director", and Wu Bofan, "Commercial Culture Critic".
Of the ten "professionals," there are five media workers.
This is still more understood by the audience, after all, they can help the show to promote and promote.
The rest of the audience of "photographers", "social experts", "national-level directors", and "education experts" is incomprehensible.
Of course, we are not saying to deny these experts, but we just think that their professionalism is really not related to singing and dancing appreciation!
Even if the program team hires some music teachers, at least the audience's heart will think that these people are really professional.
The program team invited these "experts" to vote for the brothers' singing.
It's like finding an emotional expert to order a selection show and a singer to comment on the acting skills.
They are definitely the top two seniors in their own fields, but in other fields, they are really not so convincing to the audience.
Let's go back to the votes of Lin Zhixuan's tribe.
If it is according to the results of the audience vote, they are undoubtedly the last three, but because of the expert support of the hot force group, they have achieved a good result of third place.
The show "Brother With Thorns" is the benchmark for "Sister Lang".
At that time, after the broadcast of "Sister Lang", everyone voted for each live audience.
To be honest, everyone felt that the voting of the live audience was not professional enough.
Perhaps the program team also heard the audience's complaints, so they added "professional judges" to the brothers' votes.
However, this "professional review" is definitely the biggest failure of "Brother Who Cut Through Thorns".
Compared with the audience voting of "Sister Lang", the audience this time has no sense of participation.
The audience did participate in the whole vote, and they could run the ticket after regretting it.
The audience seriously thinks about running tickets back and forth, afraid that because of their own poor consideration, the brothers will have fewer tickets.
But then again, the audience is actively involved, and the result?
The percentage of the audience's vote is so low that they simply can't control the ranking of each tribe.
What really had an impact on the brothers was the high votes of the ten "professional judges".
In the final analysis, to put it bluntly, the program team is controlling the number of votes of each tribe.
No matter what kind of variety show it is, the final audience is always the audience.
Even if the judges are professional, their advice can convince everyone.
But the audience's eventual liking doesn't change much.
The audience of Lin Zhixuan's tribe voted so low, but in the end, they completed the counterattack with the vote of the hot force group.
This is not only disrespectful to the live audience, but also disgusting the audience in front of the TV.
In the training process of Yigong, the contradiction between Lin Zhixuan and Li Xiang can be said to be boiling over.
In this controversy, the audience is more supportive of Li Xiang.
Although the final result is that Li Xiang and Liu Jia are assigned a few lyrics, their main duty is to accompany the dance.
Lin Zhixuan's tribe seems to have finally reached an agreement, but in fact, Lin Zhixuan still has the upper hand.
In the eyes of the audience, the final stage presented is Lin Zhixuan's main coffee, Li Xiang and Liu Jia accompanied by dance, and Li Yundi accompanied by Li Yundi.
This result is not wanted by the audience, because none of the four have broken through.
This performance may really be called a "work of art", but it is not suitable for the stage of "Brother With Thorns".
The audience voted very low, but to be fair, is this really not the voice of the audience in front of the TV?
However, the program team has to make a fuss about the number of votes that the audience feels are fair, and eventually makes the ranking unfair.
The show "Thorny Brother" has only been broadcast for a short time, but the audience's popularity has obviously decreased a lot.
The program team gave the brothers oil and let the brothers show their own handsomeness as much as possible, which was really amazing.
But from the perspective of song selection and voting rules, this show is destined to go high and low.
Of course, it is not impossible to keep this show popular until the end.
First, balance the voting weight of the "professional jury" and the "live audience".
The principle is to make this vote look fairer and more just.
Second, let the brothers choose their own songs.
Whether it is "Sister Lang" or "Brother Who Cuts Through Thorns", the program team has been spat upon in various ways in the selection of songs.
Of course, there are also some song copyright issues involved.
The program team can completely let the brothers choose their own songs.
For Lin Zhixuan, Chen Xiaochun, Huang Guanzhong and other seniors in the music industry, they all have their own connections.
To put it bluntly, they can take a lot of singers' classics to adapt when they say hello, and the program team does not need to worry about copyright issues.
For the age of these brothers, the tracks they choose must also be those classic songs.
These songs are exactly the playlists that the audience wants to listen to, how can they not be hot?
I hope that the program team can make changes as soon as possible, and do not let such a good show go high and low, otherwise it is really a waste of this luxurious guest lineup.